ChatGPT prompts for SEO competitor analysis, using Google's rules
Short answer Paste your page and the top three ranking pages into ChatGPT, give it the criteria from Google's quality rater guidelines (effort, originality, accuracy, first-hand experience, trust), and ask for a side-by-side gap table. Then fix only what you can back with real facts. Raters don't change rankings, and ChatGPT's answers need checking.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow to use ChatGPT for SEO competitor analysis
Use it as a judge with a rulebook, not as a search tool. ChatGPT is good at reading two pages and saying what one has that the other lacks. It is bad at knowing who ranks, how much traffic anyone gets, or what Google rewards. So you bring the evidence and the rulebook; it does the comparing.
- Pick one search. The exact words a customer types, like "water heater replacement cost Denver".
- Collect the pages yourself. Search it on Google, note the top three results that are businesses like yours (skip directories), and copy the text of each page, plus your own.
- Paste, don't link. OpenAI says ChatGPT may fail to read a website "due to technical issues, paywalls or preferences set via robots.txt" (OpenAI Help Center: Does ChatGPT tell the truth?). Pasted text is what it actually compares.
- Give it Google's criteria (next section), then run the prompts below in one chat.
- Check every gap it names against the real pages before you change anything.
Finding which competitors and keywords to study in the first place is its own job: see how to reverse engineer SEO competitors.
What do Google's quality rater guidelines actually check?
They're the handbook for people Google pays to grade search results. The current version is dated September 11, 2025 (Google: Search Quality Rater Guidelines). Two things in it matter for this job.
First, raters don't rank pages. The guidelines say:
"No single rating can directly impact how a particular webpage, website, or result appears in Google Search, nor can it cause specific webpages, websites, or results to move up or down on the search results page." (Google: Search Quality Rater Guidelines)
Ratings measure whether Google's systems work. So the guidelines show what Google is aiming for, not a checklist that moves you up.
Second, the criteria. The guidelines judge the main content of a page by four things:
| Criterion | What raters look for | What it means for your page |
|---|---|---|
| Effort | "the extent to which a human being actively worked to create satisfying content" | Real photos, your own process, numbers you worked out |
| Originality | Content "not available on other websites" | Something the top three don't say |
| Talent or skill | Enough skill for "a satisfying experience" | Clear, correct, easy to use |
| Accuracy | Facts right; on health, money or safety topics, in line with expert consensus | Prices, rules and claims you can stand behind |
Then E-E-A-T: experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trust. If you've read about "E-A-T", that's out of date: Google added experience in December 2022 (Google Search Central Blog: E-A-T gets an extra E). Google says E-E-A-T "itself isn't a specific ranking factor" and that trust is the most important part (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content). Our E-E-A-T guide covers what it means for a small business site.
Don't ask ChatGPT to "use the rater guidelines" from memory. It may know an older version. Paste the criteria in.
Seven prompts for competitor gaps
Run them in order in one chat, so each builds on the last. Swap the brackets.
1. Set the rulebook. "You'll compare web pages the way Google's search quality raters judge them. Score main content on: effort (did a person clearly work to make it useful), originality (does it say things the other pages don't), skill (is it clear and easy to use), accuracy (are facts right, especially prices, laws and safety), and trust (who is behind it, can you contact them, does it show first-hand experience). Only use the pages I paste. If something isn't on a page, say 'not on page' instead of guessing."
2. Name the searcher's need. "The search is: [words]. Before reading any page, list what this person most likely wants, the 5 questions they need answered, and what would make them pick a business. Mark which questions are local."
3. Side-by-side gap table. "Here are 4 pages. Page A is mine. B, C and D rank above me. [Paste each, labeled.] Make a table: one row per question from step 2, one column per page, each cell 'answered', 'partly' or 'missing', quoting the line that answers it. Then one row each for effort, originality, accuracy and trust, with a one-line reason."
4. Find what only you can say. "List what B, C and D all say. That's table stakes, not an advantage. Then list what none of them show: real photos, prices, timelines, local details, worked examples, named people. Which of those could a business like mine supply from its own jobs? Don't invent any."
