Keyword obtainability: can your site actually rank for it?
Short answer A difficulty score rates a keyword for an average site, not yours. To judge your odds, check four things: whether Google already shows you for it, whether sites like yours rank on page one, how your links compare with theirs, and whether your page matches what searchers want. Formulas that divide difficulty by Domain Rating mislead.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe short rule: compare yourself with page one, not with a score
"Obtainability" means: can your site reach page one for this keyword, with the effort you can afford? A keyword difficulty score (KD) can't tell you that by itself. Ahrefs, which publishes one of the best-known scores, says so on its own blog: the score "doesn't account for *your* specific website's authority" (Ahrefs Blog: Keyword Difficulty).
So judge each keyword with four checks, in this order:
| Check | Where | Good sign |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Google already shows you for it | Search Console, Performance report | You appear, even on page 2 or 3 |
| 2. Sites like yours rank | The results page itself | Other small businesses on page one, not only big brands |
| 3. Your links can catch up | Free link checkers, Search Console Links report | Top pages have a number of linking sites you could reach |
| 4. Your page fits what searchers want | The results page | Top results are the same kind of page you have |
Pass all four and the keyword is within reach now. Fail check 2 or 3 and it is a later goal. Fail check 4 and it is the wrong keyword for that page.
Why "KD divided by DR" formulas don't work
A popular shortcut divides a keyword's difficulty by your site's Domain Rating (DR), or subtracts one from the other, and calls the result obtainability. It looks precise, but the two numbers are different kinds of thing.
- KD rises faster than it looks. Ahrefs builds KD from how many separate websites link to the top 10 pages. Its own table shows the curve: KD 20 means about 22 linking sites, KD 40 about 56, KD 60 about 129, KD 80 about 353, KD 90 about 756 (Ahrefs: Free Keyword Difficulty Checker). Going from 40 to 80 isn't twice the work; it's more than six times the links.
- DR is a ranking against other sites, not a unit. Ahrefs says "Domain Rating is a relative metric by definition" (Ahrefs Help: What is Domain Rating). Moz says the same of its Domain Authority score and adds that it is "easier to grow your score from 20 to 30 than it is to grow it from 70 to 80" (Moz: What is Domain Authority?).
- Google uses neither. Moz states its score "is not used by Google to determine search engine rankings" (Moz: What is Domain Authority?).
Dividing one curved scale by another produces a number with no fixed meaning. Use the two scores as rough clues inside check 3, not as a formula.
If you pay for a tool, one shortcut is closer to the real question. Semrush's Personal Keyword Difficulty estimates "how difficult it will be for the specified domain to reach the top 10" for a keyword, weighing your site's topic fit and its metrics against the sites already ranking (Semrush Knowledge Base). It is still an estimate from one company's data.
Check 1: does Google already show you for it?
This is the strongest evidence you can get, and it's free. If Google already shows your site for a phrase, it already thinks your page is relevant. Moving from position 15 to 8 is usually far easier than starting from nothing.
- Open Search Console > Performance > Search results.
- Turn on Average position and stay on the Queries tab.
- Sort by impressions and look for phrases with position between about 8 and 30.
Google defines position as "the topmost position occupied by a link to your property or page in search results, averaged across all queries" (Search Console Help: What are impressions, position, and clicks?). Treat it as a trend, not a rank you will see yourself. Google warns that results "are specific to the time, place, device, and recent history of the person searching" (Search Console Help: Performance report). For how to read the rest of the report, see Google Search Console for a small business.
Check 2: who is on page one?
Search the keyword in a private browser window, from your service area. Write down the top 10 and sort each into one of three groups:
- Sites like yours: other local businesses of similar size.
- Directories and marketplaces: Yelp, Angi, Houzz, government or association lists.
- Big brands: national chains, large publishers.
Three or more sites like yours on page one is a strong yes. A page filled with brands and directories means the top spots are held by sites with far more links and recognition; aim for a narrower phrase instead, such as the service plus your city or a specific problem.
