Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Diversify traffic beyond Google: channels AI can't take

Updated · 7 min read

Short answer When Google shows an AI summary, people click a result about half as often. Build channels that need no search: an email and text list of past customers, referrals you ask every customer for, two or three partner businesses, and a Nextdoor or social page neighbors recommend. Start with customers you already have, and keep your SEO.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Traffic beyond Google: what to build first

Build the channels where no search engine or AI answer stands between you and the customer. Start at the top: your own customers cost nothing to reach.

ChannelWho decides if people see youWhat it takesCount it by
Email and text list of past customersYou, once you have consentCollect contact details at every job; send a few useful messages a yearRepeat bookings
Customer referralsYour customersAsk at the end of every job; give them something easy to pass onAnswers to "How did you hear about us?"
Partner businessesThe partnerTwo or three businesses that serve your customers just before or after youJobs from each partner
Nextdoor and social pagesThe platformA page, recommendations from customers, posts neighbors shareMessages and calls

The first three are yours: the contacts and relationships stay when Google, Facebook or an AI app changes its rules. Social pages are rented, since the platform picks who sees each post. So are lead sites like Angi and Thumbtack.

How much are AI answers cutting clicks from Google?

Pew Research Center tracked the browsing of 900 US adults in March 2025. When Google showed an AI summary, they clicked a regular result on 8% of visits; without one, on 15%. They clicked a link inside the summary on 1%.

Google says total clicks have held roughly steady. Its head of Search wrote in August 2025:

"Overall, total organic click volume from Google Search to websites has been relatively stable year-over-year." (Google: AI in Search is driving more queries and higher quality clicks)

Google is still where most local searches start. In BrightLocal's 2026 panel of 1,227 US consumers, 52% began their latest local business search on Google Search, and 75% used more than one channel during that search: 30% used social media, 23% AI tools. Fewer website visits don't always mean fewer customers: is SEO dead because of AI.

Build an email and text list from past customers

Your job software and invoices already hold most of it.

  1. Add an email field and a "send me reminders and offers" checkbox to your booking form, quotes and invoices.
  2. Keep past customers in one list, with the date of their last job.
  3. Send a few useful messages a year tied to your work: a seasonal check, a reminder when service is due, a note to anyone you haven't seen in a year. Ideas: email and text marketing.
WhereEmailText
USOpt-out: the law gives people "the right to have you stop emailing them." Each message needs your "valid physical postal address" and a way to opt out, honored "within 10 business days" (FTC: CAN-SPAM guide).Marketing texts need written consent first: email and text marketing
CanadaConsent first. A purchase or inquiry can give implied consent, which "may be valid for up to 2 years—or just 6 months in the case of inquiries or applications." Express consent has "no time limit unless the recipient withdraws" it (ISED).Same rules as email: CASL consent

How to get more referrals from customers

Referred customers tend to be worth more. A 2011 Journal of Marketing study followed about 10,000 customers of a German bank for almost three years. Referred customers stayed longer, and their average value was at least 16% higher than that of similar customers who came another way.

  • Ask when the job is done and the customer is pleased, in person or in your follow-up message.
  • Give them something to forward: a text with your booking link, or two business cards.
  • Ask every new customer "How did you hear about us?" and thank the person they name.

A reward for referrals is allowed in most trades, with limits:

SituationThe rule
A customer posts about you to earn a rewardUS: the FTC's Endorsement Guides say rewards for social posts "should be clearly and conspicuously disclosed" (16 CFR 255.5, Example 9). Canada: the Competition Bureau tells anyone promoting a business to "disclose all material connections."
A reward for a Google reviewNot allowed. Google bars merchants from offering "payment, discounts, free goods and/or services" for reviews (Google Maps: Prohibited and restricted content). More: asking for reviews.
Real estate, mortgage and title (US)RESPA: no "fee, kickback or other thing of value" for referring settlement-service business on a federally related mortgage loan (12 CFR 1024.14(b)). More: RESPA Section 8.
LawyersEthics rules limit paying for a recommendation: can lawyers pay for leads.
Health care billed to Medicare or Medicaid (US)The Anti-Kickback Statute bars paying "remuneration" to "induce or reward patient referrals" for services federal health programs pay for (HHS-OIG).

Partner businesses that send you work

Pick two or three businesses that see your customer just before or after you: a roofer and a gutter installer, a groomer and a dog trainer, a wedding photographer and a florist. Agree to recommend each other, and count the jobs each one sends. If money or gifts change hands, the rules above still apply.

