Does your domain name affect SEO?
Hardly. Google's starter guide answers the question directly:
"When picking the name of your site, do what's best for your business. Users will use this name to find you, so we recommend following general marketing best practices. From a ranking perspective, the keywords in the name of the domain (or URL path) alone have hardly any effect beyond appearing in breadcrumbs." (Google: SEO Starter Guide)
| Domain | Effect on Google ranking | Effect on customers |
|---|---|---|
| Your business name (smithplumbing.com) | Normal | Easy to remember and say on the phone |
| Exact match (calgaryplumber.com) | Hardly any, and capped by Google's exact match domain system | Sounds generic; harder to tell apart from rivals |
| Keyword plus a city you may outgrow | Hardly any | Awkward once you serve other towns |
Do exact match domains still work?
Not as a shortcut. Google runs a ranking system just for them:
"Our ranking systems consider the words in domain names as one of many factors to determine if content is relevant to a search. However, our exact match domain system works to ensure we don't give too much credit for content hosted under domains designed to exactly match particular queries." (Google: Ranking systems guide)
Google's own example is a domain with "best-places-to-eat-lunch" in it; "Our system adjusts for this" (Google). An exact match domain isn't a penalty, and it can rank with good pages. It just doesn't do the work for you.
One trap: a keyword domain doesn't let you put keywords in your Your free business listing on Google Search and Maps: hours, photos, reviews, services and contact details. More name. Google says your name should match "your business’s real-world name," and "Including unnecessary information in your business name isn't permitted, and could result in the suspension of your Business Profile" (Google Business Profile Help: Guidelines). If you trade as "Calgary Plumber Co." on your trucks, invoices and signs, that's your name. If you trade as Smith Plumbing, the profile says Smith Plumbing.
.com, .ca, .org or a new ending?
For ranking, the ending rarely matters:
"And while still on the topic of domain names: the TLD (the domain name ending like ".com" or ".guru") only matters if you're targeting a specific country's users, and even then it's usually a low impact signal." (Google: SEO Starter Guide)
Google adds: "Otherwise Google Search doesn't care which TLD you're using (whether it's a .com or .org or .asia)" (Google).
Canada is the exception that matters. A country ending like .ca gives "a strong signal to both users and search engines that your site is explicitly intended for a certain country" (Google: Multi-regional sites). A Canadian business serving only Canadians can use .ca. One serving both the US and Canada is better off with .com, which isn't tied to either country.
Does changing your domain name affect SEO?
Yes, for a while, even when done right. Google says to "Expect temporary fluctuation in site ranking during the move," and that "a small to medium-sized website can take a few weeks for most pages to move" (Google: Site moves).
What Google asks for:
- Redirect every old page to its matching new page with a permanent (301) redirect (Google: Site moves).
- Use Google's free tool that shows which searches bring people to your site and flags pages Google can't index. More's Change of Address tool after the redirects are live (Search Console Help).
- Keep the redirects "generally at least 1 year" (Google: Site moves), and keep paying for the old domain "for at least a year to prevent others from buying and using your abandoned domain" (Search Console Help).
- Update the website link on your Business Profile and everywhere else you control.
Page-by-page redirect mapping is in why traffic dropped after a redesign. Rebranding is a business decision; Google calls the ranking dip during a move temporary.
Can I buy an old keyword domain?
You can, if you build a real site on it. Google's expired domain abuse policy targets domains bought to rank low-value content on a previous owner's reputation. It also says: "It's fine to use an old domain name for a new, original site that's designed to serve people first" (Google Search Central Blog, March 2024). Because the keywords add little, paying a premium for one rarely makes sense.
Example
A new HVAC company choosing a name
The owner can get either "denverfurnacerepair.com" or "peakairhvac.com". Google gives the keyword one hardly any ranking credit, and it would sound odd once the company adds AC and moves past Denver. He takes the brand name and builds a page for each service.
A Toronto cleaning company: .ca or .com
It serves only the Greater Toronto Area. A .ca tells Google and customers it's Canadian, and the company buys the matching .com too, redirected, so nobody else takes it.
A roofer rebranding off an exact-match domain
Five years on "springfieldroofrepair.com", he renames the company. He maps every old page to a new one with 301 redirects, files the Change of Address, keeps both domains for a year, and expects a few weeks of uneven traffic.
Different for you?
- Traffic fell after a new site or domain: why traffic dropped after a redesign.
- Your agency registered the domain: who owns your website domain.
- You're also choosing a website platform: is Wix or Squarespace bad for SEO.
- Your new site doesn't appear at all: website not showing up on Google.
- You'd rather have the site built and moved for you: Website Agent.