Checkout Optimization: Cut Friction and Cart Abandonment
Short answer Fix the reasons buyers name most. Show shipping, tax and fees before the last step. Let people buy without an account. Cut the form to the fields you need and turn on browser autofill. Add Apple Pay, Google Pay or PayPal. Keep card entry on your processor's hosted fields. Then measure each checkout step to see which fix worked.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callCheckout optimization: what to fix first
Start with the problems shoppers themselves name. Baymard Institute asked US online shoppers why they quit a checkout. Leaving out people who were only browsing, these were the top answers (Baymard, updated October 2026):
| Reason shoppers gave | Share | The fix |
|---|---|---|
| Extra costs too high (shipping, tax, fees) | 40% | Show the full price, shipping included, before the last step |
| Delivery too slow | 20% | Show the delivery date in the cart; offer a faster option |
| Didn't trust the site with a card | 19% | Hosted card fields, HTTPS, a known payment brand |
| Had to create an account | 18% | Guest checkout as the default |
| Checkout too long or complicated | 17% | Fewer fields, autofill, one clear path |
| Site had errors or crashed | 17% | Test the whole checkout on a phone every month |
| Return policy not good enough | 13% | Link the return policy beside the pay button |
| Couldn't see the total up front | 12% | A shipping and tax estimate in the cart |
| Card declined | 10% | A second way to pay (wallet or PayPal) |
| Not enough ways to pay | 9% | Add wallets before niche methods |
Most of these are design fixes, not ad spend. Baymard estimates the average large store could raise its conversion rate by 35.26% through checkout design alone. That figure comes from testing big retailers, so treat it as a ceiling, not a promise for your store.
Why do shoppers abandon their carts?
Most cart abandonment is normal. Baymard's average across 50 studies is 70.22%: about 7 of every 10 carts never become orders. In its survey, 42% of US shoppers had left a cart because they were just browsing. You can't fix that group.
What you can fix is the rest: surprises, effort and doubt in the last few screens, from people who already wanted to buy.
Show shipping, tax and fees before the final step
Surprise costs are the top reason by a wide margin. Put a shipping estimate on product pages and in the cart. If you offer free shipping over an amount, say how far the cart is from it.
The law also sets limits on hidden fees:
- US, federal: the FTC's fee rule, in force since May 12, 2025, covers only live-event tickets and short-term lodging. Even there, a business "can – but is not required to – exclude shipping charges from the total price" (FTC: Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees FAQ).
- California: since July 1, 2024, a listed price must include all mandatory fees. Government taxes and reasonable shipping may be left out, but handling charges may not (California Attorney General: SB 478 FAQ).
- Canada: the Competition Act treats drip pricing as misleading:
"For greater certainty, the making of a representation of a price that is not attainable due to fixed obligatory charges or fees constitutes a false or misleading representation, unless the obligatory charges or fees represent only an amount imposed on a purchaser of the product ... by or under an Act of Parliament or the legislature of a province." (Competition Act, section 74.01(1.1))
Some other states have their own fee-display laws; check your state attorney general's site.
In plain words: in Canada, a fixed mandatory fee must be in the price you show, unless it is a government tax or levy. This describes what the rules say, not legal advice for your store.
Let customers check out as a guest
Don't make an account the price of buying. Google's guide for web developers is direct:
"For an online store, the simplest way to reduce form friction is to make guest checkout the default." (web.dev: Payment and address form best practices)
Offer the account after payment, on the order confirmation page. The customer has already typed a name, email and address, so one password field turns them into a member. If your store platform has a setting that requires sign-in at checkout, turn it off.
How many form fields should a checkout have?
Fewer than most stores ask for. Baymard's testing found a good checkout needs only 12 to 14 form elements, or 7 to 8 if you count only the fields people type into. The average US checkout shows 23.48 elements (14.88 typed fields).
Go through every field and ask: do I need this to ship and charge the order? Google's guide puts it in six words: "Don't ask for data you don't need!" (web.dev). Then make the remaining fields easier:
| Change | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| One field for full name | Fewer boxes; works for every name format |
| Autofill turned on (the autocomplete attribute, for example cc-number for the card) | The browser fills saved name, address and card in one tap |
| Right keyboard on phones (email field, phone field) | No hunting for the @ or the numbers |
| One field for the card number | Autofill and wallets work; no splitting into four boxes |
| Check each field as it's typed | The error shows at the field, not as a list after "Pay" |
| Disable the pay button once tapped | Stops double orders from a second tap |
| Clear numbered steps (shipping, payment, review) | Buyers see how much is left |
| "ZIP/postal code" and "Country/region" labels | Canadian and US addresses both fit |
Autocomplete is a small code attribute that tells the browser what a field holds. If someone built your checkout by hand, ask them to check it against Google's list.
Which payment methods should a checkout offer?
