Neil Patel's hiring strategy: hire proven talent from rivals
Short answer Neil Patel's tip is to hire people your competitors kept promoting, since repeated promotions suggest they deliver. It's legal in the US and Canada, but read every agreement they signed, have them bring no files or client lists, and never agree with a rival not to hire each other's staff. That last one is a crime.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callNeil Patel's hiring strategy in one line
Look for people who have been promoted again and again at your competitors, and hire them. On his Marketing School podcast, Patel and co-host Eric Siu put it this way:
"If someone who works for one or more of your competitors has been promoted multiple times, the chances are they are a good marketer." (Marketing School, episode 2386, March 2023)
The logic holds for any trade, not just marketing. A rival already paid to train this person, and a manager there kept choosing to give them more. You skip months of learning your market, your customers and your tools.
It works best for roles where industry knowledge is the slow part to learn: an estimator at a roofing company, a hygienist who knows your patients' insurers, an account manager at an agency. It matters less for roles any good person learns fast.
Is it legal to hire from a competitor?
Yes. In both countries a worker may change jobs, and you may offer one. The risk isn't the hire. It's three things around it:
| Risk | Who can come after you | How to avoid it |
|---|---|---|
| A non-compete they signed | Their old employer, in a lawsuit | Read it before the offer; check the law where they work |
| Files, price lists or client lists they bring | Their old employer, under trade secret law | Tell them in writing to bring nothing |
| A deal with the rival not to hire each other's staff | Prosecutors in the US and Canada | Never make one, even a handshake |
Does their non-compete stop me?
It depends on where they work, and it changed recently.
- US, federal: there is no nationwide ban. The FTC's 2024 rule never took effect; a court blocked it, and on September 5, 2025 the FTC voted 3–1 to drop its appeal and accept that ruling (FTC press release).
- California: non-competes are void, and the law reaches contracts signed anywhere.
"Any contract that is void under this chapter is unenforceable regardless of where and when the contract was signed." (California Business and Professions Code 16600.5)
- Minnesota: "Any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable" (Minnesota Statutes 181.988), with exceptions for selling or closing a business.
- Other states: the rules differ. Many enforce a non-compete if a court finds it reasonable. Have a lawyer in that state read it.
- Ontario: employers can't make new non-competes.
"Effective October 25, 2021 employers are prohibited from entering into employment contracts or other agreements with an employee that include a non-compete agreement." (Ontario, Your guide to the Employment Standards Act)
Two exceptions: chief executives (CEO, CFO and similar), and a seller who joins the buyer after selling a business. Agreements signed before that date aren't covered by the ban.
- Rest of Canada: Ontario's ban is provincial. Ask a lawyer in your province.
Two clauses outlive a non-compete ban. A non-solicit bars someone from pursuing their old employer's clients or staff. A non-disclosure agreement (NDA) bars sharing confidential information. Ontario's guide says its law "does not prohibit non-solicit agreements or non-disclosure agreements." So even a hire who is free to work for you may not be free to call their old customers.
What can't they bring with them?
Skills and experience, yes. Their old employer's files, no. US federal trade secret law covers not only the person who takes the secret but anyone who gets it while knowing, or having "reason to know," it was taken improperly (18 U.S.C. 1839, the Defend Trade Secrets Act). A new hire who arrives with a customer spreadsheet makes that your problem too.
Put it in the offer letter: bring no documents, devices, price lists, customer lists or logins from your old job. Then don't ask them for any.
The one move that is a crime: no-poach deals
Hiring a rival's staff is fine. Agreeing with a rival not to is not.
- US: the DOJ and FTC guidelines say agreements between companies "not to recruit, solicit, or hire workers" may violate antitrust law and can mean felony charges for companies and individuals. They add that such an agreement doesn't have to be written down.
- Canada: since 2023, the Competition Act makes it an offence for unrelated employers to agree "to not solicit or hire each other's employees." The penalty is up to 14 years in prison, a fine set by the court, or both (Competition Act, section 45).
So if a competitor calls and says "let's not steal each other's people," say no.
How to find and vet a candidate
- Search LinkedIn for current and past staff of the competitors your customers compare you with. Note anyone with two or more promotions.
- Treat titles as a lead, not proof. Ask what they did, with numbers: jobs closed, revenue kept, complaints cut. Check they fit how your smaller team works, too.
- Ask for every agreement they signed with their current employer before you make an offer. Have your lawyer read them.
- Offer what a bigger rival can't match, such as a clearer path up, more say in decisions, or flexible hours, if you can't win on pay alone.
- Plan the first 90 days. Write down what success looks like, who they report to, and which clients they may and may not contact.
Example
A roofing company in Ohio
The owner wants an estimator who already knows local storm-claim work. A rival's estimator was promoted twice in four years. Her contract has a one-year, 50-mile non-compete. Ohio has no blanket ban, so the owner pays a lawyer about $500 to review it before making an offer.
A dental office in California
The office hires a front-desk lead from the practice down the street. Her old contract has a non-compete. Under California law it is void, so it doesn't stop her. Her NDA still applies, so she starts with an empty notebook, not the old patient list.
A marketing agency in Toronto
An account manager signed a non-compete in 2022. Under Ontario's law that clause is barred, since he is not an executive. His non-solicit may still stop him from pitching his old clients, so the agency keeps him on new accounts for the first year.
FAQ
Can my competitor sue me for hiring their employee?
They can sue if they believe you broke a valid agreement, or used their trade secrets. Hiring a person who is free to work for you, with no files, is not by itself wrong.
Can my new hire bring their clients?
Clients may follow someone on their own. But if the hire signed a non-solicit, asking those clients to switch may breach it. Check the clause first.
Should I make my own staff sign non-competes?
Not in California, Minnesota or Ontario, where they are banned for most workers. Elsewhere, ask a lawyer. The DOJ and FTC guidelines say that even overly broad NDAs and non-solicits may break antitrust law.
Does a promotion record really mean someone is good?
It's a signal that a manager kept trusting them, not proof. Confirm it with specific results and references.
Different for you?
- You need more sales capacity, not one star hire: see scale sales without hiring.
- The role is marketing: compare an agency, freelancer, in-house hire or AI, or the alternatives to an agency.
- You want a mixed human and AI team: see AI marketing strategy.
- New leads go unanswered while you hire: see the Conversion agent.