Topical Authority Strategy: Measure It and Close the Gaps
Short answer Google publishes no topical authority score, so measure two things yourself. Coverage: list the questions customers ask about each service and mark which ones you and your top three competitors answer well. Results: track each topic's searches and clicks in Search Console. Fill the gaps tied to services you sell first.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callCan you measure topical authority?
Not as one number. Topical authority means your site answers most of what people ask about a subject, so Google trusts it on that subject. Google has no public score for it. Its only system with that name covers news. Google's Search Central blog describes it this way:
"Google developed a system called topic authority that helps determine which expert sources are helpful to someone's newsy query in certain specialized topic areas, such as health, politics, or finance." (Google Search Central Blog: Understanding news topic authority)
For other sites, Google says it ranks page by page and also uses site-wide signals:
"Site-wide signals and classifiers are also used and contribute to our understanding of pages." (Google Search Central: Ranking systems guide)
So you can't read Google's view directly. You can measure what feeds it and what comes out:
| What to measure | Question it answers | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | Do we answer the questions customers ask about this service? | A spreadsheet, built below |
| Coverage vs competitors | Who answers more of them, and better? | Their sites and sitemaps |
| Results | Does Google show us for more of those searches over time? | Search Console |
If a tool shows a "topical authority" score, that is the vendor's own formula, not Google's. Domain Authority is the same kind of outside estimate, built from links.
Step 1: list the questions in each topic
One topic per service you sell. A dentist might have implants, braces and emergency care. An accountant might have bookkeeping, payroll and tax filing. Under each, list every question a buyer asks before hiring someone:
- Questions from calls, emails, chats and sales meetings. These are the best source: they come from people who paid.
- Searches your site already shows up for in Search Console (Performance report, Queries tab). See keyword research with Search Console.
- What Google suggests as you type the service name, and the questions it shows under the results.
Google's own starting point is the same:
"Think about the words that a user might search for to find a piece of your content." (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide)
Group near-duplicates. "How much do braces cost" and "braces price" are one question. Twenty to forty questions per service is a workable list for a local business.
Step 2: see what competitors cover
Pick the three sites that show up most for your services' searches in your area. They may not be the rivals you think of; a directory or a national chain can be the real competitor in search.
The fastest view of a competitor's pages is its sitemap, a file listing the pages it wants Google to find. Try `theirsite.com/sitemap.xml`. If nothing loads, open `theirsite.com/robots.txt` and look for a line starting with "Sitemap:". Google tells site owners to put it there:
"Insert the following line anywhere in your robots.txt file, specifying the path to your sitemap." (Google Search Central: Build and submit a sitemap)
No sitemap? Search `site:theirsite.com braces`. It's a rough view only; Google warns the operator "doesn't necessarily return all the URLs that are indexed under the prefix specified in the query" (Google Search Central: site: operator).
For a deeper teardown, see reverse engineer SEO competitors.
Step 3: build the coverage map
Put each question in a row and score each site from 0 to 2:
- 0: no answer anywhere on the site.
- 1: mentioned, but thin. A line in a list, or the reader still has to call to find out.
- 2: a clear, complete answer a buyer could act on.
| Question (braces) | You | Competitor A | Competitor B | Competitor C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How much do braces cost? | 1 | 2 | 2 | 0 |
| Braces vs clear aligners? | 0 | 2 | 1 | 2 |
| Does insurance cover braces? | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| How long do braces take? | 0 | 2 | 2 | 1 |
Add each column. The totals are your coverage score for that topic, side by side with competitors'. Redo the map every quarter. The score is your own yardstick, not a Google number, but it tells you where you stand and what to write next.
Step 4: decide which gaps to fill first
Fill a gap when the question is tied to a service you sell, a buyer asks it before hiring, and at least one competitor already answers it well. A question no one answers can be a bonus, if customers really ask it.
| Row looks like | Do this |
|---|---|
| You 0, competitors 2 | Write it. Highest priority. |
| You 1, competitors 2 | Expand your existing answer. Often faster than a new page. |
| You 0, competitors 0, customers ask it | Write it. Easy ground to take. |
| Off your services | Skip it. |
Skip topics you don't sell. Google's helpful content guide lists this as a warning sign:
"Are you producing lots of content on many different topics in hopes that some of it might perform well in search results?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content)
A short answer can go on the service page. A question with its own depth earns its own page, linked to and from the service page. See topic clusters for how to link them, and refresh or write new to choose between the two.
Step 5: track each topic's results in Search Console
Coverage is the input; Search Console shows the output. In the Performance report, filter pages to one topic (for example, URLs containing "braces"), or filter queries to the topic's main word. Then note these numbers each month:
| Number | What rising means |
|---|---|
| Queries with impressions | Google shows you for more of the topic's searches |
| Average position on those queries | You show up higher |
| Clicks | People pick you |
| Calls and form leads from those pages (from your forms or call tracking, not Search Console) | The topic brings business |
To check a year of trend, Google's own advice for traffic reviews is to "choose the Date filter on top of the chart and select Last 16 months" (Google Search Central: Debugging search traffic drops). How to filter and compare is in our Search Console performance report guide.
Give it time. Google's starter guide says "some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months" (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide).
What doesn't show topical authority
- Page count. The map scores questions answered, not pages. Forty pages that skim the same five questions still score 10 at most.
- Word count. Longer is not more complete. Score answers, not length.
- New dates on old pages. Google asks: "Are you changing the date of pages to make them seem fresh when the content has not substantially changed?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content)
Example
A plumber in Ohio
Thirty questions about water heaters. Coverage scores: the plumber 18, the top competitor 44. The gaps are tankless vs tank, repair or replace, and sizing. The plumber writes three pages and expands the water heater service page. Four months later Search Console shows the topic's queries with impressions up from 40 to 90.
A bookkeeper in Toronto
Twenty-five questions about payroll. Competitors score 20 to 30; the bookkeeper scores 35. Coverage is not the gap here. The bookkeeper moves on to the next service, and works on reviews and links instead.
FAQ
Is there a free topical authority checker?
Not one that shows Google's view; Google publishes no such score. A spreadsheet coverage map plus Search Console, both free, measures what matters.
How many competitors should I compare?
Three is enough. Pick the sites that rank most for your services' searches, even if they are directories or chains.
Should I cover every question competitors cover?
No. Cover the ones tied to services you sell and that buyers ask. Skip topics outside your business.
How often should I redo the coverage map?
Every quarter, or when a competitor adds a batch of pages. Questions change as products, prices and rules change.
Different for you?
- Your answers exist but don't show up in AI answers: see topical authority for AI search.
- Coverage is strong but rankings lag: links may be the gap; see Domain Authority.
- You'd rather have the map built and the gaps written for you: see SEO & GEO.