Google product reviews update: write reviews that still rank
Short answer There is no separate update to wait for anymore. Google's last announced one was in November 2023; since then its reviews system improves continuously and covers products, services and businesses. Review pages rank when they prove first-hand use: your own photos or tests, measurements, real drawbacks and comparisons. Thin summaries of spec sheets lose.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callIs there still a Google product reviews update?
Not as a named event. Google ran eight announced reviews updates between April 2021 and November 2023. When it released the last one, it said:
"Going forward, as the reviews system is now being improved at a regular and ongoing pace, we will no longer be posting about future updates on the status dashboard." (Google Search Status Dashboard: November 2023 reviews update)
So a review page can rise or fall any week, not only on announced dates. Google still lists the reviews system as one of its active ranking systems, and says what it rewards:
"The reviews system aims to better reward high quality reviews, content that provides insightful analysis and original research, and is written by experts or enthusiasts who know the topic well." (Google Search Central: A guide to Google Search ranking systems)
The fix hasn't changed since 2021: show you used the thing, and say something the maker's page doesn't.
What changed since the first update?
| Date | Change |
|---|---|
| April 8, 2021 | First "product reviews update", English only (Google Search Central Blog) |
| Dec 2021 to Feb 2023 | Five more product reviews updates (Status Dashboard history) |
| April 12, 2023 | Renamed "reviews update"; now "covers reviews about products, services, and things" (Status Dashboard) |
| November 8, 2023 | Last announced update; future changes roll out unannounced (Status Dashboard) |
| Today | Applies in 11 languages, including English, Spanish and French (Google Search Central: reviews system) |
The 2023 widening matters to service businesses. Google's page now names reviews of "services and businesses such as restaurants or fashion brands". A roofer's "best shingle brands" post, a bookkeeper's software comparison or a wedding photographer's venue guide all count.
What first-hand evidence does a review page need?
Proof you used it, in a form a reader can check. Google's review guide asks writers to:
"Provide evidence such as visuals, audio, or other links of your own experience with what you are reviewing, to support your expertise and reinforce the authenticity of your review." (Google Search Central: Write high quality reviews)
Its helpful content guide adds what readers trust: knowing "the number of products that were tested, what the test results were, and how the tests were conducted, all accompanied by evidence of the work involved, such as photographs."
| Evidence | Weak | Strong |
|---|---|---|
| Photos | Maker's stock images | Your own shots on a real job, with your setting visible |
| Measurements | "Very quiet" | "52 decibels at 3 feet on our meter" |
| Method | None stated | "We installed 6 units over 2 winters; here's what we checked" |
| Drawbacks | Only praise | What broke, what annoyed customers, who should skip it |
| Comparison | One product alone | How it stacks up to 2–3 rivals, and which fits which buyer |
| Change over time | Launch specs | What the new model fixed versus the old one |
| Author | No name | A byline with the person's trade experience |
Google also asks for the "most important decision-making factors" for that category. For a car, it names fuel economy and safety. For a heat pump, it might be cold-weather output and noise. Rate those, not a generic "value" score.
Two things Google says don't help: length and fakery. It says to focus "on the quality and originality of your reviews, not the length." And it calls made-up authors, such as "AI-generated headshots, made-up names, or false credentials", deception, which it calls "a signal of a low-quality page" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content).
Does the reviews system judge my customer reviews?
No. It judges review articles you write yourself:
"It does not evaluate third-party reviews, such as those posted by users in the reviews section of a product or services page." (Google Search Central: Google Search's reviews system and your website)
It mostly scores page by page. A site with "a substantial amount of review content" can be judged as a whole; Google says a site-wide check "is not likely to happen" if you don't have many reviews.
Separate rule for star ratings in search results: if a business controls the reviews about itself, its pages marked up as LocalBusiness or Organization can't get review stars, even when the reviews come through an embedded widget (Google Search Central: Review snippet structured data).
Do affiliate links or links to several sellers matter?
Google suggests multiple sellers but doesn't call them a ranking factor. Its exact words: "Consider including links to multiple sellers to give the reader the option to purchase from their merchant of choice."
Affiliate links themselves are fine. Copying the merchant's text is not. Google's spam policies call that thin affiliation: product descriptions and reviews "copied directly from the original merchant without any original content or added value." Its spam policies also say: "Not every site that participates in an affiliate program is a thin affiliate."
Do I have to disclose commissions or free products?
In the US, yes. The FTC tells affiliates to disclose the relationship "clearly and conspicuously on your site", gives the sample line "I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post," and adds: "The closer the disclosure is to your recommendation, the better." It says a "buy now" button alone is not enough (FTC: Endorsement Guides, What People Are Asking).
In Canada, the Competition Bureau's guidance is written for social media posts. It says to "disclose all material connections", lists commissions and free products among them, and says linking to an affiliate page "is unlikely to be enough" (Competition Bureau Canada: Influencer marketing and the Competition Act).
Google's review snippet rules point the same way: reviews written for money, discounts or free products must "clearly and prominently" disclose it, or they break the rules for review stars.
How do I know if my review pages were hit, and can they recover?
Since no dates are announced, look for a drop that hits review and "best X" pages harder than your service pages. Compare those pages in Search Console over 3–6 months. If the drop lines up with a listed core update, start with traffic dropped after a core update.
Recovery is possible but slow:
"Content impacted by the reviews system may recover over time, if you've made improvements to your content." (Google Search Central: Google Search's reviews system and your website)
Fix the pages that earn the most first. Add your own evidence, cut reviews of things you never used, and merge thin list posts into one strong page (how to update or merge old pages).
Example
An HVAC contractor's heat pump guide
A "best heat pumps for cold climates" page lists 10 brands with specs from maker sites. It slides over several months. The owner cuts it to the 4 brands the crew installs, adds job photos, winter output readings from 3 homes, and one model they stopped installing and why. The page is shorter and finally says something no maker page says.
A bookkeeper's software comparison
A bookkeeping firm earns $50 per signup from one software brand. Its comparison names that brand "best" with no proof. The fix: screenshots from real client books, a table of 4 tasks timed in each tool, a link to each vendor, and a line near the links saying the firm earns a commission from one of them.
A salon's product picks
A salon blog reviews 3 shampoos it sells. Its reviews of hair products are first-party content, so the reviews system can judge them. Customer star ratings on its booking page are not.
FAQ
When was the last Google product reviews update?
The last announced one ran November 8 to December 7, 2023. Google then stopped posting reviews updates because the system now improves continuously.
Did the reviews system become part of the core update?
Google hasn't said so. Its ranking guide still lists the reviews system as active. The helpful content system is the one that joined core, in March 2024.
Does product structured data help a review rank?
It may help Google spot a review: markup "might help us better identify if something is a product review, but we don't solely depend on it."
Can I use AI to write product reviews?
AI can help draft, but the evidence Google asks for, like photos and tests, must come from your own use. See does Google penalize AI content.
Different for you?
- Your whole site dropped, not just review pages: traffic dropped after a Google core update.
- You want readers and Google to trust who wrote it: E-E-A-T for a small business.
- You're collecting customer reviews, not writing them: asking for reviews: the rules.
- You'd rather have someone run your content and rankings: SEO.