Website navigation audit: the six steps
Navigation is how a visitor gets from the page they land on to the page that answers them: the menu, the footer, and the buttons and links between pages. An audit checks whether people actually get there, and where they stop. Work in this order; each step tells you where to look in the next.
| Step | What you do | Free tool | What it shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. List the jobs | Write the 3–5 things visitors come to do: see prices, check you serve their area, book | Paper | What the menu must make easy |
| 2. Find the drop-offs | See which pages people leave from, and where they go after the home page | Google Analytics 4 | Where people get lost |
| 3. Read site searches | List the words people type into your search box | Google Analytics 4 | What the menu hides |
| 4. Watch the clicks | Find clicks that do nothing and repeated angry clicks | Microsoft Clarity | What looks clickable but isn't |
| 5. Test with five people | Ask them to do each job using only the menu | A text list, or their own phone | Why they get lost |
| 6. Fix, then measure again | Change the labels or links they missed; compare the same numbers | Same tools | Whether the fix worked |
Both tools cost nothing: Google offers Analytics "free of charge" (Google Marketing Platform), and Clarity is "a free service forever" (Microsoft Learn: Clarity FAQ).
Three things change how you run it:
- Little traffic. With a few hundred visits a month, analytics shows patterns slowly. Lean on step 5.
- Sensitive pages. Clinics and law firms should check what recordings capture before step 4. See tracking on a clinic website.
- Ad-only pages. They often have no menu on purpose. Judge them as landing pages, not by this audit.
Where do visitors get lost? Start in Google Analytics
Pages people leave from. In Google Analytics 4 (GA4), open the Pages and screens report and add bounce rate with Customize report (Editor or Administrator access needed). In GA4, a bounce is a visit of 10 seconds or less, with one page view and no key event (an action you marked as important, such as a form sent) (Analytics Help: Engagement rate and bounce rate). A high bounce rate on a page meant to send people onward, like your home page or a services overview, points at navigation. For pages with low engagement, Google says to check:
"whether those pages or screens offer users easy paths to the next steps you want them to take." (Analytics Help: Engagement rate and bounce rate)
Paths. In Explore, start a Path exploration, click Start over, and set the starting point to your home page (page path "/"). Among the uses Google lists:
"Uncover looping behavior which may indicate users becoming stuck." (Analytics Help: Path exploration)
Look for three patterns:
- Loops. Home, Services, Home, Services: people are hunting.
- The wrong next page. The top page after Home is About or the blog, not the services people came for.
- Early ends. Gray boxes mark where paths stop; Google says these nodes "are at the end of the user's path."
Then flip it. Set an ending point instead, such as your booking or form key event, to see how the people who did book got there. A path exploration takes a starting point or an ending point, not both (Analytics Help: Path exploration). If buyers use a route most visitors never find, make that route the obvious one.
What are visitors searching for on your site?
If your site has a search box, its searches list what your menu doesn't show. GA4's enhanced measurement records a view_search_results event when the results page's address carries the search in one of five parameters, q, s, search, query or keyword (as in ?s=prices), and stores what was typed in the Search term dimension (Analytics Help: Enhanced measurement events). Check it's on under Admin, Data streams.
Read the top 20 terms. "Price", "hours", "insurance" or the name of a service you offer means people couldn't see it in the menu. Add it, or rename the menu item to the word they used.
No search box? Ask whoever answers your phone which questions callers ask that the site already answers. Same signal.
Which menu clicks go nowhere?
A session recording tool shows it. Microsoft Clarity flags these (Microsoft Learn: Clarity semantic metrics):
| Signal | Clarity's definition | What to check in your navigation |
|---|---|---|
| Dead click | "a user clicks on an element but gets no feedback in a reasonable amount of time" | A menu heading that only opens a dropdown; a photo or icon that looks like a link |
| Rage click | "the user clicks multiple times in a clustered area in rapid succession" | A slow or broken menu; a link too small to tap on a phone |
| Excessive scrolling | More vertical scrolling "than the expected average" | People scrolling to find what the menu should point to |
Dropdown headings are a common culprit. The Baymard Institute, which tests online stores, finds that 31% of sites don't make dropdown headers clickable, while its test users "often tried clicking them" (Baymard, updated October 2026). Open Clarity's heatmap for your home page, filter to phone visitors, and compare clicks on each menu item with what you expected.
How do I test my menu with real people?
Give five people who match your customers the jobs from step 1, and watch without helping. Jakob Nielsen's rule of thumb (Nielsen Norman Group, 2000): a first test with five users finds 85% of usability problems, so run several small tests rather than one big one.
