Ecommerce SEO agency or AI: which fits your store
Short answer Use AI for volume: first drafts of product descriptions, alt text and meta tags, checked by a person before they go live. Pay an agency or expert for judgment: a platform move, filter URLs flooding Google, or a big catalog Google won't index. Agencies averaged $3,209 a month in Ahrefs' 2024 survey of SEO providers.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callAgency or AI: the short version
Split the work by what it needs. Repetitive writing across hundreds of products suits AI. Decisions that can sink a store's traffic for months suit an experienced person.
| Store task | AI handles it? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| First drafts of product descriptions | Yes, with review | Volume work; you add what only a seller knows |
| Alt text, title tags, meta descriptions | Yes, with review | Google says to fact-check these too (below) |
| Category (collection) intro text | Yes, with review | Short, repeatable, easy to check |
| Merchant Center product feed | Partly | The feed tool can sync it; AI-written titles need a label (below) |
| Which filter pages to index or block | Needs a person | One wrong rule can hide or flood thousands of URLs |
| Moving to a new platform or domain | Needs a person | Every old URL needs a redirect plan |
| Earning links and press | Needs a person | Built on relationships, not output |
The how-to for each task is in ecommerce SEO for product and category pages. This page is about who should do it.
What an ecommerce SEO agency does that a general SEO doesn't
A store has problems a five-page service site never meets. Google keeps a separate set of ecommerce guides for them (Google Search Central: Best practices for ecommerce sites). The store-specific services worth paying for:
- Catalog-scale product copy. Replacing the maker's text on hundreds of products, best sellers first.
- Filters and duplicate URLs. Color, size and sort filters (faceted navigation) can turn one category into thousands of near-copies. The agency decides which few deserve to rank and keeps the rest out.
- Product markup and feeds. Structured data (code that labels price, stock and reviews for Google) plus a Merchant Center feed, so products can show in Google Shopping.
- Platform moves. Shopify to WooCommerce, or a new domain. This is the riskiest job in store SEO.
- Discontinued and seasonal products. Whether to keep, redirect or remove each page.
If an agency's proposal reads the same as one for a dentist, with no word on feeds, filters or variants, it isn't an ecommerce specialist.
How much does an ecommerce SEO agency cost?
No public survey splits out ecommerce. The best general data is Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers, updated August 15, 2024 (Ahrefs):
| What the survey found | Figure |
|---|---|
| Agencies, average monthly fee | $3,209 |
| Freelancers, average monthly fee | $1,348 |
| US and Canada providers charging $1,001+ a month | 79.1% |
| Providers who also price by project | 48.9% |
These are sellers' prices from a worldwide poll; only the 79.1% row is US and Canada alone. For a store, three things push the price up: catalog size, how many pages need new copy, and whether a platform move is in scope. A move or a filter cleanup is often a one-time project, not a retainer. More on retainers: how much SEO costs.
AI tools cost less, and some cost nothing extra. Shopify's built-in assistant, Sidekick, writes product descriptions, store pages and blog posts inside the admin. Shopify says "Many of these features are available at no additional cost, but availability can vary by plan, device, and language." (Shopify Help Center: AI-powered tools)
Is AI-written product copy safe for SEO?
Yes, if a person checks it and it adds something. Google says this check also covers title tags, meta descriptions, structured data and image alt text:
"It is critical to manually factcheck and review all AI-generated content for accuracy and trustworthiness before publishing." (Google Search Central: Guidance on using generative AI content)
The risk is volume without value. Google's spam policies name scaled content abuse, including "Using generative AI tools or other similar tools to generate many pages without adding value for users" (Google Search Central: Spam policies). Rewording 2,000 maker descriptions into 2,000 slightly different ones adds nothing. Adding fit notes, sizing and customer questions does.
Shopify gives the same warning: "AI outputs can contain errors, so review anything a tool creates or changes." (Shopify Help Center)
Google Shopping has its own rule for AI titles
Merchant Center, Google's tool for sending your product list to Shopping, requires AI-written titles and descriptions to be labeled. Its help page says:
"When using AI-generated content for the title and description text attributes, an alternative attribute must be used instead of, or in addition to, the existing title [title] or description [description]" (Google Merchant Center Help: AI-generated content)
In practice, AI text goes in the structured title and structured description fields, marked "trained_algorithmic_media." AI-made product images must keep their AI metadata tag. Whoever runs your feed, agency or app, should know this rule before mass-producing titles.
When a store should pay an expert
Before a platform or domain move. Google's site move guide starts with mapping every old URL to its new one and redirecting each. It warns: "Expect temporary fluctuation in site ranking during the move." Done right, the move keeps your link value: "301 and other permanent redirects don't cause a loss in PageRank." (Google Search Central: Site moves) Missing redirects are the costly part. Paying for this once is cheaper than losing a season of traffic.
When thousands of URLs won't index, or filter pages crowd out your real ones in Search Console.
When traffic fell and you don't know why. Diagnosis takes judgment that AI tools can't supply from your data alone.
A small store on Shopify with a few hundred products and no move planned usually needs neither: the platform handles the technical base, and AI plus your own product knowledge covers the copy.
Questions to ask an ecommerce SEO agency
Start with Google's own hiring list (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?):
"What's your experience in my industry?"
"Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site"
Then the store-specific ones:
- Which of our filter pages should rank, and how will you keep the rest out?
- Will you use AI for product copy? Who reviews it, and how is it labeled in Merchant Center?
- If we change platforms, who builds and tests the redirect map?
- Do we stay owner of Search Console, Merchant Center and Analytics?
Walk away from a guarantee. Google says: "If they guarantee you that their changes will give you first place in search results, find someone else." For contract terms, see the marketing agency contract checklist.
Example
Illustrative cases. The numbers are invented.
A Shopify tea shop with 150 products (US dollars)
The owner drafts descriptions with Sidekick, adds brewing notes from her own tasting, and checks each before publishing. Cost: her time, about 15 hours. No agency.
A Canadian outdoor store moving from Magento to Shopify (Canadian dollars)
3,000 product URLs will change. A specialist builds and tests the redirect map for a one-time CA$6,000. The owner keeps writing copy with AI afterward.
A home goods store with 20,000 filter URLs (US dollars)
New products take weeks to show. An agency spends three months, about $9,000, choosing 25 filters to make into real categories and blocking the rest, then hands back to the owner.
FAQ
Can AI replace an ecommerce SEO agency?
For drafting copy and tags across a catalog, largely. For platform moves, filter strategy, link building and diagnosing drops, not yet.
Is an ecommerce SEO agency worth it for a small store?
Usually only for a specific job, like a migration or an indexing problem. A small catalog on a mainstream platform rarely needs a monthly retainer.
Will Google penalize AI product descriptions?
Not for being AI-written. Google targets many pages made "without adding value for users," whoever or whatever wrote them.
Do I need to label AI copy on my own product pages?
Google's rule for your site is to fact-check AI content. The labeling rule applies to titles and descriptions you send to Merchant Center.
Different for you?
- You want to do the store fixes yourself: ecommerce SEO for product and category pages
- Comparing a freelancer, agency and hire in general: SEO agency vs freelancer vs in-house
- Weighing AI tools on their own: can AI do SEO?
- Traffic dropped after a redesign or move: traffic dropped after a website redesign
- You'd rather have the work done and tracked: SEO & GEO Agent