Local SEO audit: which fixes come first
An audit only helps if it tells you what to fix first. Put every problem you find into one of four groups and work from the top. Inside a group, start with whatever touches the most customers.
| Order | Group | Examples | Why it's in this place |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Broken: people who find you can't reach you | Wrong phone number, wrong hours, old address, two profiles for one location, a suspended profile | You lose customers who already chose you |
| 2 | Hidden: Google can't show you | Unverified profile, key pages not indexed, a manual action on your site | You don't appear at all |
| 3 | Mismatched: you show for the wrong searches | A vague business category, services missing from the profile, no page for a service you sell | You appear, but not to people who want that job |
| 4 | Outranked: rivals win the same search | Fewer or older reviews, few links from local websites | You compete and lose |
Accuracy sits at the top because Google ties it to whether you show at all:
"If your business info isn't accurate, your Business Profile might not show up for relevant searches in your area." (Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google)
Polish (speed scores, Code on a page that states facts like your business name, hours and prices in a format search engines read reliably. More, more directories) comes after all four.
How to do a local SEO audit, step by step
Keep one sheet open while you work. For each problem, write the group (1 to 4) next to it. Every tool below is free.
1. Search like a customer
On your phone, search your business name. Then search the service plus your town, such as "water heater repair Fresno". Repeat from two or three neighborhoods you serve, or have staff search from job sites.
Why more than one place: Google ranks local results partly on distance from each searcher, and "If a customer doesn't share where they are, Google uses what it knows about their location" (Your free business listing on Google Search and Maps: hours, photos, reviews, services and contact details. More Help). Your rank at the office says little about the far side of town.
Write down the three businesses that show next to you most often. They are your yardstick for the rest of the audit. If you don't show even for your own name, that's group 2: see Business Profile not showing.
2. Check the Business Profile itself
| Check | Google's rule | Group if wrong |
|---|---|---|
| The phone rings your business | The number "must be under the direct control of the business" | 1 |
| Hours are current | List your "regular customer-facing hours"; appointment-only businesses shouldn't list hours | 1 |
| The address is a place you work | A rented mailing address you don't operate from (a virtual office) "isn't eligible" | 1 |
| One profile per location | "Do not create more than one page for each location of your business" | 1 |
| The name matches your sign | Extra words "could result in the suspension of your Business Profile" | 1 |
| The profile is verified | Verified profiles are "more likely to show up in search results" | 2 |
| Categories are specific and match what rivals use | Add "the most specific categories for your business" | 3 |
Rules quoted from Google Business Profile Help. To find a duplicate, search Google Maps for your name, old name and old address. Then open Profile Strength: on verified profiles it lists missing details such as description, hours and contact info (Google Business Profile Help).
3. Read your profile's Performance report
The Performance report (verified profiles only) lists "The search terms people used to find your business", refreshed at the start of each month (Google Business Profile Help). Read that list. If your best-paying service never appears, that's group 3: add it to your profile's services and give it its own page on your site.
Then note calls, website clicks and direction requests for recent months. If you advertise, these mix in ad results:
"Performance data includes views, searches, and actions from both organic search results and Google Ads." (Google Business Profile Help)
4. Compare reviews with your three rivals
For you and each rival, note the number of Google reviews, the average rating, the date of the newest review, and whether the owner replies. Google says "More reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking" and "Positive reviews and helpful replies can help your business stand out" (Google Business Profile Help).
A big gap is group 4. Close it by asking every customer, within the rules for asking for reviews. If you find fake or unfair reviews, see responding to negative reviews.
5. Check your website in Search Console
| Report | What to look for | Group if wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Pages (indexing) | Home page and every service page are indexed | 2 |
| Manual actions | No issues listed | 2 |
| Search results, by query | Searches with your town or service in them | 3 |
| Links, Top linking sites | Sites you recognize, including local ones | 4 |
With a manual action, "some or all of that site may not be shown in Google Search results" (Google Search Central: How to use Google's free tool that shows which searches bring people to your site and flags pages Google can't index. More). The Links report shows "a sample", not every link (Search Console Help). Few local sites linking to you is group 4: see backlinks for a local business. New to the tool? See Search Console for a small business.
