Track AI visibility on a budget: what SEO tools miss
Short answer Free tools now show part of your AI visibility: Search Console counts your pages' impressions in Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, Bing counts Copilot citations, GA4 counts visits from AI assistants, and claimed ChatGPT listings count mentions. None shows the questions, who's named instead, or wrong facts. A monthly hand check fills that gap for $0.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhat SEO tools miss about AI answers
Three things. Rank trackers and Search Console were built to report where your link sits on a results page. They now report some AI numbers too, but no free report tells you:
- Which questions you show up for. Search Console's Generative AI report groups your impressions by page, country, device and date. It has no view of the searches themselves (Search Console Help).
- Who gets named instead of you. Bing now shows your share of the citations for a query, but not the rivals behind the rest:
"It does not expose competitor domains, represent traffic share, or assign quality scores to content." (Bing Blog: New AI Visibility Insights in Bing Webmaster Tools, June 2026)
- What the AI says about you. A report can count a mention. It can't tell you the answer gave your old hours or a service you dropped.
Google's report lists only AI Overviews and AI Mode, not the Gemini app (Search Console Help). For Gemini, Claude or Perplexity answers, you look yourself or pay a tool to look.
What the free reports do show
Start here. Each costs nothing and fills part of the picture.
| Free report | What it counts | Its limits |
|---|---|---|
| Search Console: Generative AI performance | How often your pages appeared in AI Overviews and AI Mode, by page, country, device and date. On for all sites as of August 31, 2026 (Google Search Central Blog) | Impressions only; no searches; Google Search only |
| Bing Webmaster Tools: AI Performance | Citations of your pages in Microsoft Copilot, Bing's AI summaries and "select partner integrations", plus the grounding queries behind them (Bing Webmaster Blog, February 2026) | A public preview; Bing says the grounding queries are "a sample of overall citation activity" |
| GA4: AI Assistant channel | Visits from assistants such as ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot (Analytics Help) | Only people who clicked through. Visits from Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode count as Organic Search instead |
| ChatGPT Business Hub: Insights | Mentions, website clicks and discovery topics over the past 28 days (OpenAI Help Center) | Needs a claimed listing and an ID check through Persona. Local stores and restaurants can claim only existing US listings. OpenAI warns "Counts may be incomplete." |
Grounding queries are the closest a free report comes to showing the question. Bing describes them as "the key phrases the AI used when retrieving content." They are not your customers' exact words. Setup help: Search Console for a small business and Bing Places and Bing Webmaster Tools.
In Canada, the ChatGPT row may be out of reach: OpenAI says availability "depends on the business’s location and type." The other three work the same.
The $0 monthly check: fill the gaps by hand
Ask the same customer questions every month, in the AI tools your customers use, and log what comes back. It answers the three things no report does.
- Write 10 to 20 questions. Half like "best [service] in [city]", half about specific jobs you want more of. Keep the list fixed so months compare.
- Pick the tools. Always Google (AI Mode, and the AI Overview on a normal search) and ChatGPT. Add Copilot if Bing's report shows citations, and any assistant that shows up in GA4's AI Assistant channel.
- Name the city in every question. For ChatGPT's privacy settings, follow the 20-question ChatGPT test.
- Ask each question twice. In BrightLocal's September 2026 study of local searches, result sets from repeat runs overlapped only 23% on ChatGPT, 21% on AI Mode and 33% on AI Overviews. One run is luck.
- Log every answer in a sheet like this one:
| Question | AI tool | Named? | Facts right? | Named instead | Sources shown |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Emergency plumber open Sunday in Mesa | AI Mode | Yes | No: old hours | Rival A | Yelp, rival's site |
| Tankless water heater install, Mesa | ChatGPT | No | n/a | Rival A, Rival B | Rival's site |
Then read it three ways:
- Mentions per tool. Count yes answers for each AI tool. Trust a trend over several months, not one month's jump.
- Wrong facts. Each one points to an old listing or page. Find it and fix it: where ChatGPT finds local businesses.
- Sources shown. If a rival's Yelp page or website appears answer after answer, that's the page you're missing.
