Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

404 Errors and SEO: Do They Hurt Your Google Rankings?

Updated · 7 min read

Short answer No. Google says a page returning 404 does not count against the rest of your site, and a deleted page should return 404. Only two kinds need work: a page you still want found that now errors, and an old address other sites or customers still link to. Soft 404s, error pages that report success, are the real problem.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Do 404 errors hurt SEO?

Not by themselves. A 404 is the code a server sends when a page doesn't exist ("not found"). Google treats it as normal and does not lower your other pages because some addresses are dead.

"If some URLs on your site 404, this fact alone does not hurt you or count against you in Google's search results." (Google Search Central Blog: Do 404 errors hurt my site?)

The same post says missing pages don't change how your working pages perform, and that Google would rather a deleted page return a real 404 than pretend to exist. That post is from 2011, but Google's current documentation still works the same way: a 404 page is dropped from the index, and nothing about it spreads to the rest of the site (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes).

So a long list of 404s in Search Console is not a penalty and not a ranking problem. What can cost you is what sits behind a few of them.

Which 404 errors should you fix?

Fix a 404 only when someone still wants that address. Ignore the rest.

The 404 is...Fix it?What to do
A page you still offer, such as a service page, that brokeYes, firstRestore it, or find the change that broke the address
An old page you replaced with a new oneYesAdd a permanent (301) redirect to the new page
An old page other sites link toYesRedirect to the closest matching page so the link keeps counting
A link inside your own site, menu or Google Business ProfileYesUpdate the link to the right address
A typo of a real address that someone linked toWorth itRedirect the typo to the real page
A page you deleted on purpose, with no replacementNoLeave it returning 404
A strange address that never existed on your siteNoIgnore it

On that last row, Google is direct:

"If you see 404 errors reported in Webmaster Tools for URLs that don't exist on your site, you can safely ignore them." (Google Search Central Blog: Do 404 errors hurt my site?)

Webmaster Tools is the old name for Search Console. Those odd addresses come from typos in other people's links, broken code on other sites, scrapers, or Google testing how your server answers unknown URLs, per the same post.

To find the 404s that matter, Google's site move guide suggests checking your sitemap, the pages with the most traffic in your analytics, and Search Console's links report for pages other sites link to (Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes). A dead page on any of those lists is worth fixing. How to read the reports: Google Search Console for a small business.

What does Google do with a 404 page?

It drops the page from search and visits it less often.

"URLs that are already indexed and return a 4xx status code are removed from the index." (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes)

The same page says Google ignores any content on a 404 page and crawls the address "gradually" less. It never fully forgets it: Google's crawl budget guide says it "won't forget a URL that it knows about," though a 404 is "a strong signal not to crawl that URL again." That is why a fixed or deleted page can keep showing in reports for a while.

You don't need Google's Removals tool for a page that already returns 404; the 2011 post says such a page drops out of results on its own. Removals requests are temporary anyway, lasting about 6 months (Google Search Central: Remove a page hosted on your site).

Do 404 errors waste crawl budget?

Not for a typical small business site. Crawl budget means how many pages Google is willing to fetch from your site in a given time. Google's guide on it is written for sites with 10,000+ pages that change daily, 1 million+ pages that change weekly, or many pages stuck as "Discovered - currently not indexed" (Google Search Central: Large site owner's guide to managing your crawl budget). A 20-page site for a plumber or a dentist is nowhere near that.

Real 404s also don't slow Google down:

"The 4xx status codes, except 429, have no effect on crawl rate." (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes)

The crawl budget guide asks large sites to return 404 or 410 for removed pages. The ones that waste crawling are soft 404s, which "will continue to be crawled, and waste your budget" (same guide).

Soft 404s: the kind that does cause trouble

A soft 404 is a page that looks missing or empty but tells Google everything is fine (a "200" success code). Google has to guess, and Search Console flags it as a soft 404 when the content "suggests an error," "an empty page or an error message" (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes). Such pages stay out of search, and on large sites they keep eating crawls.