Two ways to run it:
- Tree test (structure only). Write your menu as a plain indented text list, with no design. Ask "Where would you look to find X?" Nielsen Norman Group defines it as "an evaluation of a hierarchical category structure, or tree, by having users find the locations in the tree where specific resources or features can be found." Note where each person looks first, and whether they go straight there or try a few places; NN/g calls that directness.
- Task test on their own phone. "Find what a drain cleaning costs, then book it." Note where they pause, what they tap and what they say out loud.
If three of five people look for prices under "Services", put prices there.
Navigation audit checklist: the menu itself
| Check | Passes when | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Labels in customers' words | "Drain cleaning", not "Solutions" | Your five testers found each item on the first try |
| Every job within reach | Call or book, and your main services, from any page | The jobs from step 1 |
| Phone menu not fully hidden | Your top one or two links sit outside the menu icon | Nielsen Norman Group, 2016, 179 people: on phones, a partly visible menu was used in 86% of cases, a fully hidden one in 57% |
| Dropdown headings are links | Tapping "Services" opens a services page | Baymard, 2026: 31% of online stores don't |
| Hover menus wait a moment | A dropdown opens after 300–500 ms, not instantly | Baymard, 2023: stops menus flickering open as the mouse passes; 60% of online stores don't |
| Same menu, same order | Every page repeats it in the same order | WCAG 2.2 criterion 3.2.3, Level AA |
| More than one way in | Menu plus search, a site map page or a list of links | WCAG 2.2 criterion 2.4.5, Level AA |
| Big enough to tap | Each link at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels | WCAG 2.2 criterion 2.5.8, Level AA |
| Works without a mouse | The Tab key reaches and opens every menu item | WCAG 2.2 criterion 2.1.1, Level A |
| Real links | Right-click a menu item: "Open link in new tab" appears | Google can generally crawl a link only if it's a standard HTML link with an address (Google Search Central: Link best practices) |
| Footer as backup | Services, contact, service area, policies | A second chance for visitors who scroll to the end |
WCAG, the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, is the usual yardstick for accessibility; the legal side is in ADA website compliance.
Fix one thing, then measure again
Change what the test exposed, then compare the same numbers over equal periods, such as four weeks before and four weeks after: bounce rate on the pages you changed, loops in the path exploration, top search terms, dead clicks, and calls or bookings. Note anything else that changed, like the season or your ad budget. Then rerun the five-person test with the same jobs.
Example
A house cleaning company
2,000 visits a month. The path exploration shows About as the top page after Home, and many paths loop back to Home. "Price" is the top site search, 40 times a month. The menu says "Our Process". Fix: a "Prices" item with ranges from $150 USD. Four weeks later, the owner compares price searches and quote requests.
A landscaping company in Calgary
Clarity shows dead clicks on "Services": it only opens a dropdown. On phones, the whole menu hides behind the icon. Fix: "Services" links to a services page, and "Get a quote" sits outside the icon. Cost: about an hour of the web designer's time, roughly $100 CAD.
A bookkeeping firm
In a tree test, four of five clients look for catch-up bookkeeping under "Services". It sits under "Solutions", then "Small business". Fix: one "Services" menu; "Solutions" goes. On the retest, all five go straight to it.
FAQ
How often should I audit my website navigation?
After you add services or pages, after a redesign, and about once a year. Read your site search terms monthly.
Does website navigation affect SEO?
Yes, through links. Google "primarily finds pages through links from other pages it already crawled" (Search engine optimization: work that helps your pages show up higher in the unpaid results on Google and Bing. More Starter Guide), so link key pages from your menu.
What is a good bounce rate?
Google Analytics sets no target; compare each page with its past months. Mark phone taps as a key event, or quick callers count as bounces.
How many items should a website menu have?
No set number. Nielsen Norman Group (2009) calls a 7-item limit "a common misconception": people recognize menu items rather than memorize them. Cut unused items.
Different for you?
- People reach the booking form and stop: Website not getting leads.
- Most visitors come from ads to one page: Landing page best practices.
- Pages load slowly on phones: Core Web Vitals and website speed.
- Calls, forms and bookings aren't counted yet: GA4 key events.
- A clinic recording visits: Meta pixel and Google Analytics on a clinic website.
- Traffic fell after a redesign changed your menu: Traffic dropped after a redesign.
- Accessibility rules: ADA website compliance.
- You want the site audited and fixed for you: Website Agent.