What $29 to $199 a month buys
A tracker runs your question list every day across several AI tools and counts the mentions for you. It's the same sampling as the hand check, done more often. Entry plans on each vendor's pricing page, November 16, 2026, billed monthly unless noted:
| Tool and plan | Price a month | AI questions tracked |
|---|---|---|
| Otterly.AI Lite | €29 | 16, daily, on 4 AI tools |
| Ahrefs prompt package, Basic | $50 | 2,500 checks a month; Ahrefs' example is 80 prompts daily on 1 platform |
| Peec AI Starter | $95 | 50, daily, on 3 AI tools you choose |
| Ahrefs Lite (an SEO suite) | $129 | 5, daily, next to 750 tracked keywords |
| Semrush Starter (SEO + AI Search) | $199, or $165.17 billed yearly | 50, daily |
The Ahrefs Lite row is the gap in one line: an entry SEO suite tracks 750 keywords but only 5 AI questions. Semrush's cheapest paid plan, SEO at $139 a month, marks "Track performance in AI search" and "Monitor custom prompts" as not included.
Compare plans by checks, not by "prompts". Otterly defines its unit plainly: "One credit is one prompt checked once on one AI engine." Ten questions on four AI tools every day is about 1,200 checks a month.
A tracker still sees only its own runs, never your customers' chats. OpenAI doesn't share those even with the business:
"Businesses don’t receive individual prompts or consumer conversations, including chats with their business agents." (OpenAI Help Center: Setting up your business on ChatGPT)
When to pay for a tracker
| Your situation | What to use |
|---|---|
| One location, a few services | Free reports plus the monthly hand check |
| The hand check keeps getting skipped, or you want daily data on a short list | A €29 to $50 plan |
| Several cities or service lines, so the list runs past 30 questions | A 50-question plan ($95 to $199) |
| You already pay for an SEO suite | Check its AI add-on before buying a second tool |
| Search Console shows no Generative AI report at all | Don't pay yet. Google says your site usually "hasn't received enough impressions in generative AI features" yet. Fix your pages and listings first |
Example
Illustrative cases. Numbers are invented for the example.
A one-location physiotherapy clinic in Toronto (Canadian dollars)
Claiming its ChatGPT listing isn't offered to it yet. Search Console shows AI impressions on its sports-injury page; Bing shows 30 citations, with grounding queries about running injuries. Its hand check, 12 questions twice each on AI Mode, ChatGPT and Copilot, finds AI Mode giving an old address twice. It fixes the listing behind it. Cost: $0.
A one-van plumber in Mesa (US dollars)
He kept skipping the hand check. He moves 16 questions into a €29-a-month tracker for daily counts across four AI tools. Every quarter he still reads a few answers himself, to catch wrong facts the tracker only counts.
An HVAC company in five cities (US dollars)
Ten questions in five cities make 50. Two runs a month on three AI tools would be 300 answers by hand. It already pays $139 a month for Semrush's SEO plan, so it compares the $199 Starter plan (50 daily questions) with a $95 standalone tracker before choosing.
FAQ
Can Search Console show which searches triggered an AI Overview?
No. Its Generative AI report groups impressions by page, country, device and date only. Google counts AI Overview and AI Mode traffic inside the regular Performance report, "within the 'Web' search type" (Google Search Central), not as separate searches.
Is Bing's AI report worth checking if my customers use Google?
Yes, it's free and quick. Of the free reports, it's the only one that lists the phrases behind your citations, and it covers Copilot plus Bing's AI summaries.
Do I need sentiment scores and co-citation reports?
Not on a small budget. Your log already shows the tone of each answer, which rivals appear next to you, and which facts are wrong.
Is a visitor from AI search worth 4.4 times a Google visitor?
Not as a rule. That figure comes from Semrush's July 2025 study of digital marketing and SEO topics, based on conversion rate, and its traffic and value figures are projections. Count your own: GA4's AI Assistant visits and the calls, forms and bookings they lead to.
Different for you?
- You only care about ChatGPT: the 20-question ChatGPT test.
- Search Console isn't set up: Search Console for a small business.
- AI tools never name you, or get your details wrong: where ChatGPT finds local businesses.
- You want AI visits counted as leads: GA4 key events for calls, forms and bookings.
- An agency is selling you a GEO package with an "AI score": is GEO worth paying for?
- You'd rather have it tracked and acted on every month: SEO & GEO Agent.