Broken link building: step by step with Ahrefs
Short answer Find a dead page that other sites still link to, publish a better page on the same topic, then email each linking site to suggest yours. In Ahrefs, the Broken backlinks and Broken links reports do the finding, but they need the Standard plan at $249 a month. A local business can do a small version free.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow broken link building works
It is three jobs: find a dead page with links, make a replacement, ask for the swap. A backlink is a link from another website to yours. When the page it points to disappears, the link breaks, and the site that placed it now sends readers to an error.
| Step | What you do | In Ahrefs | Free route |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Find | A dead page that other sites still link to | Broken backlinks, or Broken links (Standard plan) | Local resource pages plus a free crawler |
| 2. Rebuild | See what the dead page said, write your own better version | Not needed; use the Wayback Machine | Same |
| 3. Pitch | Email each linking site with your page as the fix | Export the list | A spreadsheet |
Steps 2 and 3 are the same with or without the tool. Ahrefs only speeds up step 1.
Which Ahrefs plan has the broken link reports?
Standard or higher. Ahrefs' own plan comparison lists Broken Backlinks, Broken links and Outgoing links among the Site Explorer reports Standard adds over Lite (Ahrefs Help: plan differences).
| Plan (November 2026) | Monthly price | Use for this job |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Your own verified site only; no competitor research |
| Starter | $29 | 250 rows per report, no exports, monthly only |
| Lite | $129 | No Broken links or Broken backlinks reports |
| Standard | $249 | Both reports, 30,000 rows per report |
Prices are from Ahrefs pricing, billed monthly, before tax; annual billing saves "up to 17%". Starter limits are from Ahrefs Help: Starter plan. Ahrefs prices in US dollars. The free account lets you use Site Explorer only "for verified websites", meaning sites you prove you own (Ahrefs Free).
For one campaign, a single month of Standard is the usual way in. For a local business doing this once or twice a year, the free route below is often enough.
Step 1: find dead pages that still have links
Ahrefs gives you two ways in. Both start in Site Explorer, as of its help pages in November 2026.
Way A: a competitor's dead pages. Enter a rival's domain, then open Backlinks profile > Broken backlinks. Ahrefs says it "shows all the referring pages that link to 404 pages of a target website" (Ahrefs Help: broken backlinks). Or open Pages > Best by links and add the filter "HTTP code: 404 not found". The dead pages with the most linking sites are your best targets, because one replacement page can be pitched to all of them.
Way B: one useful site's dead outgoing links. Enter a resource site in your field, such as an association or a city guide, then open Outgoing links > Broken links. Each dead link carries a red tag, usually "404 not found" or "cannot resolve host" (the whole domain is gone) (Ahrefs Help: broken outbound links). You can filter by link type and use Export at the top right.
Check before you pitch. Ahrefs warns that the report reflects when its crawler last visited the pages, not today (Ahrefs Help). Click each dead link yourself.
To rank the list, Ahrefs' Domain Rating (DR) helps. It is Ahrefs' own 0–100 score of a site's links "compared to the others in our database" (Ahrefs Help: DR), not a Google number. For a local business, a site in your town or trade usually beats a high score from an unrelated one.
The free route for a local business
Look for pages that list local businesses or useful links: a chamber of commerce member page, a city's "community resources" page, a school or homeowners' association "recommended vendors" list. Businesses close and change domains, so these lists rot.
Then check the page's links. Screaming Frog's SEO Spider is free for "up to 500 URLs at a time" (Screaming Frog user guide: General), and its External tab shows each outside link's response code (Screaming Frog user guide: Tabs). A 404 next to a closed competitor's old address is your opening. See Screaming Frog for owners for setup.
Step 2: rebuild the content
Find out what the dead page offered, then publish your own version that does the job better.
- Read the old page. Paste the dead address into the Wayback Machine at web.archive.org. Not every page is there; the Internet Archive says some sites were missed or "blocked by robots.txt" (Internet Archive Help).
- Ask why people linked to it. Was it a price guide, a checklist, a local permit explainer, a business that served their area? The linking pages' surrounding text tells you.
- Write your own. Use your prices, photos, process and local knowledge. Don't republish the archived text: it belongs to whoever wrote it, and Google asks whether content will "avoid simply copying or rewriting those sources, and instead provide substantial additional value and originality" (Google: helpful content).
