Site content analysis: how to review every page on your site
Short answer Put every page of your site in one spreadsheet, add each page's Google clicks and leads, then score it on four things: purpose, accuracy, demand and business. The score gives each page one verdict: keep, update, merge or delete. A small service business site takes an afternoon with free tools: Search Console, Google Analytics and a free crawler.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe method: one row per page, one verdict per row
A site content analysis (also called a content audit or content inventory) is a list of every page you publish, with the facts you need to judge it, and a decision for each. It is not a crawl report full of warnings. It answers one question per page: is this page worth keeping as it is?
Google asks site owners to do exactly this:
"Check in on previously published content and update it as needed, or even delete it if it's not relevant anymore." (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide)
Build one spreadsheet with these columns:
| Column | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| Address (URL) | Your site builder, sitemap or a crawler (step 1) |
| Page type | You: service, location, blog, about, contact, landing page |
| Clicks and impressions from Google, last 16 months | Search Console, Performance, Pages tab (step 2) |
| Leads (calls, forms, bookings) | Google Analytics, Landing page report (step 2) |
| Last real edit | Your site builder |
| Score: purpose, accuracy, demand, business | You (step 3) |
| Verdict and the one fix | You (step 4) |
Step 1: list every page
Use the most complete list you can get, then merge them and remove duplicates.
- Your site builder's page list. WordPress, Wix and Squarespace all show every page and post you made. This is the best start for a small site.
- A crawler. A crawler follows every link on your site the way Google does, so it also finds pages you forgot. Screaming Frog's free version is "restricted to crawling up to 500 URLs in a single crawl"; a licence removing the limit costs €245 a year (Screaming Frog, read November 2026). Most service business sites fit under 500.
- Search Console's Page indexing report. It shows which addresses Google indexed and which it didn't, and why. Don't treat it as your full list: its example list "is limited to 1,000 items, and isn't guaranteed to show all URLs in a given status" (Search Console Help).
Pages that show up in Google but not in your builder are worth a look: old promotions, test pages, or tag and archive pages your builder made on its own.
Step 2: add the numbers
Two free Google tools fill the number columns. Neither needs a paid add-on.
- Google clicks and impressions. In Search Console, open Performance. The report starts with "the past three months" (Search Console Help); change the Date filter to "Last 16 months", the longest it holds, so a seasonal dip doesn't fool you (Google Search Central). Open the Pages tab and export. Impressions are how often a page appeared in results; clicks are visits from Google.
- Leads. In Google Analytics, go to Reports, then "Engagement > Landing page" (Analytics Help). Read the key events column: the number of times visitors did something you marked as a lead, such as a form sent or a call button tapped. If key events show zero everywhere, set them up first: GA4 key events for calls, forms and bookings.
Paste both into your sheet by address. A page missing from the Search Console export most likely had no Google impressions in that time.
Step 3: score each page
Give each page 0, 1 or 2 on four questions. Keep it fast: a minute or two per page.
| Question | 0 | 1 | 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose: does a real customer need this page? | Nobody would miss it | Useful, but another page covers it | It answers a question customers ask you |
| Accuracy: is it true today? | Wrong prices, dropped services, dead links | Mostly right, some old details | Fully current |
| Demand: does Google show it? | No impressions | Impressions, few clicks | Steady clicks |
| Business: does it bring leads? | None, and no clear next step | Some visits go on to contact you | Regular calls, forms or bookings |
For purpose, borrow Google's own test for content made for people:
"After reading your content, will someone leave feeling they've learned enough about a topic to help achieve their goal?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content)
The same page lists a warning sign worth checking site-wide: "Are you producing lots of content on many different topics in hopes that some of it might perform well in search results?" Pages written only to catch a search, for a service you don't sell, score 0 on purpose.
Step 4: turn scores into verdicts
| Pattern | Verdict |
|---|---|
| High purpose, high demand or business, accurate | Keep. Add a clear call or booking link if it lacks one. |
| High purpose, low accuracy | Update at the same address: prices, photos, today's rules. |
| High demand, low business | Fix the page's job: clearer offer and next step, not more words. |
| Two pages answer the same question | Merge into the stronger one and redirect the other. |
| Purpose 0, no demand, no business | Delete, or redirect if a close replacement exists. |
| Customers often ask something no page answers | Write one new page for it. |
Don't panic about near-duplicates. Google says "some duplicate content on a site is normal and it's not a violation of Google's spam policies" (Google Search Central: canonicalization). Merge when two pages split the same customers, not because a tool flagged them.
How to update, merge with a 301 redirect, or delete without losing traffic is covered in content decay: update, merge or delete old pages.
What to fix first
Sort the sheet so the biggest payoff rises to the top:
- Service and location pages with impressions but low business. People already see them; a better offer or next step pays fastest. See on-page SEO for service pages.
- Pages with wrong facts. A wrong price or a service you no longer offer costs trust on every visit.
- Merges. Each one turns two weak pages into one stronger page.
- Blog posts with no demand and no purpose. Delete or leave them; they cost little while they sit.
Which tools you need, and which you don't
| Job | Free option | Paid tools add |
|---|---|---|
| List pages | Site builder list; Screaming Frog up to 500 addresses | Bigger crawls, scheduled runs |
| Google demand | Search Console | Estimates of competitors' traffic |
| Leads per page | Google Analytics | Nothing essential |
| Accuracy and purpose | Your own reading | Nothing replaces it |
Paid suites estimate. Google is plain about it: "Third-party tools don't have access to our internal ranking data" (Google Search Central). For your own pages, Search Console's numbers come from Google itself.
One tool many checklists still name is gone: "The Mobile Friendly Test and the Mobile Usability report have been retired" since December 1, 2023 (Google Search Central Blog). Open your pages on your own phone instead; for speed, see Core Web Vitals.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A landscaper with 38 pages (US dollars)
The sheet shows 9 service pages, 3 town pages and 26 blog posts. "Lawn aeration" has 4,000 impressions a year and 1 lead: it gets a price range and a Book button. Two posts on spring cleanup are merged. Seven posts about a 2021 equipment sale are deleted. Total time: one afternoon.
A physiotherapy clinic (Canadian dollars)
Its "Direct billing" page scores 2 on demand but 0 on accuracy: it still lists an insurer the clinic dropped. Updating that one page, with current fees from C$95, comes before any new writing.
An accounting firm with 140 blog posts
Most posts score 0 on demand and 1 on purpose. Rather than rewrite all of them, the firm updates the 15 tied to services it sells and leaves the rest alone for now.
FAQ
How often should I do a site content analysis?
Once a year, plus whenever you change services, prices or website platform. Keep the sheet and update only the rows that changed.
Is a content audit the same as an SEO audit?
No. An SEO audit finds technical problems: broken links, slow or unindexed pages. A content analysis judges whether each page is worth having. Most sites need both.
Should I delete pages that get no traffic?
Not automatically. A financing or warranty page may get no Google visits but still help customers. Delete only when it also scores 0 on purpose.
Can AI do the scoring for me?
It can summarize pages and flag old dates. It can't know you dropped a service or changed a price, so accuracy and purpose need you.
Different for you?
- Traffic fell sharply across the whole site: traffic dropped after a Google core update.
- Pages show "not indexed" in Search Console: crawled or discovered, currently not indexed.
- You need the Search Console basics first: Search Console for a small business.
- Visitors come but don't call: website not getting leads.
- You'd rather have every page reviewed and fixed for you: SEO & GEO Agent.