Reviews and comparison pages for hosting and SaaS companies
Short answer Ask every customer for a review at the same point, never only the happy ones, and never tie a reward to a good rating. G2 allows labeled gift cards up to $100; Trustpilot bans incentives. On a vs page, compare only what you can prove, date it, and say who the competitor suits better.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe rule: ask everyone, pay for nothing that depends on the rating
Hosting and software buyers check review sites before they hand over a credit card. A web host is judged on Trustpilot; a SaaS tool on G2. Each platform sets its own rules, and the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sets a floor under all of them:
| Trustpilot | G2 | FTC rule (US) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ask customers to review? | Yes, all of them the same way | Yes | Yes |
| Ask only happy customers? | Banned | Banned; reviews removed | Not banned by the rule, but may break the FTC Act |
| Gift card or discount for a review? | Banned | Allowed if disclosed to G2; labeled; $100 max | Allowed if not tied to a positive review; disclose it |
| Employees review the product? | Banned | Banned | Allowed only with a clear disclosure |
| Competitors review you? | Banned | Banned | Fake reviews banned outright |
The strictest column wins. If you collect on both platforms, run Trustpilot's rules everywhere: no rewards, no filtering.
Can you offer a gift card for a G2 or Trustpilot review?
On G2, yes, if G2 knows about it. On Trustpilot, no.
"We don't allow incentivized reviews on Trustpilot." (Trustpilot: Guidelines for businesses)
G2 runs its own gift card offers and marks the result: "If a review is incentivized, G2 will clearly label the review as incentivized." It caps any reward at $100 and bans "independently incentivizing reviewers without disclosing those incentives to G2" (G2: Community guidelines). So a free month of hosting you hand out yourself, unreported, breaks G2's rules even if the reviews are honest. The same guidelines now cover Capterra, Software Advice and GetApp.
The FTC's line is about sentiment, not money:
"The rule does not prohibit giving incentives for reviews, as long as there isn't an express or implied requirement that the reviews have to express a particular sentiment." (FTC: Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule Q&A)
The same page warns that "failing to disclose incentives could be a violation of the FTC Act."
Who to ask, and when
Trustpilot asks you to invite "everyone in the same way, and at the same point in the customer journey," and bans timing invitations so only people with a good experience reach them. That rules out the common software trick of asking only after a customer clicks a happy face in a survey. G2 calls it "segments out potentially negative reviews" and bans it too.
Pick one trigger for every customer and automate it:
| Business | A fair trigger |
|---|---|
| Web or game server host | 30 days after the first invoice |
| SaaS on a free trial | After the first paid month, not during the trial |
| SaaS with yearly contracts | At each renewal, win or lose |
| Any | Never only after a 5-star support rating |
Give people time to use the product first; Trustpilot asks for that too. Write the request in neutral words ("Tell others what it's like to use us"), never "If you love us, leave 5 stars". More on wording and text consent: asking for reviews.
What the FTC rule bans
The FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule took effect on October 21, 2024, and "authorizes courts to impose civil penalties for knowing violations" (FTC Q&A). For a hosting or software company, the parts that bite:
- Fake reviews. Writing, buying or selling reviews from people who never used the product.
- Rewards tied to praise. Even implied: "you can't suggest to consumers that their reviews must be positive."
- Insider reviews. Staff and their families may review only with a clear disclosure. Managers who ask staff to round up reviews are expected to check for it.
- Fake "independent" comparison sites. A business can't misrepresent that a site it controls "provides independent reviews or opinions" about its category. A disclaimer can't cure an express claim of independence.
- Review suppression. Hiding negative reviews on your own site. Sorting them is fine: "Organizing reviews is not suppressing reviews under the rule."
Paying a customer to take down a bad review isn't banned by the rule, but the FTC says it "could be an unfair practice." Answer the review instead: responding to negative reviews.
