Backlink audit: review your links without overreacting
Short answer Use Search Console's free Links report. Check three things: links you or an SEO bought or swapped, linked pages that now show an error, and good local sites not linking yet. Ignore random spam: Google typically ignores it. Disavow only bought links you can't get removed, and only if they caused, or likely will cause, a manual action.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhat a backlink audit should check
A backlink is a link from another website to yours. An audit is a look at those links to find the few that need action. For a small business, that's usually three things, not hundreds of "toxic" links.
| Check | Why it matters | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Links you or a past SEO paid for, swapped or mass-submitted | These break Google's link spam policy | Ask the site to remove them; disavow only what stays |
| Your pages that other sites link to, but that now show an error | The link points to a page Google drops from its index | Redirect the old address to the closest current page |
| Good local sites that don't link to you | Missed links you could easily earn | Ask suppliers, associations and partners for a link |
| Links from sites you've never heard of | Usually nothing | Leave them; Google typically ignores known spam |
Google's own Links report help says the purpose is to "confirm that you recognize the sites listed here" and, if you see spammy ones, "you might need to ask to be removed or, if all else fails, disavow them" (Search Console Help: Links report). The same page adds: "For known spam sites, Google typically will ignore the links."
Should I disavow toxic backlinks?
Almost always no. Disavowing tells Google to ignore certain links to your site. Google's test has two parts, and both must be true:
"You have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links pointing to your site, AND The links have caused a manual action, or likely will cause a manual action, on your site." (Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site)
A manual action is a penalty a Google reviewer places on a site, shown in Search Console's Manual actions report. Google also warns that the tool "can potentially harm your site's performance in Google Search results" if used wrongly, and that "most sites will not need to use this tool" (Search Console Help: Disavow links).
| Your situation | Disavow? |
|---|---|
| An SEO tool flags 300 toxic links; you never bought links; no manual action | No |
| Spam directories and scraper sites you never dealt with | No: Google typically ignores them |
| A former agency bought links for you; no manual action yet | Remove what you can first, then disavow the rest |
| Manual action: "Unnatural links to your site" | Yes, after asking sites to remove links. See manual action guide |
Google's first instruction for bad links you built is removal, not the file: "we recommend that you remove as many spammy or low-quality links from the web as possible" (Search Console Help: Disavow links).
What "toxicity score" and "authority score" really mean
They are the tool maker's estimates, not Google's. Google's disavow test above mentions no score. Semrush's Backlink Audit says that after you disavow, "our system will recalculate the overall Toxicity Score": the score is Semrush's own calculation (Semrush Knowledge Base: Backlink Audit overview).
The same goes for site strength scores. Moz, which created Domain Authority, says:
"Domain Authority is not a Google ranking factor and has no effect on the SERPs." (Moz: What is Domain Authority?)
These numbers help you sort a long list. They don't tell you what to delete.
How to do a backlink audit free in Search Console
Open Search Console and go to Links.
- Top linking sites. Scan the list. Recognize your chamber, suppliers and local news? Good. A paid directory network or blog farm an old agency used? Note it.
- Top linking text. This is the clickable text of the links. Google says to "confirm that the link text is what you expect, and not spammy text." The same keyword phrase, like "best plumber Dallas", on many unrelated sites is the pattern Google's spam policy describes. It lists "links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases distributed on other sites" as link spam (Google Search Central: Spam policies).
- Top linked pages. Open each one. If it shows a "not found" page, the link is wasted: Google says "URLs that are already indexed and return a 4xx status code are removed from the index" (Google Search Central: HTTP status codes). Set up a permanent (301) redirect to the closest current page. Google says it uses that redirect "as a signal that the redirect target should be canonical" (Google Search Central: Redirects). Don't send them all to your home page: that "might be treated as a soft 404 error" (Google Search Central: Site moves).
- Export "Latest links". This lists the most recently found links, up to 100,000 rows. Look at the last few months, especially after you hired or changed an SEO provider.
- Check Manual actions. A green check means no link penalty. Then you're done with cleanup.
Know the report's limits. Google says it "isn't a comprehensive list" but a sample, tables stop at 1,000 rows, it includes links that "may have since been removed", and it "doesn't specify if a link is marked as nofollow" (Search Console Help: Links report). For most local businesses, that sample is enough. Paid tools find more links; they don't change Google's test.
How to disavow links, if you must
If you pass Google's test, the rules (Search Console Help: Disavow links):
| Rule | Detail |
|---|---|
| Property type | Not available for Domain properties; use a URL-prefix property |
| File | Plain .txt, UTF-8 or 7-bit ASCII, one URL or domain per line |
| Whole site | Write `domain:example.com` |
| Notes | Lines starting with `#` are ignored |
| Size | Up to 100,000 lines and 2MB |
| Updating | One list per property; a new upload replaces the old one |
| Timing | "it can take a few weeks" to take effect |
| Undo | Click Cancel Disavowals |
Disavowed links keep showing in the Links report, so don't expect them to disappear there.
How often to audit backlinks
Google's help pages set no schedule. Look again when something changes: you hire or fire an SEO provider, you buy an existing domain or business, you get a manual action, or traffic drops. Otherwise a quick pass once a year is plenty for a local business. A traffic drop with no manual action usually has another cause; see traffic dropped after a core update.
Example
A dentist whose SEO tool shows 450 "toxic" links
They come from foreign scraper sites. The practice never bought links, and Manual actions shows a green check. Action: none. The time goes to fixing two old service page addresses that still get links.
A roofer whose old agency bought 80 guest posts
Every link reads "roof replacement Phoenix". No manual action yet. Action: email the blogs asking for removal, then disavow the 50 domains that don't respond, since Google says to act when links "likely will cause a manual action".
An accountant who moved to a new website
Ten sites link to the old "/tax-services.html" page, which now shows "not found". Action: one 301 redirect to the new tax page.
FAQ
Can bad backlinks hurt my rankings?
Rarely. Google says it usually "can assess which links to trust without additional guidance." The real risk is links you or your SEO bought or schemed.
Can a competitor hurt me by pointing spam links at my site?
Unlikely. Google "works very hard to make sure that actions on third-party sites do not negatively affect a website." Without a manual action, leave it alone.
Do I need a paid backlink audit tool?
Not usually. Search Console is free and shows Google's own sample of your links. Paid tools find more links; their scores are only their estimates.
How long does a disavow take to work?
Google says it "can take a few weeks." With a manual action, you also need to request a review.
Different for you?
- You have a manual action for unnatural links: manual action guide.
- You want links that won't cause problems later: backlinks for a local business.
- You've never opened Search Console: Search Console for a small business.
- An agency offers a "toxic link cleanup" package: hiring an SEO company.
- You want the audit and fixes handled: SEO & GEO Agent.