Growing a community-run game server: marketing basics
Short answer New players find a game server in three places: server lists where players vote daily, Discord communities, and word of mouth from players and creators. Each has written rules. List sites ban vote bots and vote trading, Discord Discovery needs 1,000 members, and the FTC bans paying for positive reviews. Grow inside those rules.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhere new players come from, and the rule on each
A server grows the way a local gym does: people hear about it, look it up, try it once, and stay if the community is good. The places they hear about it each have a rulebook:
| Channel | What it does for you | The rule that limits it |
|---|---|---|
| Server lists and voting sites | Strangers browsing for a game mode find you | One vote per player per day, no bots, no vote trading (list terms) |
| Discord | Players talk between sessions; Discovery lets strangers join | Discovery needs 1,000 members and an 8-week-old server (Discord) |
| Reviews and word of mouth | Players vouch for you on lists and socials | No rewards tied to positive reviews (FTC) |
| Creators and streamers | Their audience sees your server being played | They must disclose that you paid or gave them perks (FTC, Mojang) |
Examples below use Minecraft because Mojang publishes clear server rules. Rust, ARK, Garry's Mod or FiveM servers use the same channels; check your game's own license for its money rules.
Server lists and voting sites: how to rank without getting removed
Lists are the search engine of game servers. Players filter by game mode, sort, and copy an address. Votes are how a list hears that players like you, which is why servers ask players to vote and reward them in game.
Take one large list, MinecraftServers.org. Its terms, last updated September 2025, set the limits most lists share:
- One vote per player per day, entered by hand with a captcha. "Voting through the use of automated voting scripts, bots or programs is strictly prohibited."
- No vote trading. Players may be encouraged to vote only for the listing of the server they came from, even if you own two servers.
- One listing per server. Duplicates are removed.
- Accurate tags. Tags must match your real game modes; staff remove those that don't.
- Uptime counts. Servers older than 10 days are removed automatically if uptime falls below 25%.
- Paid spots are an auction. The top five bids win sponsored slots, which are non-refundable "with no guarantee of uptime or site traffic".
The list can "remove or reset votes" when it suspects fraud, so a month of bought or botted votes can vanish overnight.
Setting up vote rewards
Lists send votes to your server through a plugin. On Minecraft that is usually NuVotifier, which receives votes from voting websites, plus a vote listener plugin that hands out the reward. Its setup guide lists free listeners such as SuperbVote and paid ones such as VoteParty. Keep rewards small and the same for everyone: a crate key, in-game money, a short boost.
What a listing page should show
Write the description like a shop window: game mode, version, what makes you different, and how to join. For Minecraft, also list what you sell and what it costs. Mojang requires that you "provide information to users on all the content and pricing applicable to your server before a person joins, signs up, or signs in" (Minecraft Usage Guidelines).
Selling ranks without breaking Mojang's rules
Growth brings costs, and most servers pay them with a store. Mojang's Usage Guidelines allow these ways to make money on a Minecraft server:
| Allowed | Condition |
|---|---|
| Charging for access | Same price for everyone, and every payer gets all enabled mods |
| Donations | The donor gets nothing only they can use; server-wide rewards for a donation goal are fine |
| Gameplay perks | Only if they don't "ruin other players' experience or give a competitive advantage" |
| Cosmetics | No capes or anything that looks like a Minecraft cape |
| In-game currency | No cash-out, no transfer to other servers, not named like Minecoins |
Every server that takes money must also give buyers a payment history and keep everything "suitable for audiences of all ages". Mojang ends with a warning:
"We reserve the right to decide if the way you are monetizing your server is consistent with our brand." (Minecraft: Usage Guidelines)
One line affects Discord-first servers. Access "can't be limited to or controlled, directly or indirectly, by a player owning or having access to out-of-game content, products, or services." Mojang doesn't say whether a free Discord account counts. The safe setup: anyone with the game can join without it.
Discord: from invite links to Google results
Discord is where a server's community lives between sessions. A Community Server can become a Discoverable Server, which "anyone can find and join without an invite." To qualify, Discord requires:
- At least 1,000 members.
- At least 8 weeks old.
- Its activity requirements, and safety settings turned on.
- The 2FA requirement for moderation enabled.
- A name, description and channel names that follow the Discovery Guidelines, which say public servers must be "appropriate for audiences of all ages 13+".