Nextdoor and social media: rented, but where neighbors talk

Most of your customers are on at least one platform. Pew's 2025 survey of 5,022 US adults found 84% use YouTube, 71% Facebook, 50% Instagram and 37% TikTok. About half visit Facebook and YouTube daily.

Don't expect clicks from there. Meta reports that 98.7% of US Facebook Feed views in the first quarter of 2026 were of posts with no link to a site outside Facebook. Count messages, calls and recommendations instead of website visits.

Nextdoor gives a free Business Page in the US and Canada, built around neighbors' word of mouth: "Collect recommendations to drive word-of-mouth," with "unlimited free posts." Ask happy customers who use Nextdoor to recommend you there. Reddit has its own rules for businesses: Reddit for a small business.

How to tell which channels bring customers

  1. Ask. Put "How did you hear about us?" on the booking form or the first call, and save the answer with the job. Analytics can't see a friend's tip: GA4 files a visit by how the person arrived, such as a search or a typed address.
  2. Tag the links you send. Add UTM tags (utm_source, utm_medium, utm_campaign) to links in emails and texts. GA4 puts a visit in its Email channel when the source or medium is "email," and in SMS when it is "sms."
  3. Compare channels in GA4. The Traffic acquisition report shows Email, SMS, Organic Social, Referral and AI Assistant next to Organic Search, which includes Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode. GA4's Referral means links from other websites, not people who sent you a customer. Count booked jobs, not visits: GA4 key events.

Example

A plumber whose Google visits fell by a third

Calls held steady, but it wants a source Google doesn't control. Its job software holds 3,000 past US customers with email addresses. It sends a fall water-heater reminder with its postal address, an unsubscribe link and a booking link tagged utm_medium=email. If 1% book, that's 30 jobs that needed no search.

A landscaper in Calgary

Under CASL, its implied consent from a purchase lasts up to 2 years. It emails only clients with a job in the last 2 years, adds a consent checkbox to its quote form, and asks each client to recommend it on Nextdoor.

A house cleaner offering a USD 25 credit per referral

A customer shares her referral code in a neighborhood Facebook group. Her post should say she gets a credit. The cleaner never offers the credit for Google reviews.

FAQ

Should I stop paying for SEO?

No. Google Search is still where 52% of US consumers started their latest local search in BrightLocal's 2026 panel. Add channels; don't swap one for another. More: is SEO dead.

Are Yelp, Angi and Thumbtack a way to diversify?

They're another source, but rented: you pay for leads, and the same request often goes to several pros. Judge them by cost per job won: Angi and Thumbtack leads.

Can I give customers a gift card for referrals?

In most trades, yes. Reward the referral, never a Google review. If a customer posts about you to earn it, the post should say so. Check your industry's rules in the table above.

Does posting on Facebook help my Google ranking?

Not directly. Social pages help people find and trust you on those platforms: does social media help SEO.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextAI SEO for real estate agents: 6 strategies for more leadsAI SEO for real estate agents: who AI shows for home searches, how to get named as the agent, area pages AI can quote, and rules for AI copy and photos.

Do it yourself

Does ChatGPT recommend your business? A 20-question testA free test any owner can run to see whether ChatGPT names their business, which competitors it names instead, and why.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Pew Research Center (2025): Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears
  2. Google: AI in Search is driving more queries and higher quality clicks (August 2025)
  3. BrightLocal (July 2026): Google is #1 for local search, but three-quarters use more than one channel
  4. FTC: CAN-SPAM Act, a compliance guide for business
  5. ISED: Getting consent to send email (CASL)
  6. Schmitt, Skiera and Van den Bulte: Referral Programs and Customer Value, Journal of Marketing (2011)
  7. eCFR: 16 CFR 255.5, Disclosure of material connections (FTC Endorsement Guides)
  8. Competition Bureau Canada: Influencer marketing and the Competition Act
  9. Google Maps: Prohibited and restricted content
  10. eCFR: 12 CFR 1024.14, Prohibition against kickbacks and unearned fees (RESPA)
  11. HHS-OIG: Fraud and abuse laws (Anti-Kickback Statute)
  12. Pew Research Center (2025): Americans' Social Media Use 2025
  13. Meta Transparency Center: Widely Viewed Content Report (Q1 2026)
  14. Nextdoor: Create a free Business Page (US)
  15. Nextdoor: Create a free Business Page (Canada)
  16. Analytics Help: [GA4] Default channel group
  17. Analytics Help: Collect campaign data with custom URLs