Canada: no rule names reviews, but the Competition Act bans any public representation "false or misleading in a material respect" (section 74.01). The Competition Bureau says staff reviews are a problem when the tie isn't disclosed, "even if the person provides an honest and unbiased review" (Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest, Volume 1).
How to write an honest vs page
A page titled "YourHost vs BigHost" catches buyers who are already choosing. It works only if a skeptical buyer believes it. The FTC backs comparisons that are true:
"Comparative advertising, when truthful and nondeceptive, is a source of important information to consumers and assists them in making rational purchase decisions." (FTC: Policy statement on comparative advertising)
Google's guidance for review pages asks you to "Discuss the benefits and drawbacks" and to "explain which might be best for certain uses or circumstances" (Google Search Central: Write high quality reviews). Built into a vs page:
- Date it. "Prices and plans as of November 2026." Competitor pricing changes; a stale page reads as a lie.
- Compare facts a buyer can check. Price per month, RAM per plan, data center regions, backup retention, contract terms. Link the competitor's own pricing page.
- Back every performance claim with a test. "Faster" or "99.99% uptime vs their 99.9%" needs your own measurements, method stated. In Canada, a performance claim must rest on "an adequate and proper test," and the advertiser carries the proof (Competition Act, section 74.01(1)(b)).
- Say where they win. "Pick BigHost if you need servers in Asia; we only run US and EU." This line is what makes the rest believable.
- Don't paste their review stars. G2's terms forbid republishing "the aggregated Star Rating of another seller's products" or reviews from their profile. Link to their G2 page instead.
- One page per real competitor. Twenty near-identical pages with the name swapped help nobody. Write the ones buyers actually ask about.
Page structure and titles: on-page SEO for service pages.
Can you bid on a competitor's name in Google Ads?
Yes, as a keyword. Google's trademark policy says it will not restrict "Using trademarks as keywords." If the trademark owner complains, it will restrict "Using trademarks in an ad from a direct competitor" (Google Ads Help: Trademarks policy). So bid on "BigHost alternative", keep their name out of the ad text, and send the click to your vs page. Basics: Google Ads for small business.
Can you show star ratings from your own reviews in Google?
Not for your company itself. Google's review snippet rules say that if "the entity that's being reviewed controls the reviews about itself," its pages using LocalBusiness or Organization markup "are ineligible for star review feature." Google also bans marking up reviews pulled from other sites or undisclosed incentivized ones (Google Search Central: Review snippet). Show your Trustpilot or G2 badge on the page; just don't expect stars in search results from it.
Example
Illustrative cases, not real companies.
A game server host with 2,000 customers
It sends a Trustpilot invite to every customer 30 days after their first invoice, with no reward. It stops a script that only emailed customers who rated support 5 out of 5.
A five-person SaaS company on G2
It joins a G2 gift card offer, so each review shows the incentive label. It does not hand out its own $50 credits for reviews.
A Canadian VPS host writing "vs BigHost"
It states prices as of November 2026, links both pricing pages, and publishes its uptime test method. It says BigHost is the better pick for Windows servers, which it doesn't offer.
FAQ
Can my staff leave reviews on G2 or Trustpilot?
No. Both platforms ban reviews from the company's own employees, disclosed or not.
Is a vs page that names a competitor legal?
In the US, the FTC supports comparisons that are truthful and clearly say what is being compared. Canada bans materially misleading claims and requires proof for performance claims.
Can I ask a customer to update a bad review after I fix the problem?
You can reply and ask once. G2 bans pressuring a reviewer to change a review, and the FTC warns that paying for removal may be unfair.
Do G2 and Trustpilot reviews help in ChatGPT answers?
No assistant publishes how it picks sources, so treat reviews as one input among many. See how to get ChatGPT to recommend your business.
Different for you?
- Your customers are local, and Google reviews matter more: asking for reviews.
- A bad review is already up: responding to negative reviews.
- You want buyers comparing tools to find you in AI answers: get ChatGPT to recommend your business.
- Want vs pages and review requests set up and kept current: SEO & GEO Agent.