New on November 16, 2026: Server Web Pages
Since November 16, 2026, every Discoverable Server has a public Server Web Page. Discord says search engines like Google can show it, and people can join straight from it. If you haven't built one, Discord publishes a default page from your Server Profile. Discord's advice reads like SEO advice:
"When adding content to your web page, use words that describe your community accurately and specifically." (Discord Support: Discord Server Web Pages)
So "Towny survival server with weekly build contests" beats "best Minecraft server". Two more things now reach the web, both turned on for servers by default:
| Content | Starts | Your control |
|---|---|---|
| Channel Summaries: automatic summaries of public channels, no usernames | November 16, 2026 | Pick channels or turn off, in Server Settings, Web Presence |
| Channel Messages: members' answers in public channels, searchable | Mid-December 2026 | Pick channels; members can opt out in User Settings, Data and Privacy |
In Canada (and the EU, UK, Brazil, Australia and South Korea), each member's Channel Messages setting starts off; in the US it starts on (Discord blog). Private channels are never included. Turning a feature off stops new content, but what is already published may stay up until removed, and search engines keep their own copies (Discord Support: Discoverable Server Web Presence). Review which channels are public before mid-December.
Reviews and creators: what the FTC allows
Players read reviews on lists and in Discord before they join. Since October 21, 2024, the FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule bans fake reviews and rewards tied to a positive review. A reward for any honest review is still allowed:
"The rule does not prohibit giving incentives for reviews, as long as there isn't an express or implied requirement that the reviews have to express a particular sentiment." (FTC: Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule Q&A)
The FTC's own example of an implied requirement is close to a server announcement: "Tell your friends about all the fun you had at Jane's Arcade for a chance to win prizes." So "leave a review, any review, for a crate key" is allowed; "post a 5-star review for a crate key" is not. Asking staff or their friends to post reviews without saying who they are also breaks the rule.
Creators who play on your server for pay or perks must say so. Mojang requires servers to make influencers "disclose their relationship with you and follow the guidelines published by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission." The FTC's influencer guide counts free or discounted products as a connection, and a free rank is one. Say it in the video itself, not just the description, and repeat it during live streams; the FTC says a hashtag such as #ad is fine but not necessary.
Naming your server
Mojang lets you use "Minecraft" in a secondary title or description, never as the main name. Its own example: "Kotoba Miners: A Minecraft server for Redstone builds" is fine; "Minecraft - the ultimate Kotoba server for Redstone" is not. A distinct name also makes you easier to find on lists, Discord and Google.
Kids on your server
Block games draw children. The FTC's COPPA rule applies to online services "directed to children under 13" that collect personal information from them, and to general-audience services that know they collect it from under-13s. If your store, forum or sign-up asks for an email, birthday or real name, read the FTC's COPPA FAQ first. Mojang also makes you responsible "for all end user data privacy and protection requirements".
Example
Illustrative cases, not real servers.
A new survival server, 40 players
It lists on three server lists with accurate tags, installs NuVotifier and a free vote listener, and gives one crate key per daily vote. It runs a Discord with invite links in-game, since Discovery is 960 members away.
A minigame network, 3,000 Discord members
It turns on Discord Discovery, rewrites its Server Web Page to name its game modes, and makes its staff and appeals channels private before Channel Messages start in December. It moves a pay-to-win sword out of its store.
A roleplay server working with streamers
It gives three streamers a free rank and asks each to say "the server gave me a rank" on stream. After events it asks every player for an honest review and offers the same reward whatever the rating.
FAQ
Can I buy votes for my server?
Lists ban it. MinecraftServers.org forbids bots and vote trading and can reset votes it suspects are fraudulent. Paid placement exists, but as sponsored slots, not votes.
Are vote rewards allowed?
MinecraftServers.org lets you encourage players to vote for your own listing, "whether in-game or otherwise". Check each list's terms. Keep rewards the same for everyone, and on Minecraft, don't let them become a paid competitive advantage.
How many members does a Discord server need to be discoverable?
At least 1,000, plus an 8-week-old server, activity and safety requirements, and 2FA for moderators (Discord Support).
Does a small Discord server get a web page?
No. Server Web Pages are only for Discoverable Servers. Until you reach 1,000 members, share invite links on your lists, website and in game.
Different for you?
- Players talk about your server on Reddit: Reddit marketing rules.
- You want reviews on Google or Trustpilot too: asking for reviews.
- Thinking about video ads for a trailer: YouTube ads.
- Wondering if TikTok and Instagram posts help search: does social media help SEO?.
- Want a website that ranks for your game mode: SEO & GEO Agent.