Google creator summit: what Google told sites hit by updates
Short answer At its October 29, 2024 Web Creator Conversation, Google told about 20 independent site owners that their sites were not the problem, promised no recovery, and said any comeback would likely be gradual. No fix followed for most. The lesson for an owner: follow Google's core update steps, change nothing in panic, and build leads that don't depend on Google.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhat Google told sites hit by updates
Three messages, as attendees reported them. Google published no transcript or summary of the day.
| What Google said | Who | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| "None of you have done anything wrong" | Danny Sullivan, then Google's Search Liaison | A drop is not proof your site is bad |
| "I can't give you any guarantees about recovery" | Pandu Nayak, Google Search vice president | No one, Google included, can promise your traffic back |
| Recovery is "much more likely" to be "a gradual process" | Sullivan, reported by Search Engine Roundtable | Expect months, not a switch flipping back |
Sources: attendee Kim Snaith's written account; Search Engine Roundtable, quoting attendee Mike Hardaker's recap.
Google's own help pages say the same thing in writing. After an update, "there might not be anything fundamentally wrong with your content" (Google Search Central: Debugging drops in Google Search traffic).
What was the Google Web Creator Conversation?
A one-day, invitation-only meeting at Google's Mountain View campus on October 29, 2024. Around 20 independent site owners came, most of them hit hard by Google's 2023 and 2024 updates, per Snaith. Most were picked from a feedback form Sullivan had posted earlier that year.
The invitation said up front there would be no site-specific advice. An opening slide read: "most Googlers here can't answer questions, they are here to hear, learn and use what you share to find ways to improve Search" (Snaith).
Did attendees pay their own way? Mostly not. Google covered flights and two hotel nights; Snaith says she was still down about £500 on extra nights, trains and other costs.
Why did site owners leave feeling unsupported?
Because they came for answers and got a listening session. What they heard:
- The one piece of advice was old advice. Elizabeth Tucker, a director of product management at Google Search, gave two "North Star" points; the first was to keep making helpful content. Snaith says she groaned.
- No promise of a fix. Sullivan said the next update was coming "fairly soon" but probably wouldn't include changes from that day, and that "September is not coming back, the whole format of search results has changed", meaning traffic from before the September 2023 update (Search Engine Roundtable).
- "Do something else in the meantime." Asked what he'd do if his site lost all its traffic, Sullivan said he'd do something else while waiting. Snaith reads it as putting energy somewhere else while waiting, not quitting.
Two technical answers worth keeping
Ranking is mostly page by page, with site-level "priors". Nayak:
"We really think of these as page signals... Having said that, there are definitely priors on sites that then get adjusted by specific page level signals that we will learn from." (Snaith's transcript)
In plain words: Google starts with a general view of your site, then adjusts it per page. One weak section can drag on the rest, but good pages can still rise.
Ads on your site are not the problem by themselves. Tucker: "nowhere do we say ads are bad" in the rater guidelines (Snaith). For a service business, this rarely matters; your site likely runs no ads.
What happened after the summit?
- Before it: Google's August 2024 core update already said it "takes into account the feedback we've heard from some creators" and aims to show "small or independent sites that are creating useful, original content" (Google Search Central Blog). Some sites recovered that August; Snaith's smaller site did, with no changes on her side.
- The liaison is gone. On August 1, 2025, Sullivan left the Search Liaison role for another job inside Google Search. The account now says "This account is no longer active." Google said updates continue through the Google Search Central accounts (Search Engine Roundtable).
- No one-to-one help replaced it. Google's channels for site owners today: the Search Central Help Community, office hours questions, and free Search Central Live events. None reviews your site for you.
What to do if a Google update hit your site
- Confirm it was an update, then wait. Google's steps, dates and what counts as a "large" drop are in traffic dropped after a core update.
- Don't panic-edit. Google: "Deleting content is a last resort" (Google Search Central: core updates and your website). Don't pay anyone who promises a recovery; Google's own vice president couldn't.
- Fix what you control, page by page. Look at the pages that fell most in Search Console, and compare them with what now ranks above you.
- Expect months. Google says improvements can take "several months" to show, and "that could mean waiting until the next core update" (same page).
- Build leads Google can't take away. That was the summit's real lesson. For a local business: your Google Maps listing ranks separately from your website pages; past customers on an email or text list come back for free; referrals don't depend on any ranking.
Example
A home-improvement blog that lost 80% of its traffic
Its income was ads on articles. The summit's message applies in full: no promised recovery. Action: keep the best articles current, stop publishing thin ones, and start an email list from the readers it still gets.
A plumber whose website fell from position 3 to 9
Calls dropped, but the Maps listing held, with 120 reviews. Action: follow the core update steps for the website; meanwhile ask every finished job for a review and text past customers before the heating season.
FAQ
Did Google apologize to the creators?
Not formally. Snaith says Sullivan told attendees several times their sites were not the problem, Google was. Google published no statement about the event.
Will Google hold another creator summit?
Google hasn't announced one. Danny Sullivan, whose feedback form produced most invitations, left the Search Liaison role in August 2025.
Can I get Google to review my site after a drop?
No. Google offers a help community, office hours and events. The exception: after fixing a manual action shown in Search Console, you can request review.
Different for you?
- The drop matches a core update's dates: traffic dropped after a Google core update.
- You need to read the Performance report: Search Console for a small business.
- Your website fell but Maps still brings calls: rank higher on Google Maps.
- You want customers who don't come through Google: email and text marketing.
- You want the drop diagnosed for you: SEO & GEO Agent.