Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

PageRank sculpting: why nofollow tricks stopped working

Updated · 6 min read

Short answer It doesn't work. Since about 2008, a nofollowed link on your own page still takes its share of that page's value; the share is simply lost, not passed to your other links. Google advises letting PageRank flow freely within your site. Link to the pages that earn you money from your menu, home page and related pages instead.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Does PageRank sculpting still work?

No. Putting `nofollow` on some of your own links no longer pushes more value through the others. Google changed the math around 2008, and Google's Matt Cutts explained it on his blog in June 2009.

His example: a page holds 10 points of PageRank and has 10 links, 5 of them nofollowed.

Each followed link passesThe 5 nofollowed links
Before the change2 pointsDidn't count, so their share went to the other 5
After the change (about 2008 to today)1 pointStill count, and their share is lost
"More than a year ago, Google changed how the PageRank flows so that the five links without nofollow would flow one point of PageRank each." (Matt Cutts, Google: PageRank sculpting, 2009)

So the trick went from "move value" to "throw value away". His advice in the same post:

"In general, I would let PageRank flow freely within your site." (Matt Cutts, Google: PageRank sculpting, 2009)

What is PageRank sculpting?

It was the practice of adding `rel="nofollow"` to internal links you thought didn't matter (About, Contact, Privacy) so the value of each page would go only to the pages you wanted to rank, like service or product pages.

A few terms:

  • PageRank: Google's way of scoring a page by the links pointing to it. Google's ranking guide calls it "one of our core ranking systems used when Google first launched" and says it "continues to be part of our core ranking systems", though it "has evolved a lot since then".
  • Link equity (or "link juice"): SEO slang for the value a link passes. It isn't a Google term.
  • Nofollow: a label on a link that tells Google not to count it as your endorsement.

When did nofollow sculpting stop working?

YearWhat happenedSource
2005Nofollow introduced to fight comment spamGoogle Search Central Blog, 2019
About 2008Nofollowed links start counting toward the split; their share is lostMatt Cutts, 2009
June 2009Google explains the change publiclyMatt Cutts, 2009
September 2019Nofollow becomes a "hint" for ranking; `sponsored` and `ugc` addedGoogle Search Central Blog, 2019
March 1, 2020Nofollow also becomes a hint for crawling and indexingGoogle Search Central Blog, 2019

Cutts gave the reason for the 2008 change: some sites that tried to steer PageRank ended up cutting off sections with high-quality information, such as user forums.

Since 2019, Google may still use a nofollowed link if it decides to. So nofollow isn't even a reliable switch anymore.

Is PageRank sculpting against Google's rules?

Not by name. Google's spam policies list link schemes such as buying links, but don't mention nofollow on internal links. Cutts called sculpting "a second- or third-order recommendation", not a spam issue. The cost is wasted value, not a penalty.

What Google does require is the opposite case: a paid link pointing to another site must be labeled.

"It's not a violation of our policies to have such links as long as they are qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" attribute value" (Google Search Central: Spam policies)

When should you use nofollow today?

On links to other sites, to describe your relationship with them. Not to steer value inside your own site.

LinkUseGoogle's words
Paid placement or ad`rel="sponsored"`"advertisements or paid placements"
Comments, forum posts, reviews visitors write`rel="ugc"`"user-generated content (UGC) links"
Any other outside link you don't want to vouch for`rel="nofollow"`"when other values don't apply"
A page on your own site you don't want crawled (cart, login)robots.txt `disallow`"For links within your own site, use the robots.txt disallow rule."
A page you don't want in search results`noindex`"To prevent Google from indexing a page, allow crawling and use the noindex robots rule."

All quotes above are from Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links. One caution from Google's robots.txt guide: robots.txt "is not a mechanism for keeping a web page out of Google". Google says a blocked page can still be indexed if other sites link to it. Use `noindex` for that.

With plain links people can see and click. Cutts's 2009 advice still matches Google's current guidance: make sure people and bots can reach your pages by clicking links.

  1. Link every page you care about. Google's link guide: "Every page you care about should have a link from at least one other page on your site."
  2. Put money pages in reach. Link your main services from the menu and home page, not three clicks deep.
  3. Link related pages to each other. A water heater repair page links to water heater installation, and back.
  4. Use words that describe the page as the link text: "drain cleaning prices", not "click here". Google says link text "tells people and Google something about the page you're linking to".
  5. Use real links. Google says it can generally only crawl a link if it is a standard HTML link (an `a` element with an `href` address). Menus built only with JavaScript click handlers can hide pages.
  6. Check the result. In Search Console, open Links, then the top internally linked pages table. Google suggests using it to "Confirm that the core site pages (home page, contact page) are properly linked within your site."

For the page itself, see on-page SEO for service pages. Value from other sites linking to you matters more than how you split it inside; see backlinks for a local business.

Example

Illustrative cases with invented numbers.

A plumber's old theme

A 2010-era theme adds nofollow to the About, Contact and Privacy links on all 40 pages. The owner removes it. Nothing is lost: those shares were being thrown away anyway.

A dental clinic with buried implant pages

The implant page, worth about $4,000 a case, is reachable only from a blog post. The clinic adds it to the Services menu and links it from the home page and the crown and bridge pages. That does what sculpting promised, by the rules.

An HVAC company with a parts store

The store creates thousands of cart and filter URLs. Instead of nofollowing every cart link, the owner disallows `/cart/` in robots.txt and keeps product pages linked from category pages.

FAQ

Should I remove nofollow from my internal links?

Usually yes, on links to normal pages. It gains you nothing there, and since 2019 Google treats it as a hint it may ignore anyway.

Does nofollow on my About or Contact page boost my service pages?

No. Since about 2008, the value of a nofollowed link is lost, not moved to your other links.

Is PageRank still used by Google?

Yes. Google's ranking guide says it "continues to be part of our core ranking systems", in a form that has changed a lot since launch.

Do footer and sidebar links count?

Yes, if they are standard HTML links, which Google says it can generally crawl. Add them where they help a visitor find the next step.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextAnchor text: what it is and how to write itAnchor text is the clickable wording of a link. The types SEO tools name, what Google says good anchor text looks like, and when keyword links become spam.

Do it yourself

On-page SEO checklist: every item to check before publishingA pre-publish on-page SEO checklist for one new page: content, title, headings, URL, images, links, indexing, mobile and speed, plus what to do after launch.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Matt Cutts (Google): PageRank sculpting, June 15, 2009
  2. Google Search Central Blog: Evolving "nofollow", September 10, 2019
  3. Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links to Google
  4. Google Search Central: A guide to Google Search ranking systems
  5. Google Search Central: Link best practices for Google
  6. Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search
  7. Google Search Central: Introduction to robots.txt
  8. Search Console Help: Links report