Common causes on small business sites:

  • A friendly "page not found" page that sends a success code. Many owners think a helpful error page needs a 200 code. It doesn't: Google's 2011 post says you can serve any content you want with a real 404 code.
  • Sending every dead address to the home page. Google says redirecting many old URLs to one unrelated page such as the home page "might be treated as a soft 404 error" (Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes).
  • Empty pages that still exist. A service area page with no text, a blog tag with no posts, a search results page with nothing found.
  • Apps built in JavaScript that show "not found" without telling the server. Google's JavaScript guide suggests a redirect to an address that returns a real 404, or a noindex tag on error pages (Google Search Central: JavaScript SEO basics).

The fix is the same in each case: if the page is gone, return a real 404 or 410; if it should exist, give it real content. Google's crawl budget guide says to check the Page indexing report for soft 404 errors. If a page you want in Google shows up there, see page not indexed in Search Console.

Should a deleted page return 404 or 410?

Either. A 410 means "gone for good," but Google handles them the same:

"All 4xx errors, except 429, are treated the same" (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes)

Pick whichever your website platform makes easy. Most send 404 by default, and that is fine.

How to check what a page really returns

A page that says "Not Found" on screen may still send a success code. Check the code itself:

  1. Open the address in Chrome, right-click, choose Inspect, then the Network tab.
  2. Reload the page. The first row's Status column shows the code: 200, 301, 404 or 410 (Chrome DevTools: Network features reference).
  3. Try a made-up address on your site, such as `/abc-test-123`. It should show 404, not 200 and not a redirect to your home page.

If the made-up address returns 200, your site creates soft 404s for every broken link. Your web host's or platform's help pages explain how to fix the error page setting.

Example

A roofer with 140 "not found" errors

Search Console lists 140 404s. Most are addresses like `/wp-content/old-theme/` that the current site never had. Two are old service pages a local news site linked to. The roofer redirects those two to the current roofing and gutter pages and ignores the other 138.

A dental office's custom error page

The office built a friendly error page with its phone number and a search box. A test with a made-up address shows Status 200. Its web developer changes the setting so the same page sends a 404. Nothing on screen changes for patients.

A bookkeeper drops payroll services

The payroll page has no replacement. She removes it from the menu, lets it return 404, and leaves it alone. Once Google recrawls it, it stops appearing in search.

FAQ

Will lots of 404 errors get my site penalized?

No. Google says 404s alone don't count against you or affect your other pages. Fix the ones on pages people or other sites still use.

How long does a 404 page stay in Google?

Google removes an indexed page that returns 404 the next time it crawls it; Google gives no fixed timing. It may still revisit the address now and then, so it can linger in Search Console reports.

Should I redirect all 404s to my home page?

No. Google may treat a pile of home page redirects as soft 404s. Redirect only to a page that closely matches; otherwise let the address return 404.

Do broken links to other websites hurt my SEO?

Google's guidance covers 404s on your own site, not outbound links. A dead outbound link mainly frustrates visitors, so fix it when you find it.

Does a custom 404 page help SEO?

Not for ranking. It helps visitors find another page instead of leaving. Just make sure it sends a real 404 code.

Different for you?

Keep learning

Next301 Redirect Problems: Find and Fix Chains, Loops and ErrorsHow to diagnose broken 301 redirects: chains, loops, wrong targets and mixed signals. What Google says, how to test one, and the fix for each.

Do it yourself

Crawlability checklist: make every page reachable by GoogleA crawlability checklist for a small business site: find orphan pages, robots.txt blocks, broken links, redirect chains and server errors, with free tools.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central Blog: Do 404 errors hurt my site? (May 2011)
  2. Google Search Central: How HTTP status codes and network errors affect Google Search
  3. Google Search Central: Large site owner's guide to managing your crawl budget
  4. Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes
  5. Google Search Central: Understand the JavaScript SEO basics
  6. Google Search Central: Remove a page hosted on your site from Google
  7. Chrome DevTools: Network features reference