User-generated content for SEO: how to use and manage it
Short answer Customer content helps SEO only when it helps the page. Google counts reviews, comments and customer photos as main content when they serve the page's purpose, and treats spam in them as a policy problem. Get permission before reusing anyone's content, moderate before it goes live, tag their links rel="ugc", and skip star markup for your own business.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callDoes user-generated content help SEO?
Yes, when it does a job on the page. User-generated content (UGC) is anything customers create: reviews, comments, questions, photos, videos. Google's guide to helpful content lists it as part of a page's main content:
"User-generated contributions: Forum discussions, customer reviews, comments, or user-uploaded media when they directly fulfill the page's purpose" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content)
So 40 real reviews on your roof-repair page add words and proof a searcher wants. A comment box full of "nice post" adds nothing.
The risk is real too. Google's spam policies name "comment spam on blogs" and "spammy posts on forum threads" as user-generated spam, and note that "often site owners are unaware" of it (Google Search Central: Spam policies). Google publishes no rule that a stream of new posts lifts rankings, so don't collect content just to look busy.
The rules in one table
| Step | What to do | Whose rule |
|---|---|---|
| Reuse | Get permission before you post their photo or words | Copyright law (US); Competition Act s. 74.02 (Canada, in writing) |
| Reward | Disclose any freebie or discount behind a post | FTC; Competition Bureau |
| Moderate | Remove spam and abuse by rules you apply to everyone | Google; FTC review rule |
| Copyright | Register a takedown agent if people upload to your site | DMCA (US) |
| Links | Tag links in customer posts `rel="ugc"` | |
| Markup | No star ratings for reviews of your own business |
How to collect customer content you're allowed to use
A customer's Instagram photo of your work is not yours to copy. The U.S. Copyright Office says a work is protected "the moment it is created and fixed in a tangible form." Their photo belongs to them.
Ask first, in writing. A reply to "Can we share this on our website and ads, with credit?" is enough to show consent. Save the message.
In Canada, the law is explicit. Section 74.02 of the Competition Act makes it reviewable conduct to publish a testimonial unless the person published it first, or approved it and gave "permission to make or publish it... in writing." And you must use it as they said it.
US rules on using what customers say:
- Featuring their words is fine. Asked if a business can put customer comments in ads, the FTC answers: "Yes. You can ask your customers about their experiences with your product and feature their comments in your ads." (FTC: Endorsement Guides, What People Are Asking)
- Don't edit the meaning. An endorsement "may not be presented out of context," and you are liable for misleading claims made through it (16 CFR 255.1).
- Disclose rewards. If customers expected a discount, gift or prize for posting, say so. For a contest, the FTC suggests putting "contest" or "sweepstakes" in the hashtag itself.
- Paid creators are not customers. If an ad implies the people are real customers, they must be, or the ad must clearly say they aren't (16 CFR 255.2(c)). Hiring a creator to film a "customer" video is legal; passing it off as a real client is not.
Canada's Competition Bureau says the same about rewards: free products, discounts and family ties are material connections that "should" be disclosed.
How to moderate without breaking the rules
Moderate before posts go live, by written rules you apply to everyone. Google's anti-spam page lists the basics:
- Manual approval. Google says it "can decrease spam on your platform considerably."
- A human check on sign-up. "Consider using reCAPTCHAs or similar verification tools to only allow human submissions."
- A blocklist of words and links that keep coming back.
- Noindex newcomers. Google suggests adding noindex to "posts that come from new users that don't have any reputation on your platform." Noindex is a tag that keeps a page out of Google's results.
For reviews, the FTC review rule (16 CFR 465.7) lets you hold back, by criteria applied to all: reviews you reasonably believe are fake; defamatory, harassing, abusive, obscene or discriminatory posts; other people's private details; content "clearly false or misleading"; and posts unrelated to what you sell. What you may not do: hide reviews for being negative while implying you show them all.