For local searches, also look at the map results. Google says local results are mainly based on "relevance, distance, and popularity", and "Distance refers to how far each business is from the customer who's searching" (Google Business Profile Help). No website score captures distance, and Google says plainly: "There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." Map results have their own playbook: rank higher on Google Maps.
Check 3: can your links catch up?
Links still count. Google says it "uses links as a signal when determining the relevancy of pages" (Google Search Central: Link best practices). So compare the links behind the top pages with yours.
- Theirs: Enter the keyword in Ahrefs' free Keyword Difficulty Checker. Its KD maps to roughly how many linking websites a page needs for the top 10 (the table above).
- Yours: In Search Console, open Links > External links > Top linking sites. It lists the sites linking to you, though Google notes it shows "a sample" of links, not every one (Search Console Help: Links report). Ahrefs' free Website Authority Checker shows your DR.
- The gap: If page one needs about 10 to 20 linking sites and you have 15, you're in range. If it needs 300 and you have 15, that keyword is a long-term project.
Two cautions. These counts come from one company's index, which never matches Google's exactly. And for local "near me" type searches, the tool scores the whole country while real results change by neighborhood, so check 2 matters more than the number. How to earn links safely: backlinks for a local business.
Check 4: does your page match what searchers want?
Google's systems try to return "the highest quality and most relevant" results, judged by "hundreds of factors", including "the user's location, language, and device" (Google Search Central: How Google Search works). In practice, look at what kind of page wins:
- Top results are service pages with prices and a phone number: a service page can rank; a blog post likely won't.
- Top results are how-to articles: a service page likely won't rank, whatever its links.
- Top results are lists of companies: searchers want to compare; a directory listing may get you there faster than your own page.
If your page is the wrong kind, the keyword isn't obtainable for that page. Build the right page or pick another keyword. What a strong service page needs: on-page SEO for service pages.
Google Keyword Planner's "Competition" is about ads
Keyword Planner shows Low, Medium or High competition, but that is not about ranking for free. Google's own definition:
"The competition level indicates how competitive ad placement is for a keyword and is determined by the number of advertisers bidding on that keyword relative to all keywords across Google." (Google Ads API: KeywordPlanCompetitionLevelEnum)
Use Keyword Planner for search volume ideas; never as a difficulty score. Finding keywords in the first place: keyword research for a local business.
Example
Illustrative cases. Numbers are invented.
A roofer in Denver (US dollars)
"Roofing company" shows KD 45 and the roofer's site has DR 12. The formula says 3.75, "hard". But Search Console shows "roof leak repair Denver" at position 14 with 300 impressions a month, and page one holds four local roofers with 10 to 30 linking sites each. The roofer has 18. That phrase is within reach now; at roughly $800 a repair job, two extra calls a month pay for the work.
A Calgary bookkeeper
"Bookkeeping" is held by national software brands and big publishers. "Bookkeeper for contractors Calgary" shows three small firms on page one and the bookkeeper already appears at position 22. She builds one page for it and leaves the broad term alone.
A new dog groomer
The site is three months old with no links and no Search Console data. Every check points to the map results and two or three narrow phrases ("mobile dog grooming" plus the town), not broad keywords.
FAQ
What is a good keyword obtainability score?
There isn't a standard one. Each tool scores differently, and ratio formulas mix two curved scales. Whether sites like yours already rank on page one is a better test than any single number.
Is a low Domain Rating why my site doesn't rank?
Not by itself. Google doesn't use DR or Domain Authority. A low DR often reflects few links, which do matter, but relevance, page type and, for local searches, distance can matter more.
Should a new website avoid high-difficulty keywords?
Mostly, at first. Aim for narrow phrases where small sites already rank, then broaden as your pages start showing up in Search Console.
Do I need a paid SEO tool to judge this?
No. Search Console, a private search from your area and Ahrefs' free checkers cover the four checks. Paid tools save time across hundreds of keywords.
Different for you?
- You don't have a keyword list yet: keyword research for a local business.
- Your business depends on map results: rank higher on Google Maps.
- Check 3 shows a big link gap: backlinks for a local business.
- Check 4 shows your page is the wrong kind: on-page SEO for service pages.
- You'd rather have the research and the pages done for you: SEO & GEO Agent.