5. Trust check. "For each page, list how a stranger would know who wrote it and whether to trust it: author name, credentials, license number, address, phone, reviews, date updated. What does my page lack that the others show?"
6. Rank the fixes. "From everything above, list the 5 changes to my page most likely to help the searcher, biggest first. For each: what to add, which gap it closes, and what fact or material I must supply. Skip anything that would mean copying or rewording a competitor."
7. Turn it into an outline. "Rewrite my page's outline with those changes. Keep my facts. Where you need something only I know, write [ASK ME]."
For updating an existing page from this list, see refreshing content with AI. For keyword ideas, which ChatGPT is weaker at, see AI keyword research and its limits.
Check ChatGPT's answer before you act
ChatGPT's gap table is a lead, not a finding. Four checks:
- Is the gap real? OpenAI warns that ChatGPT "can produce incorrect or misleading outputs" and may sound confident when wrong (OpenAI Help Center: Does ChatGPT tell the truth?). Open each competitor page and confirm the thing it says is "missing" really is.
- Did it read the whole page? Long pages get skimmed. If a cell looks wrong, paste that page alone and ask again.
- Are you copying? The guidelines rate a page Lowest when almost all its content is "copied, paraphrased, embedded, auto or AI generated, or reposted from other sources" with little effort, originality or added value (Google: Search Quality Rater Guidelines). Closing a gap means adding your own answer, not rewording theirs.
- Are you scaling? Google's spam policy defines scaled content abuse as "when many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users" (Google Search Central: Spam policies). Running this on 50 city pages and publishing what comes out is that risk.
Google also says to fact-check all AI-generated content for accuracy before publishing (Google Search Central: Guidance on using generative AI content). The rater guidelines add that using AI "alone does not determine the level of effort" or quality: what you add does.
How do I know the changes worked?
Not from ChatGPT. It can't see your rankings. After you publish, give Google a few weeks, then compare the page's clicks, impressions and average position for that search in Search Console, before versus after. Our guide to the Search Console performance report shows how to set up the comparison.
Example
A plumber in Phoenix (US dollars)
The page for "tankless water heater install cost" sits on page two. The gap table shows all three rivals give a price range and a timeline; the plumber's page gives neither. Prompt 4 finds none of them shows real jobs. The owner adds a range from last year's 40 installs ($2,500–$5,000), a typical half-day timeline, and two photos with what each job cost. No rival wording used.
A bookkeeper in Calgary (Canadian dollars)
Prompt 5 shows every top page names its accountant and credential; the bookkeeper's page is signed "Our Team". She adds her name, CPA status and a short bio. Prompt 3 had also flagged a rival as "missing" GST filing deadlines; she checks and the rival does cover it in an FAQ. She drops that "gap".
A landscaper who wanted 30 suburb pages
He planned to run the prompts for each suburb and publish the outlines as pages. The scaled content policy stopped him. He wrote five pages instead, for the suburbs where he had real jobs, photos and local plant notes.
FAQ
Can ChatGPT find my competitors' keywords?
Not reliably. It has no ranking or volume data, only guesses from page text. Use Search Console or an SEO tool for keywords.
Is it legal to paste a competitor's page into ChatGPT?
Comparing a public page for analysis is common. Publishing their text, or a reworded version, risks copyright claims and Google's quality rules. Not legal advice.
Can ChatGPT tell if a competitor used AI?
No. OpenAI says ChatGPT "can't reliably determine whether text was AI-generated." And Google judges the content, not the tool used.
Which ChatGPT plan do I need?
Any plan can compare pasted text. OpenAI says web search is on by default, but sites can block it via robots.txt, so pasting is safer.
Different for you?
- You don't know who your real competitors are: start with reverse engineering SEO competitors.
- Health, legal or money topics: accuracy and credentials weigh more; read E-E-A-T for a small business.
- The gap is on dozens of old pages: see refreshing content with AI, or have the work done through /seo/.
- Your page ranks but nobody clicks: that's a title and snippet problem; read the Search Console performance report guide.