Local SEO services: agency, DIY or AI for a small business
Short answer Local SEO providers averaged $1,557 a month in Ahrefs' survey. Doing it yourself costs $0 to about $140 a month in tools, plus your hours. AI services take the routine work. Pick by how many hours you can give. Whoever does it, you still collect the reviews, keep ownership of your Google profile, and can't buy a better ranking.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callLocal SEO services: the three ways, compared
Local SEO is the work that gets a business into Google Maps and the "near me" results: the Google Business Profile, service pages, directory listings and reviews. You can pay someone to do it, do it yourself with a tool, or use an AI service that does the routine parts.
| Agency or freelancer | You, with a tool | AI service | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | Local SEO averaged $1,557 (agencies $1,819, freelancers $1,150) (Ahrefs) | $0 with Google's free tools; $41–$65 for a local tool (BrightLocal); $139 for a full SEO suite (Semrush) | No public price survey yet; compare the monthly work list |
| Your time | Some time each month to approve and review | Most of the hours are yours | Approving changes, plus the tasks below that only you can do |
| Who writes and changes things | A person | You | Software, ideally with your sign-off |
| Fits | Several locations, a new website, or no time at all | One location and a few spare hours a week | Steady routine work: pages, posts, listing checks |
Ahrefs' figures are what 439 SEO providers worldwide say they charge, last updated August 15, 2024; the most common hourly rate for local SEO was $75–$100 (Ahrefs). Some tool companies also sell done-for-you service: Whitespark lists its SEO service at $499 to $1,999 a month (Whitespark).
Canada: where the Ahrefs survey splits out countries, it groups the US and Canada together, and BrightLocal and Whitespark price in US dollars (BrightLocal). Check the currency on every quote.
What a local SEO service should do each month
Whichever path you choose, the work is the same list. Use it to compare quotes.
| Task | Agency | You with a tool | AI service |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keep the Google Business Profile complete: categories, hours, services, photos, posts | Yes | Yes; the tool flags gaps | Text and posts yes; real photos come from you |
| One page per service, and per area you truly serve | Yes | Yes, if you can write | Yes; check every page before it goes live |
| Same name, address and phone on Yelp, Bing and directories | Yes | The tool finds mismatches; you fix them | Often |
| Ask customers for reviews | Sets up the link and texts | You | Sends requests; customers write the reviews |
| Reply to reviews | Drafts, you approve | You | Drafts, you approve |
| Monthly report: calls, direction requests, rankings | Yes | Tool reports | Yes |
Google's own list of what SEO providers offer includes "Expertise in specific markets and geographies" and "Optimizing for generative AI" (Google Search Central). Ask any provider which items you get and how many hours each takes. The full task order is in the local SEO checklist.
The parts nobody can do for you
Three things stay with the owner, whatever you pay.
Ranking can't be bought. Google says:
"There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." (Google Business Profile Help)
Local results depend mainly on "relevance, distance, and popularity" (same page). No provider can move your shop closer to a searcher.
Reviews come from your customers. Google counts "how many reviews you have," and "More reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking" (Google Business Profile Help). A provider can send the request; you or your staff still have to ask at the end of the job. In the US, paying for reviews of a set tone is illegal under the FTC's rule, which bans giving "compensation or other incentives" for reviews "expressing a particular sentiment" (16 CFR 465.4). More: asking for reviews rules.
Ownership. Stay the owner of your Business Profile and add the provider as a manager. Owners have "full control" and can "add or remove users"; managers can't add or remove users or remove the profile (Google Business Profile Help). For a first audit, Google advises giving an SEO only "read access to Search Console" (Google Search Central).
Can a small business do local SEO itself?
Often, yes. Google says so plainly:
"If you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself." (Google Search Central)
The profile, Search Console and Google's Starter Guide are free. What DIY really costs is hours, and patience: Google says some changes "could take several months" to show (SEO Starter Guide). A paid tool saves checking time but does none of the writing or fixing.
When an agency is worth the fee
When the work is bigger than one profile and a few pages: several locations, a website rebuild, or ads alongside SEO. Google calls a redesign "a great time to hire" (Google Search Central). Before you sign, ask Google's question: "Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site" (same page). How to compare agencies, freelancers and hires: SEO agency vs freelancer vs in-house vs AI.
What AI handles, and what to check
AI suits the repeat work: drafting service pages, profile posts, review replies and listing checks. Its weak spot is facts only you know, like the areas you serve, prices and licenses. Ask for an approval step so nothing goes live unread. What AI can and can't do in SEO: Can AI do SEO?
Red flags in any local SEO offer
- A ranking promise. "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Google Search Central)
- A cold email or call. Google says to "Be wary of SEO firms and web consultants or agencies that email you out of the blue." (same page)
- An offer to buy or write reviews (see the FTC rule above).
- A request to be made owner of your Business Profile instead of manager.
Example
A dog groomer with one shop
Has three free hours a week. Does the profile and review requests herself; a $41 local tool flags listing mismatches. About $500 a year in tools.
A plumber covering five towns
No spare time. Pays a freelancer $1,200 a month for service and town pages, listing cleanup and a monthly report. Stays owner of the profile; the freelancer is a manager. Asks for a Google review on every invoice.
A two-office accounting practice
Uses an AI service for profile posts and page drafts, and approves each one. Pays an agency a one-off fee to merge two old websites. Reviews stay with the partners.
FAQ
How much does local SEO cost per month?
Providers in Ahrefs' 2024 survey averaged $1,557 a month for local SEO. Doing it yourself costs $0 in Google's tools, or about $40–$140 a month with a paid tool.
Is local SEO worth paying for?
When one new customer covers the monthly fee and you can wait a few months for results. If you'd need many new customers to break even, start with the free profile and reviews. See how much SEO costs.
Should I give my SEO company owner access to my Google profile?
No. Add them as a manager. Managers can edit info, reply to reviews and post, but can't remove users or delete the profile.
Can a local SEO service get me into the top three on Google Maps?
No one can promise it. Google says there's no way to pay for a better local ranking, and distance to the searcher is one of the main factors.
Different for you?
- Want the task list in order: Local SEO checklist
- Comparing outside prices in detail: How much SEO costs
- Choosing between agency, freelancer and hire: SEO agency vs freelancer vs in-house vs AI
- Holding a contract now: Marketing agency contract terms
- Your Maps ranking is the problem: How to rank higher on Google Maps
- Want the routine work done for you: SEO & GEO