If the dead link was a closed business on a vendor list, your "replacement" can simply be your service page, provided you serve the same area and work.
Step 3: pitch the replacement
Email the person who edits the page, keep it short, follow up once.
- Who: the author named on the page, or the site's editor or webmaster. A general inbox works for small sites.
- What to say: the page, the dead link, and your page as one option. For example: "Your Home Resources page links to Smith Heating, which closed. The link now shows an error. If you want a replacement, our furnace maintenance page covers the same area. Thanks either way."
- Pitch readers, not SEO. Google says a page that returns 404 "does not hurt you or count against you in Google's search results" (Google Search Central Blog, 2011). The real cost to them is annoyed visitors, so say that.
- Follow up once, about a week later, then stop.
- Offer nothing in return. Google's link spam examples include "Exchanging money for links" and "Exchanging goods or services for links" (Google: Spam policies). If they add nofollow to your link, that's their call and still within Google's rules.
The email rules differ by country:
- US: if the email promotes your business, CAN-SPAM can apply, and the FTC says "The law makes no exception for business-to-business email." Include "your valid physical postal address" and a clear way to opt out (FTC: CAN-SPAM guide).
- Canada: CASL treats consent as implied when the person "has conspicuously published" the address, with no statement refusing such mail, and the message is relevant to their "business, role, functions or duties" (CASL, section 10(9)(b)). An editor's posted address with a pitch about their page fits that pattern; a scraped personal address doesn't. See CASL consent.
Is broken link building worth it for a small business?
Sometimes. It pays when one dead page had many links and you can genuinely replace it. A national retailer or software company finds those often. A local plumber or dentist usually finds a handful, mostly on local lists, and each is worth one polite email.
Two cheaper jobs come first. Your own moved or deleted pages may have links pointing at errors. Google's advice for content that moved is to "301 redirect the old URL to the new URL" (Google Search Central Blog, 2011), and it treats a permanent redirect as a signal that the new page "should be canonical", the version shown in search (Google: Redirects). The free Ahrefs account shows "which sites and pages link to you" on your verified site (Ahrefs Free). After a redesign, see traffic dropped after a website redesign. Second, the relationship links in backlinks for a local business usually come easier than cold pitches.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
An HVAC company and a closed competitor (US dollars)
A rival heating company closed and its domain lapsed. On a free crawl of three local pages (the chamber directory, a homeowners' association vendor list, a realtor's "trusted pros" page), all three link to the dead domain. The owner emails each with his furnace service page. Two swap the link. Cost: $0 and an afternoon.
A home inspector buying one month of Standard (US dollars)
She pays $249, runs Broken backlinks on two national inspection sites, and finds a dead "pre-purchase inspection checklist" with links from 40 sites. She writes her own checklist from her reports, pitches all 40 and gets 3 links. She cancels after the month.
An accounting firm in Ontario (Canadian dollars)
A provincial small business association's resource page links to a dead tax-deadline calendar. The firm publishes its own calendar and emails the editor at the address posted on the page. No tool cost.
FAQ
Is broken link building white hat?
Yes, if you only suggest your page and offer nothing for the link. Paying, giving a free service or trading links for ranking is link spam under Google's policies.
Can I do broken link building without Ahrefs?
Yes. Find resource pages with Google searches, then check their links with a free crawler such as Screaming Frog (500 URLs per crawl). You lose Ahrefs' list of who links to a dead page.
Should I use Wikipedia dead links?
Only as a topic idea: a "dead link" tag shows a source that other sites may also have cited. Don't add your own site to Wikipedia. Its conflict of interest guideline says to "propose the edit on the article's talk page" instead.
How many sites will say yes?
No reliable public figure exists. Expect most emails to go unanswered, and pitch only where your page truly fits.
Different for you?
- You want links from people you already work with: backlinks for a local business.
- You'd rather crawl sites free: Screaming Frog for owners.
- Your own old pages now show errors: traffic dropped after a website redesign.
- You email Canadian businesses: CASL consent.
- You're weighing directory listings instead: local citations and directories.
- You'd rather have the prospecting and pitching done for you: SEO & GEO Agent.