Questions to ask when hiring an SEO company
Google publishes its own interview list for hiring an Search engine optimization: work that helps your pages show up higher in the unpaid results on Google and Bing. More (Google Search Central). These are the ones that sort good from bad fastest:
| Ask | A good answer | Walk away if |
|---|---|---|
| Can you show me past work, and can I call two of those clients? | Named sites and owners who pick up the phone | Only screenshots, or "client confidentiality" for everyone |
| What results do you expect, by when, and how will you measure them? | Search Console clicks, calls and form leads, compared with today | A promised position or "page one in 30 days" |
| Will you share every change you make to my site, and why? | A written log of changes each month | "Our methods are proprietary" |
| What's your experience in my industry and my city? | Similar businesses in similar markets | Nothing local, or one template for every client |
| Do you follow Google Search Essentials? | Yes, and they cite Google's own pages for advice | They call Google's rules optional |
| What do you need from me? | Questions about your services, customers and rivals | Nothing but a card number |
Google's last test is the simplest: a good SEO asks "about what makes your business unique, who your competitors are, how search results can help, and how your customers find you" (Google Search Central).
For a free audit, give view access only. Google: "only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don't grant them write access)" (Google Search Central). In Google's free tool that shows which searches bring people to your site and flags pages Google can't index. More, that is a restricted user, who "Has simple view rights on most data" (Search Console Help).
SEO scams to spot
Most SEO scams lean on Google's name. Google's own pages answer each one.
| What you hear | What Google says |
|---|---|
| "We guarantee you #1 on Google." | "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Google Search Central) |
| "We have a special relationship with Google" or "priority submit" | Google says to beware of SEOs that claim either (same page) |
| A recorded call: "This is Google, your listing is about to be removed" | "Google does not place robocalls." (Google Help) |
| An invoice to "keep your business on Google Maps" | "Google does not charge for inclusion in Google Maps." (Google Help) |
| "Our tool is approved by Google" | Google "doesn't evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools" (Google Search Central) |
| "Link to us from your footer" | "You should never have to link to an SEO." (same page) |
| An email out of the blue about your rankings | Google says to be wary of exactly this (same page) |
Is a "Google Partner" badge proof of SEO skill?
No. The badge is earned through Google Ads work: an optimization score of at least 70%, $10,000 in ad spend over 90 days across client accounts, and Google Ads certifications (Google Ads Help). Google's badge rules say:
"You cannot show the Partner or the Premier Partner badge on any materials, such as websites, that advertise Search Engine Optimization (SEO) services without a prominent notice saying such SEO services are not verified or endorsed by Google." (Google Ads Help)
A Partner can be a good ads manager. It tells you nothing about their SEO.
Cheap SEO packages and link gigs
A package that sells you a set number of Links to your website from other websites. Links from trusted, relevant sites can help your pages rank. More is selling bought or automated links. Both are on Google's list of link spam: "Exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links" and "Using automated programs or services to create links to your site" (Google spam policies). The cost lands on you, not the seller:
"Sites that violate our policies may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all." (Google spam policies)
"Ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" (Google Search Central)
What links do help a local business: backlinks for a local business.
Is pay-for-performance SEO worth it?
Only if you pick the keywords and the payment tracks leads, not positions. In a pay-per-ranking deal, you pay when chosen searches reach chosen spots. Three problems:
- The seller picks easy words. A rare phrase can hit #1 and bring no calls. Agree on the list yourself, using searches from your own Search Console.
- Rank depends on who's looking. Google uses "your location, past Search history, and Search settings" to decide what each person sees (Google Search). A screenshot of #1 from the seller's office proves little.
- The pressure is to rank fast. Fast usually means the link tactics above, and the penalty is yours.
A fairer deal: a fixed monthly fee for named work, reviewed against Search Console clicks and leads.
Keep the keys
Whoever you hire, stay the owner of your Search Console, Your free business listing on Google Search and Maps: hours, photos, reviews, services and contact details. More, Analytics and domain, and add the SEO as a user. Owners keep "full control" (Search Console Help). The clauses to put in writing are in marketing agency contract terms.
Already paid a scammer?
Report it. Google points US owners to the FTC, online or at 1-877-FTC-HELP, and complaints about companies outside the US to econsumer.gov (Google Search Central).
In the US, the FTC's impersonation rule makes it an unfair or deceptive practice to falsely pose as a business, or falsely claim ties to it such as its endorsement, in a way likely to affect a buyer's choice (16 CFR 461.3).
In Canada, report it to the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre at reportcyberandfraud.canada.ca or 1-888-495-8501, and to local police if you lost money (CAFC).
Example
Illustrative cases. Prices are invented for the example.
A plumber gets a "Google" robocall
The recording says his listing will be suspended unless he verifies today for $199. He hangs up and signs in to his Business Profile himself: no notice. Google doesn't place robocalls, so he blocks the number and reports it.
A dentist compares two proposals
One promises "top 3 in 90 days, guaranteed" for $800 a month. The other lists four new treatment pages, profile updates and a monthly Search Console report for $1,500, with no ranking promise. She calls two clients of the second firm, then signs with it.
A roofer on a pay-per-ranking deal
He pays $300 a month per keyword on page one. Six months in, he pays for 10 keywords, but calls are flat: most are rare phrases nobody searches. He switches to a flat fee for named work.
Different for you?
- Deciding between an agency, a freelancer, a hire or AI: SEO agency vs freelancer vs in-house vs AI.
- Checking whether a quote is fair: what SEO costs a small business.
- Holding a contract now: marketing agency contract terms.
- Already hired and unsure it's working: is my SEO working?
- Want the work done and shown to you each month: SEO & GEO Agent.