Cards first, then a wallet row. Digital wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Link) let a buyer pay with saved details and a fingerprint or face scan, which skips most of the form. Stripe's Express Checkout Element, for example, shows "one-click payment method buttons" for Link, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Klarna and Amazon Pay, and hides a wallet the buyer hasn't set up (Stripe Docs).
Buy now, pay later (BNPL) splits a price into installments. Stripe says of these methods: "You're paid immediately and in full" (Stripe Docs: Buy now, pay later). Affirm, Afterpay and Klarna all serve buyers in both the US and Canada through Stripe. BNPL matters most for higher prices; check each provider's merchant fee before you turn it on.
Add methods your buyers ask for, not every logo you can find.
Make checkout fast and error-free
A crashed or frozen checkout loses as many shoppers as a long one (17% each in Baymard's survey). Every month, place a real order on your own phone over mobile data, using a wallet, a card and a coupon. Fix anything that stalls.
Each script you add to the checkout page (chat widgets, trackers, pop-ups) adds weight and risk. Stripe advises keeping outside JavaScript on payment pages to a minimum, because "Including JavaScript from other sites makes your security dependent on theirs" (Stripe Docs: Integration security guide).
How to make a checkout feel safe
Nearly 1 in 5 shoppers quit because they didn't trust the site with a card (Baymard). Trust at checkout comes from a few things buyers can see:
- HTTPS on every page. Stripe's guide says payment pages must use TLS 1.2 or above. TLS is the encryption behind the padlock; people still call it SSL.
- Card entry on your processor's fields. Every business that takes cards must follow PCI DSS, the card industry's security standard. Stripe notes that handling card data yourself can mean "more than 300 security controls." Its hosted pages and fields send card details straight to Stripe, which cuts that work. Ask your processor which of its options keeps card data off your server.
- Familiar payment brands on the button row.
- Delivery date, return policy and a contact link beside the pay button. Slow delivery and weak returns together account for two of the top seven reasons.
We found no primary research on security-vendor badges, so put the basics above first.
How to measure checkout drop-off
Measure before and after each fix. Cart abandonment rate, as Baymard defines it, is 1 minus completed purchases divided by carts created. For example, 1,000 carts and 300 orders is a 70% rate.
To see which step loses people, track the checkout steps in Google Analytics 4. Google's ecommerce guide names four events: begin_checkout for the first step, add_shipping_info when shipping is entered, add_payment_info when payment is submitted, and purchase. If your store doesn't send them yet, a developer can add them. A funnel report built from those four steps shows where the drop is largest. See our Google Analytics 4 guide for setup and our conversion rate guide for the math.
Change one thing at a time and give it enough orders to judge. A store with 20 orders a month can't A/B test a button color. It can fix a surprise fee and watch the trend.
Example
These are illustrative, with round numbers.
A candle shop with a $9 shipping surprise
A US shop gets 400 checkouts a month and 160 orders. Shipping of $9 appears only on the last screen. The owner adds "Shipping $9, free over $50" to every product page and a shipping estimate in the cart. Abandonment at the shipping step is the number to watch next month.
A Canadian supplement store with a "handling fee"
A Toronto store adds a fixed $3.99 handling fee after the product price. Under section 74.01(1.1) of the Competition Act, a fixed mandatory fee that isn't a government charge belongs in the price shown. The store folds the $3.99 into product prices and drops the line.
A dog-grooming salon selling gift cards
The salon's gift card checkout requires an account and asks for phone, birthday and "how did you hear about us." It switches to guest checkout, keeps name, email and card, and adds Apple Pay and Google Pay. The form drops from nine fields to three, and a buyer with a wallet skips even those.
FAQ
What is a good cart abandonment rate?
There's no fixed target. Baymard's 50 studies range from 55% to 84%, averaging 70.22%. Your own rate falling over time is the useful benchmark.
Should I force account creation to build my email list?
No. Required accounts are among the top reasons for abandonment (18%). Offer the account after payment instead.
Do I need to show tax in the product price?
Usually not. California's rule and Canada's drip pricing rule both let government taxes come later. Other mandatory fees belong in the price.
Does Buy Now, Pay Later cost the shopper interest?
Pay-in-4 plans from Affirm, Afterpay and Klarna are interest-free, per Stripe. Longer monthly plans can differ; the provider sets their terms.
Different for you?
- Your checkout is a booking or quote form, not a cart: the same rules about fields and surprises apply. See landing page best practices and our Conversion agent.
- Visitors never reach the cart: the problem is earlier, in product pages or traffic. See ecommerce SEO.
- Checkout is slow on phones: start with mobile page speed or the Website agent.
- You can't tell where people drop off: set up tracking first with Google Analytics 4.
- Ad clicks reach the cart but don't buy: check the ad's promise matches the checkout price. See Paid Ads.