Getting listed in 'best X' roundups for your business
Short answer Most 'best X' roundups come from one of four places: a review platform's formula, a directory's editors, a publisher's writers, or a competitor ranking itself. Find the lists that already show up for your service, meet each one's stated criteria, mostly reviews and verifiable facts, and ask to be considered. Paying for a spot must be disclosed.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow 'best X' roundup lists get made
A roundup is a page that ranks several businesses for one need: "best roofers in Denver", "best payroll software for small business". Who builds the list decides how you get on it.
| Who makes it | How a business gets picked | Your way in |
|---|---|---|
| Review platforms (G2 for software, and similar sites) | A formula from reviews and market presence | Enough recent reviews on that platform |
| Directory editors (Expertise.com, for example) | Staff grade businesses against published criteria | Meet the criteria; use their request or update form |
| Publishers and bloggers (local magazines, trade sites, review blogs) | A writer chooses, sometimes funded by ads or affiliate fees | A short pitch with facts they can check |
| Competitors | The company writing the list ranks itself first | Rarely worth chasing |
Two examples of the formula and editor types, from the list makers' own pages:
- G2 puts a product in a category grid only with enough reviews: "To qualify for inclusion, a product or service must have at least 10 reviews in the corresponding category." Its yearly Best Software lists count only products with at least 10 reviews in the past year (G2 Documentation, October 26, 2026).
- Expertise.com says its lists feature "objectively quantified and qualified professionals hand-picked by our selection process", graded on reputation, qualifications, experience, engagement and professionalism. It lets businesses in its Legal and Home Improvement categories request a review, and its portal for updating a listing is free (Expertise.com: About).
Competitor lists are common. Ahrefs checked 250 Google results pages for "best X software"-style searches: 67.6% included a list where the company writing it ranked itself number one (Ahrefs, December 4, 2025).
Why being on a roundup matters for Google and AI answers
A roundup can send customers directly, but it also feeds the two places most customers look first.
- Google Maps and local results. Google names prominence (how well-known a business is) as one of three local ranking factors:
"This factor's also based on info like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have." (Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking, archived October 31, 2026)
- ChatGPT and other AI assistants. In Ahrefs' study of ChatGPT answers to 750 "best" prompts in software, products and agencies, "best X" blog lists made up 43.8% of all cited source pages (Ahrefs, December 4, 2025). The study covered software, products and agencies, not local services, so treat it as a direction, not a number for your trade. Where ChatGPT finds local businesses covers the local sources.
How to get your business on 'best X' lists
- Find the lists that matter. Search Google for "best [your service] in [your city]" and "best [your service] for [your type of customer]". Ask ChatGPT and Perplexity the same, and note which pages they cite. Keep the 10 that come up most.
- Read each list's method. Most say how they choose: a review minimum, a license check, a service area, a date range. If you fall short, that tells you what to fix first.
- Meet the formula. For review-driven lists, the work is steady reviews from real customers on the sites the list counts. Asking for reviews covers what the FTC allows.
- Use the official door. Directories often have a "request a review", "suggest a business" or "claim your listing" form. Use it before emailing anyone.
- Pitch the writer, briefly. For publisher lists, send three to five facts the writer can check: license number, years in business, the exact services and area, review count and rating, one thing you do that others on the list don't. Offer to help with the next update rather than asking to replace someone.
- Keep your facts the same everywhere. Writers and AI tools check your name, address, phone and services against your website and directories. Mismatches make you look less certain. See local citations and directories.
- Recheck twice a year. Lists get refreshed often: 79.1% of the 1,100 lists Ahrefs checked had been updated in 2025 (Ahrefs, December 4, 2025). A refresh is your next chance.
Can you pay to be on a 'best' list?
You can buy advertising or a featured spot. Hiding that it was paid is the problem.
- Google: buying links "for ranking purposes" is link spam, including "Exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links" (Google Search Central: Spam policies). A paid placement link should be marked:
"Mark links that are advertisements or paid placements (commonly called paid links) with the sponsored value." (Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links)
- US (FTC): a review site may sell ad space, but the FTC warns that "If the purchase of a display ad positively impacts the editorial content of the review, the review could be deceptive." (FTC: Endorsement Guides Q&A). If your payment buys a better rank, the list needs to say so.
- Canada: the Competition Bureau says its deceptive marketing rules apply to paid endorsements that aren't clearly disclosed, and that "advertisers may be liable for representations made through influencers." (Competition Bureau: Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest, Volume 4). Paying a publisher for a better spot raises the same question.
Paid "top 10" plaques and badges that arrive by email are ads, not editorial picks. Judge them as ads: will customers see the page, and is the paid status disclosed?
Should you publish your own 'best X' list?
Only if you are open that it's yours. Since October 21, 2024, the FTC's rule on reviews makes it illegal for a business to misrepresent that a site "that it controls, owns, or operates provides independent reviews or opinions" about a category that includes its own products or services (16 CFR 465.6; Federal Register, August 22, 2024).
An honest comparison page on your own site, clearly from you, is allowed. It earns less trust from AI tools than a third-party list: in Peec AI's study of 232,000 citations in software, self-promotional lists were 3.6% of ChatGPT's citations, against 10.3% in Google AI Mode and 10.4% in Perplexity (Peec AI, March 2026). Effort spent getting onto other people's lists usually goes further.
Example
A plumber in a mid-size city
Searching "best plumbers in [city]" shows a local magazine list, two directory lists and Yelp. The plumber has 18 Google reviews; the directory lists favor businesses with far more. They ask every finished job for a review for six months, then use one directory's "request a review" form and send the magazine editor four checkable facts before its spring update.
A bookkeeping firm
ChatGPT's answer to "best bookkeeper for contractors in [state]" cites two blog lists. One is a competitor ranking itself first, so the firm skips it. The other is a trade blog; the firm emails the writer its niche, client types and software certifications, and offers a short quote for the next update.
A software startup
Its product has 6 reviews on G2, under the 10-review minimum for a category grid. It asks current customers for reviews on that platform, then pitches three independent comparison blogs once it qualifies.
FAQ
How long does it take to get on a roundup?
It depends on the list's update cycle. G2's live category grids update daily and its Best Software lists once a year; editor and publisher lists change when they're refreshed, and most lists Ahrefs checked had been updated within the year.
Do 'best of' badges help SEO?
A badge on your site doesn't help by itself. What can help is the list page linking to you, which Google says counts toward prominence.
Should I ask to replace a competitor on a list?
No. Ask to be considered at the next update, with facts. A pitch that runs down another business makes yours look worse.
Do AI assistants trust every list equally?
No. Peec AI found ChatGPT cited self-promotional lists far less than Google AI Mode and Perplexity did. Independent lists that show a clear method carry more weight.
Different for you?
- You have few reviews: fix that first. Asking for reviews.
- You want links from local sites, not just lists: backlinks for a local business.
- You care most about AI answers: how to get ChatGPT to recommend your business.
- You'd rather have it done for you: the SEO agent.