Unrealistic keyword requests: what to target instead
Short answer A keyword request is unrealistic when the people searching it don't want what you sell, when national brands own the results, or when the deadline ignores how slowly Google moves. Test it first: search it, check who ranks, and check what customers actually type. Then aim for specific searches you can win, and widen later.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhich keyword requests are unrealistic?
Most impossible keyword requests fall into a handful of patterns. Each has a version that can actually bring customers.
| The request | Why it rarely works | Ask for this instead |
|---|---|---|
| One big word: "cakes", "glass", "plumber" | People typing it want many different things; big brands, directories and maps fill the page | The service plus the place: "custom birthday cakes Calgary" |
| A phrase nobody types: "best pizza in the universe" | No one searches it, so ranking first brings no one | The words customers really use, checked in a free tool |
| Something you don't sell: "credit cards" for a credit-score ebook | Visitors leave when the page isn't what they wanted | The problem your product solves: "how to raise my credit score" |
| Your jargon, not theirs | Customers may type a different word for the same thing | The common word, with your term on the page too |
| A competitor's business name | People searching it want that business | A fair comparison page, or ads |
| Page one in 30 days on a small budget | Google's own guide says some changes take months to show | Checkpoints at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months |
Google's hiring guide sets the floor for any promise:
"No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
How to check if a keyword is realistic
You can test a keyword in about 10 minutes with free tools.
- Search it yourself in a private browser window. Look at who holds the top 10. If it's national chains, marketplaces and encyclopedias, a small site won't move them soon.
- Look for a map. If Google shows a map with businesses, the result is local. Google says local results are "mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity," and that distance means "how far each business is from the customer who's searching" (Google Business Profile Help). You can win near you, not across the country.
- Check demand in Keyword Planner. It shows "the average number of times people have searched for a keyword" per month (Google Ads Help). Its Competition column counts "the number of advertisers that showed on each keyword," so it measures ad bidding, not how hard the organic results are. For that, see keyword difficulty.
- Compare the wording in Google Trends. Trends lets you "compare up to 8 groups of terms at once" (Google Trends Help). Its numbers are "scaled on a range of 0 to 100" against all searches (Google Trends FAQ), so they show which phrase is more popular, not how many people search.
- See what you already show up for. Search Console's Performance report lists the searches where your site appeared, with impressions, meaning "how many times your site appeared in Search results" (Search Console Help). Searches with impressions but a low position are often your fastest wins.
- Ask: does my page give this searcher what they want? If not, ranking won't turn into sales.
Why do one-word keywords rarely pay?
Because the searcher's need is unclear. Someone typing "glass" might want a window repair, drinking glasses or a film. Even if you ranked, most visitors wouldn't want your service. Longer searches like "windshield replacement near me" carry fewer searches, but nearly every one is a possible customer. Long-tail vs short-tail keywords shows how to balance both.
Our word or the customer's word?
Use the customer's, and keep yours on the page too. Google's starter guide puts it this way:
"Users who know a lot about the topic might use different keywords in their search queries than someone who is new to the topic." (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide)
Its example is "charcuterie" versus "cheese board." A clinic may say "dermal fillers" while patients type "lip injections." Compare both in Trends and build the page around the bigger one. The same guide adds that you don't need to anticipate every variation.
Can I rank for a competitor's name?
In regular search, rarely. Someone typing a rival's name usually wants that business, so the results are mostly about it. What can work:
- A truthful comparison page. In the US, the FTC's policy statement says it "encourages the naming of, or reference to competitors" in comparative advertising, but it requires clarity and no deception (16 CFR 14.15). In Canada, the Trademarks Act bars using another's registered trademark in a way "likely to have the effect of depreciating the value of the goodwill" (section 22), so naming a rival's brand carries more risk there.
- Ads. Google's trademark policy says it won't restrict "using trademarks as keywords," but it may restrict a competitor's trademark in the ad text after the owner complains (Google Ads policies: Trademarks).
What doesn't work: stuffing a rival's name across your pages. Google's spam policies define keyword stuffing as filling a page with keywords "in an attempt to manipulate rankings" (Google Spam policies).
What about keywords for things we don't sell?
Skip them. Google's own self-check asks whether you're "writing about things simply because they seem trending and not because you'd write about them otherwise for your existing audience" and whether you're "producing lots of content on many different topics in hopes that some of it might perform well" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content). A page that wins the click but can't help the reader earns no customer.
How should an SEO answer an impossible request?
With evidence, not a flat no. A good answer shows you the current results page, the search numbers and the competitors, then proposes a ladder:
- Now: specific searches you can win in months, such as service plus town.
- Next: broader phrases once those pages rank and earn reviews and links.
- Later, maybe: the big word, if the business, budget and site have grown to compete.
Google tells owners to ask anyone they hire, "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?). If someone simply says yes to "number one for plumber next month," treat it as a red flag. For setting the goals and review dates in writing, see unrealistic SEO expectations.
Example
A bakery that wanted "cakes"
The owner asks to rank for "cakes" on $500 a month. A search shows recipe sites, supermarket chains and a map. The plan targets "custom wedding cakes" and "birthday cakes" plus the city, with a page for each, and checks calls and orders at month 6.
An installer stuck on its own term
A solar company insists on "photovoltaic systems." Trends shows "solar panels" far ahead in its province. The page title switches to the common term and keeps the technical one in the text.
A shop eyeing a rival's name
A landscaper wants to rank for the leading competitor's name. Instead, it buys ads on its own service keywords and publishes a fair page comparing its packages, with prices it can back up.
FAQ
Is it ever worth going after a one-word keyword?
Sometimes, for a large business with a strong site and budget. For most small businesses, specific searches bring customers sooner. Revisit the big word once those pages rank.
Can an SEO guarantee page one for a keyword I choose?
No. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
How do I find what my customers actually type?
Check Search Console's Performance report, compare phrases in Google Trends, and listen to the words customers use on calls and in reviews.
Is it legal to name a competitor on my website?
In the US, the FTC encourages clear, truthful comparisons. Canada's Trademarks Act is stricter about using a rival's registered brand. Keep claims provable; ask a lawyer before publishing.
Different for you?
- Want a clear number for how hard a keyword is: Keyword difficulty.
- Building your first keyword list: Keyword research for a local business.
- Picking keywords that lead to sales: Buyer-intent keywords.
- Want customers from the big word now: SEO vs Google Ads or Paid Ads.
- Want the keyword work done for you: SEO.