Then open your site on your phone and check by eye: the name, address and phone match your profile, and each service you want booked has its own page. If you built one page per town with only the town name swapped, Google lists "pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page" as doorway abuse (Google Search Central: Spam policies). See city pages for service areas.
6. Check your other listings
Open your Yelp, Bing Places, Apple Business (Apple Maps; it replaced Business Connect in 2026, per Apple Newsroom) and Facebook listings, plus your trade's main directory. A wrong phone or address on any of them is group 1. Which directories matter: local citations and directories.
7. Make sure you can measure the fixes
Can you say how many calls and bookings came from Google last month? If not, set that up before you change anything, or you won't know which fix worked: GA4 key events.
What to skip in a local SEO audit
Many audit templates still carry advice Google has dropped or never gave.
| Common audit item | What Google says now |
|---|---|
| Run Google's Mobile-Friendly Test | Gone: "The Mobile Friendly Test and the Mobile Usability report have been retired" (Google Search Central Blog, December 1, 2023). Use your own phone. |
| Disavow "toxic" links a tool flagged | Most sites "will not need to use this tool"; it's for spammy links that caused, or will likely cause, a manual action (Search Console Help) |
| Trim titles to 60 characters and descriptions to 160 | Google sets no length limit for either; it shortens them to fit the screen (Google Search Central) |
| Add star-rating markup for your own reviews | Pages where a business controls reviews about itself "are ineligible for star review feature" (Google Search Central) |
| Answer questions in your profile's Q&A | Google shut its Q&A API on November 3, 2025 while "updating the Q&A functionality" (Google for Developers). If your profile shows no Q&A, skip it. |
| Chase a perfect speed score | A good score "doesn't guarantee that your pages will rank at the top" (Google Search Central). Fix pages that fail. |
| Trust a tool's "authority" or "visibility" score | "Third-party tools don't have access to our internal ranking data" (Google Search Central) |
| Post more on social media to rank | See what Google says about social signals |
How often should you do a local SEO audit?
Do the full audit once, then take a short look each month. That matches Google's data: profile search terms update monthly, and Google suggests checking Search Console "around once every month, or when you make changes to the site's content" (Google Search Central).
Redo the full audit after a move, a new phone number, service, name or website, or a sudden drop in calls.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A plumber whose calls dropped (US dollars)
Profile calls fell from 40 a month to 10. The profile phone is an old tracking number that rings an unused line, the category is "Contractor", and rivals have twice his reviews. Order: phone today (group 1), category this week (group 3), review requests from now on (group 4). At $300 a job, the phone cost the most.
A dental clinic in Calgary (Canadian dollars)
The clinic has 45 reviews against rivals' 200 to 400, and the owner wants a review drive. But the implant page, which sells $4,000 treatments, isn't indexed: group 2, so it goes first.
A landscaper who only shows for his own name
His profile's search terms are all his business name. His category is broad, rivals show "Landscaper", and his site has one "Services" page. All group 3: change the category, list his services, and give lawn care, patios and tree work a page each.
FAQ
What's the difference between a local SEO audit and a regular SEO audit?
A regular audit checks your website. A local audit adds what drives map results (your Business Profile, reviews, distance to searchers), plus other listings.
Can I do a local SEO audit for free?
Yes: Business Profile, Search Console and a phone cover it. Paid tools like Moz Local manage many listings at once but lack Google's ranking data.
Should I disavow the toxic links my audit tool found?
Usually not. Google says most sites never need it; see Google manual actions if you have one.
Can I pay Google for a better local ranking?
No. Google: "There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." Ads buy ad space, not rank.
Different for you?
- Your profile doesn't show at all: Business Profile not showing.
- Your profile was suspended: how to appeal.
- You're starting from scratch, or got a quote for a paid audit: local SEO checklist.
- A rival's listing looks fake: report fake Google listings.
- Key pages show "not indexed": crawled or discovered, currently not indexed.
- You'd rather have the audit done and the fixes made: SEO & GEO Agent.