In the US, Section 230 says no site owner "shall be treated as the publisher or speaker" of what a user posts, and protects good-faith removal of "objectionable" material. It doesn't cover copyright ("any law pertaining to intellectual property"). Section 230 and the DMCA below are US laws.
Customer photos and copyright takedowns
If people upload photos or files to your site, the DMCA safe harbor (17 U.S.C. 512) can protect you from copyright claims over what they upload. You keep it by:
- Registering a designated agent with the U.S. Copyright Office. The fee is $6, and the designation "will expire and become invalid three years after it is registered" unless you renew it (37 CFR 201.38).
- Posting the agent's contact details on your site "in a location accessible to the public."
- Taking down reported material quickly. The law's word is "expeditiously."
- Having a policy to cut off repeat infringers.
The safe harbor covers what users post. It doesn't cover a photo you copied from someone's social account yourself.
How to mark up user-generated content
Links. Google recommends "marking user-generated content (UGC) links, such as comments and forum posts, with the `ugc` value." You can combine values (`rel="ugc nofollow"`). Since March 1, 2020, Google treats all three link tags as hints. Google adds that you "might remove this attribute" for members with a long record of good posts (Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links).
Star ratings. Customer reviews of your own business won't earn stars in Google results:
"If the entity that's being reviewed controls the reviews about itself, their pages that use LocalBusiness or any other type of Organization structured data are ineligible for star review feature." (Google Search Central: Review snippet structured data)
That holds for reviews pulled in through a third-party widget too, and Google says "Don't aggregate reviews or ratings from other websites."
Forum markup. DiscussionForumPosting markup fits only a real community area: "Only use DiscussionForumPosting markup to describe a user-generated post on a website." It's not for your blog posts with comments under them. A section that's mostly questions and answers should use Q&A markup instead (Google Search Central: Discussion forum structured data).
Example
A landscaper reposting customer photos (US dollars)
A landscaper sees a client's Instagram photo of a $12,000 patio. She messages: "Can we use this on our site and ads, with your name?" The client says yes; she saves the screenshot, adds the photo to the patio page, and credits the client.
A renovation company with a Q&A section (Canadian dollars)
A renovator in Ottawa lets customers ask questions on its kitchen page. It approves each question by hand, deletes ads for other contractors, and tags any customer links `rel="ugc"`. A customer emails a glowing note; before quoting it in a $500 Facebook ad, the company gets written approval, as section 74.02 requires for a testimonial the person never published.
A cleaning company running a contest (US dollars)
A cleaning company gives a $100 gift card to one customer who posts a before-and-after photo. Its hashtag is #SparkleContest, so the reward is plain. Every entry goes through the same approval, good or bad.
FAQ
Is user-generated content a ranking factor?
Not by itself. Google counts it as main content when it serves the page's purpose, and as spam when it doesn't.
Do I need permission to share a customer's review from Google on my website?
In Canada, section 74.02 lets you repeat a testimonial the person published themselves, like a Google review, if you quote it as given; anything unpublished needs written approval. In the US, quote it exactly and don't cut it in a way that changes its meaning (16 CFR 255.1).
Should all links in comments be nofollow?
Google suggests `nofollow` or `ugc` "to all links in untrusted content." Links from long-time, trusted contributors can go untagged.
Can I delete negative comments on my website?
You can remove spam, abuse and off-topic posts by rules applied to everyone. Hiding honest negative reviews while presenting the rest as complete breaks the FTC review rule.
Different for you?
- Asking for reviews, incentives and text consent: Asking for reviews: the rules.
- A bad review on Google rather than on your site: Respond to negative Google reviews.
- Adding business markup the right way: Local business schema markup.
- A "user-generated spam" notice in Search Console: Google manual action.
- Lawyers, therapists and financial advisors have stricter testimonial rules: Law firm website rules, Therapist testimonials, Financial advisor marketing rule.
- Want someone to run this for you: SEO & GEO agent.