AI Comparison Tools: How to Compare AI Models and Apps
Short answer Use public leaderboards like Arena and Artificial Analysis to narrow the field to two or three AI apps, then decide with your own blind test on real tasks. Rankings average strangers' prompts, not your work. Before you pay, check the plan's privacy terms: several personal plans may train on your chats unless you opt out.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow do you compare AI models and apps?
Work in three passes. Public rankings shortlist, your own test picks the winner, and the plan's terms pick which plan to buy.
| Tool | What it compares | What it can't tell you |
|---|---|---|
| Arena (arena.ai) | Chat models, ranked by people voting on two anonymous answers | How a model handles your customers, your trade or your files |
| Artificial Analysis (artificialanalysis.ai) | Models on a set of test questions, plus speed and price per use through a developer account (the API) | What a monthly app plan includes, or its usage limits |
| Each vendor's pricing and privacy pages | Plan features, usage limits, whether your chats train the model | Quality |
| Your own blind test | Which answer your team would actually send | Nothing a ranking can replace |
A model is the engine (GPT, Claude, Gemini). An app is the product you log into (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Microsoft Copilot), with its own limits, tools and privacy rules. Two apps can run the same model and still differ in what they let you do. Microsoft, for example, offers Anthropic and OpenAI models inside its work Copilot, and an admin decides whether to switch them on, per Microsoft Learn.
What do AI leaderboards actually measure?
Arena shows you two answers from unnamed models and asks which is better. Your vote counts only while the names are hidden:
"Only votes made while the models are anonymous count toward official rankings." (Arena FAQ)
Votes feed a Bradley-Terry rating, a scoring method for head-to-head matchups, much like chess ratings, says Arena's FAQ. Its Side by Side mode lets you pick two named models and compare them on your own prompt, but those votes stay out of the public rankings.
Artificial Analysis runs its own tests and publishes an Intelligence Index, a weighted score across knowledge work, coding, science and general questions, each weighted 25%, per its methodology page. It is honest about the limit:
"Like all evaluation metrics, it has limitations and may not apply directly to every use case." (Artificial Analysis)
The same page says the index is mostly text and English. Its prices are what providers charge developers per token (a small chunk of text), not what you pay for an app subscription.
Rankings can also be gamed. A 2025 study of Arena found that some AI companies tested many private versions and published only the best score; the authors (Singh et al., April 2025) wrote that picking the best score "leads to biased Arena scores." Treat a small gap between leaders as a tie.
How do I run my own AI comparison?
An hour of testing on your real work beats any ranking. Use each app's free plan where one exists.
- Pick three tasks you do every week: reply to a price question, draft a service page section, summarize last month's reviews.
- Write one prompt per task and paste the exact same prompt and file into each app.
- Copy the answers into one document labeled A, B and C, with the app names removed.
- Have the person who would send the work rank them, without knowing which is which.
- Check every fact, price and claim in each answer. Count the edits needed before it could go out.
| Score each answer on | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Facts right | Microsoft Learn says AI answers "aren't guaranteed to be 100% factual" |
| Edits needed | Fewer edits is the time you save |
| Sounds like you | Customers notice generic copy |
| Follows instructions | Length, format, what to leave out |
Don't paste customer names, health details or anything private into a test tool. Arena's FAQ says conversations may be shared in research datasets and with model makers, and it advises "avoiding including any sensitive information."
Which criteria matter when choosing an AI app for a business?
Quality is one row. For a small business, privacy and fit often decide.
| Criterion | What to check | Where it says so |
|---|---|---|
| Does it train on your chats? | ChatGPT's Free, Go, Plus and Pro plans show "Content is used to train our models", with an opt-out | ChatGPT pricing page |
| Claude's personal plans use chats for training only if you allow it in settings; its business plans don't by default | Anthropic Privacy Center | |
| Microsoft's work Copilot: prompts and responses "aren't used to train foundation LLMs" | Microsoft Learn | |
| Google Workspace: your data is not used for model training "outside your domain without permission" | Google Workspace AI privacy page | |
| Where your work lives | If your email and files are in Google Workspace or Microsoft 365, the built-in AI can read them; a separate app can't without connectors | Vendor pages above |
| Limits and ads | Free and cheap plans cap messages and uploads; ChatGPT's Go plan "may include ads" | ChatGPT pricing page |
| Claims you can check | "AI-powered" on a sales page proves nothing; ask for a free trial on your own task | FTC, September 2024 |
The FTC has acted against companies that overstate what their AI does. Its then-chair said in September 2024:
"Using AI tools to trick, mislead, or defraud people is illegal." (FTC, September 2024)
Is it different in Canada?
The tools and rankings are the same. The privacy duty is yours under Canadian law, whichever app you pick. Canada's federal, provincial and territorial privacy commissioners wrote that organizations "using generative AI are obligated to ensure that their activities comply with applicable privacy laws and regulations in Canada" (December 2023). So the training rows in the table above matter as much as quality.
Example
A plumbing company choosing a writing assistant
The owner shortlists the top three apps on Arena's text leaderboard. She runs the same three prompts (a quote follow-up, a water-heater page, a review reply) in each free plan. Her office manager picks app B blind in two of three tasks. Since customer emails will go in, she buys its business plan, which doesn't train on chats by default, not the personal one.
An accounting firm already on Microsoft 365
The firm's files and email are in Microsoft 365. Rather than add a new app, the partners test Copilot against one outside assistant on a client-letter draft. Copilot needs fewer edits because it can see last year's letter, and its prompts stay out of model training. They keep the outside app's free plan for public research only.
A bakery comparing image tools
Rankings won't answer the owner's real question: which one draws a cake that looks like hers. She uploads one product photo to two tools, asks for the same holiday post, and counts how many tries each needs. She keeps the one that needed fewer tries.
FAQ
Is there one website that compares every AI app?
No. Arena and Artificial Analysis compare models, not app plans. Plan limits, prices and privacy terms are only on each vendor's own pricing and privacy pages, and they change often.
Are AI leaderboards trustworthy?
They're a fair shortlist, not a verdict. Arena reflects strangers' prompts and preferences, and a 2025 study found companies could test private versions and publish their best score.
Do I need to pay to compare AI tools?
Usually not. ChatGPT lists a Free plan on its pricing page, and Arena lets you compare two named models on your own prompt. Pay only after your test shows a winner.
How often should I re-check my choice?
When a vendor launches a new model or changes plan terms, rerun your three-task test. It takes an hour and uses the same prompts.
Different for you?
- Choosing a model for each marketing job (ads, drafts, images): AI marketing models.
- Using a second AI to check the first: model-agnostic AI for SEO.
- Comparing AI search engines rather than assistants: best AI search engines.
- Patient or client health data in the prompt: is ChatGPT HIPAA compliant?.
- Comparing AI agents that do SEO work for you: AI SEO agent review checklist or see the SEO agent.