Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

301 Redirects and SEO: What You Lose Without Them

Updated · 7 min read

Short answer A 301 redirect tells browsers and Google a page moved for good. Without one, the old address returns "not found", Google removes it from search, and links from other sites stop helping you. With one, Google says no ranking credit is lost. Point each old page to its closest new match and keep it at least a year.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

What you lose when a changed page has no 301

Every page address (URL) that changes needs a permanent redirect, called a 301, from the old address to the new one. Skip it and the old address returns a 404 ("page not found") error. Here is what goes with it.

What you loseWhy
The page's place in GoogleGoogle removes pages that return 404 from its index (Google Search Central). The new address starts with no history.
Credit from links on other sitesLinks from directories, local news or suppliers still point to the old address. A 404 page passes them nowhere.
Visitors from old linksBookmarks, old emails, printed QR codes and links in old social posts all land on an error page.

Google's own words on what happens to a 404 page:

"URLs that are already indexed and return a 4xx status code are removed from the index." (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes)

Does a 301 redirect lose ranking?

No, according to Google. A permanent redirect carries the old page's link credit (Google calls it PageRank) to the new address.

"301 and other permanent redirects don't cause a loss in PageRank." (Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes)

Expect some movement while Google catches up. For a medium-sized site, Google says it "can take a few weeks or more" before the new addresses replace the old ones in results (same page). Google may also keep showing the old address now and then after a domain change; it says this is normal and fades on its own (Google Search Central: Redirects).

When do you need a 301 redirect?

Whenever an address that people or Google already know stops working.

SituationRedirect?
You renamed a page (`/services.html` became `/plumbing-repair/`)Yes, old to new
You merged three thin pages into oneYes, all three to the merged page
You moved to a new domain or business nameYes, every old page to its match on the new domain
Your site opens at both `www` and non-`www`, or `http` and `https`Yes, all versions to the one you prefer
You deleted a page and have a close replacementYes, to the replacement
You deleted a page with no real replacementNo. Let it return 404 or 410 ("gone")

Google lists the last case plainly: if you are not moving old content, those URLs should "correctly return an HTTP 404 or 410 error response code" (Google Search Central: Site moves).

301 vs 302: which one to use?

Use a 301 when the move is permanent. Use a 302 only when the old page is coming back. The difference is which address Google shows.

TypeGoogle treats it asUse it when
301 or 308Permanent: shows the new addressThe page moved for good
302, 303 or 307Temporary: keeps the old address in resultsA seasonal page is hidden for a while
Instant meta refresh (0 seconds)PermanentYour platform can't do a server redirect
Delayed meta refreshTemporaryRarely a good idea
JavaScript redirectPermanent, if Google renders the pageOnly as a last resort
"Use permanent redirects when you're sure that the redirect won't be reverted." (Google Search Central: Redirects)

Google also warns that it "might never see" a JavaScript redirect if rendering the page fails (same page). A server-side 301 is the type Google is most likely to read correctly.

How to set up a 301 on your website platform

Most small business sites never touch code. The platform has a redirect screen.

PlatformWhereWorth knowing
WixSEO & GEO dashboard → URL Redirect ManagerWix creates a 301 automatically when you change a page's slug, but not for blog posts. Up to 5,000 redirects per site (Wix Help)
SquarespaceDeveloper tools → URL mappings, one line each: `/old-url -> /new-url 301`Works only after the old page is deleted or disabled (Squarespace Help)
ShopifyContent → Menus → URL redirectsWorks only from addresses that no longer load a page; 301s are cached by browsers (Shopify Help)
WordPressA redirect plugin, such as RedirectionIt can create a redirect automatically when a post's address changes (WordPress.org)
Your own server`.htaccess` on Apache, or the NGINX configGoogle's redirect page shows the exact lines (Google Search Central)

A note on Shopify's caching: a browser that has followed a 301 may keep following it after you delete it. That is why a 301 should only be used for moves you won't undo.

Mistakes that throw the value away

A redirect that exists but points to the wrong place can cost almost as much as no redirect.

  1. Sending everything to the home page. Google says not to redirect many old URLs to one unrelated page such as the home page: it "might be treated as a soft 404 error" (Google Search Central: Site moves). A soft 404 counts as a missing page. Some platform help pages suggest this for deleted pages; for one page with no match it is harmless, for dozens it is the mistake.
  2. Chains. Page A goes to B, then B to C. Googlebot follows up to 10 hops, but Google advises pointing straight to the final page, "ideally no more than 3 and fewer than 5" if you can't (same page). After a second redesign, update the first set of redirects too.
  3. Removing them too soon. Keep redirects "generally at least 1 year" so Google can reassign links from other sites; for visitors, Google suggests "keeping redirects indefinitely" (same page).
  4. Leaving your own links on old addresses. Update menus, buttons and links inside your site to the new URLs. Redirects add delay for every visitor (Google Search Central: Site moves). Change your Google Business Profile website link and your ad landing pages the same day.

How to check your redirects work

  1. Paste a few old addresses into a browser. Each should land on its matching new page, not the home page or an error.
  2. In Search Console, watch for new "not found" errors. Search Console reports errors for 4xx codes and for failed redirects (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes).
  3. Before a big change, list the pages worth saving. Google suggests your sitemap, your analytics' top pages and Search Console's Links report for pages other sites link to (Google Search Central: Site moves).

Search Console's URL Inspection tool won't follow a redirect to its target, so inspect the new address on its own. Google says its inspection tools don't follow redirects (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes).

Example

An electrician renames service pages

The site moves from `/services/panel.html` to `/panel-upgrades/`. A local news site links to the old page. With a 301, that link keeps counting and the page keeps its place in Google. Without one, the link hits a 404 and Google drops the old page.

A landscaper merges seasonal pages

Four pages (spring cleanup, fall cleanup, leaf removal, aeration) become one "Yard cleanup" page. All four old addresses get a 301 to the new page. Google allows this when the content now lives on one page.

A bakery closes its catering line

The catering page has no replacement. The owner deletes it and lets it return 404 instead of sending it to the home page.

FAQ

Can I delete my redirects after a few months?

Google recommends keeping them at least a year, and for visitors, indefinitely. Old links and bookmarks keep sending people to the old address long after Google catches up.

Is a 308 redirect the same as a 301?

For Google, yes. Both mean "moved permanently", and Google treats both as a signal to show the new address.

Should I redirect a deleted page to my home page?

Only if nothing closer exists, and never for many pages at once. Google may treat a pile of home page redirects as missing pages. If there is no related page, a 404 is the honest answer.

Do redirects slow my site down?

Each hop adds a little delay. One redirect is fine; chains of several hops add up, which is why Google says to point straight at the final page.

Can I use a canonical tag instead?

Only when you can't redirect. Google's SEO Starter Guide says to redirect duplicate pages to the best one, and "If you can't redirect, use the rel="canonical" link element instead." A canonical tag is a line in the page code naming the preferred version.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextWebsite migration services: what they cost and how to choose oneWhat hosts and freelancers charge to move a website, what the price leaves out, and the questions to ask so your Google traffic survives the move.

Do it yourself

Crawlability checklist: make every page reachable by GoogleA crawlability checklist for a small business site: find orphan pages, robots.txt blocks, broken links, redirect chains and server errors, with free tools.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: Redirects and Google Search
  2. Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes
  3. Google Search Central: How HTTP status codes and network errors affect Google Search
  4. Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide
  5. Wix Help Center: Setting up a 301 redirect for a page on your site
  6. Squarespace Help Center: URL mappings
  7. Shopify Help Center: Creating and managing URL redirects
  8. WordPress.org: Redirection plugin