Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Brand image audit: how to check how customers see you

Updated · 8 min read

Short answer A brand image audit compares what you think your business stands for with what customers actually say. Survey recent customers, call five of them and a few people who didn't buy, then check your messaging, logo and signs, and three competitors against their words. Fix the biggest gap first. Run it yearly or after a big change.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Brand image audit: the five checks

Your brand image is the short story people tell about your business: "fast but pricey", "the friendly one", "never calls back". The audit finds that story and puts it next to the one you're trying to tell. Five checks, in this order:

CheckQuestion it answersFree way to do it
1. OnlineWhat does a stranger find?Search, reviews, social, AI answers
2. CustomersWhy do people pick you, or not?A short survey and five calls
3. MessagingDo your words match theirs?Your website, profile, ads and scripts side by side
4. VisualsDo you look like one business?Every logo, sign, vehicle and page laid out together
5. CompetitorsHow do you compare where customers compare?The same checks on three rivals

The online check has its own step-by-step guide: Online brand image audit. This page covers the other four, which tell you why the online picture looks the way it does.

Before you start, write one sentence: what you want customers to say about you. "The electrician who shows up when promised." Every check measures distance from that sentence.

Who should I ask in a brand image audit?

Three groups, because each sees a different side:

  • Recent customers (last 6–12 months): why they chose you and what they'd tell a friend.
  • People who didn't buy: quotes that went cold, callers who never booked. They know why you lost, and nobody else will tell you.
  • Your staff: what customers praise and complain about to them, and how they describe the business on the phone.

Leave out friends and family. They'll be kind, which is the opposite of useful.

How do I survey customers about my brand?

Keep it to five questions or fewer, sent by email or text within a few weeks of the job.

#QuestionType
1How likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague? (0–10)Score
2What's the main reason for your score?Open
3What three words would you use to describe us?Open
4Why did you choose us over other options?Open
5What's one thing we should change?Open

Question 1 is the Net Promoter Score (NPS), a standard loyalty measure. Bain & Company's definition: people answering 9 or 10 are promoters, 7 or 8 passives, 0 to 6 detractors. Your score is the percentage of promoters minus the percentage of detractors. With a few dozen replies, the score is a rough signal; the comments in questions 2 to 5 are the audit.

Three rules from Pew Research Center's guide to survey questions keep the answers honest:

  • One idea per question. Pew says "it is also important to ask only one question at a time." "Was our crew fast and friendly?" can't be answered if they were fast but rude.
  • Neutral words. Pew notes that "even small wording differences can substantially affect the answers people provide." Ask "How was the price?" not "Did you find our pricing fair?"
  • No agree/disagree lists. Some people agree with whatever's written. Pew's advice:
"A better practice is to offer respondents a choice between alternative statements." (Pew Research Center: Writing Survey Questions)

Tools: SurveyMonkey's free Basic plan allows 10 questions per survey but lets you view only a limited number of responses (SurveyMonkey pricing page). A form builder or a plain email with the five questions works too.

A small thank-you, like a coffee card, is fine for a survey. Don't tie it to a public review. In the US, the FTC's rule bans incentives "conditioned expressly or by implication on, the writing or creation of consumer reviews expressing a particular sentiment, whether positive or negative" (16 CFR 465.4). How to ask for reviews properly: Get more customer reviews.

How do I interview customers about my brand?

Call five customers and three people who didn't buy. Fifteen minutes each. Surveys tell you what; calls tell you why.

  1. "How did you first hear about us?"
  2. "What else did you look at, and what made you decide?"
  3. "Before you called, what did you expect? What actually happened?"
  4. "If a friend asked about us, what would you say?"
  5. For lost leads: "What made you go with someone else?" Then stop talking.

Write down their exact words, not your summary. "You were the only one who answered the phone" is a message you can use; "good service" isn't.

Recording the call? Ask first. In the US, federal law allows recording when one party to the call consents (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)), but some states are stricter: California's Penal Code § 632 bars recording a confidential conversation "without the consent of all parties." In Canada, the Criminal Code allows it with the consent of either person on the call (section 184(2)(a)). Asking at the start, and getting the yes on the recording, meets the stricter rule.

How do I check if my messaging matches what customers say?

Copy what you say about yourself from every place into one document:

  • Website headline and first paragraph
  • Google Business Profile description
  • Ad headlines
  • Social media bios
  • Your quote or estimate template
  • What staff say when they answer the phone

Now put the customers' words beside them. Look for three gaps:

GapExampleFix
You stress what they don't mentionSite says "25 years of experience"; customers say "answered on Sunday"Lead with the thing customers mention
They praise what you never sayCustomers keep saying "clean"; no page says itAdd it to your headline and profile
Different places say different thingsSite says "premium"; ads say "cheapest in town"Pick one promise and use it everywhere

The best headline you'll ever write is often a phrase three customers used without being prompted.

How do I check my brand visuals?

Gather one of everything people see: logo files, business cards, signs, vehicle wraps, uniforms, invoices, website, social profile pictures, email signature. Lay them on a table or one screen and check:

  • Same name. Not "Smith Plumbing" on the van and "Smith & Sons" on Google.
  • Same logo version. Old logos linger on trucks and invoices for years.
  • Same colors and phone number everywhere.
  • Does it match the promise? A dated, blurry logo works against "modern" or "premium".

Then check that nobody nearby looks like you. A competitor with a similar name and logo can take your calls and your reviews. The USPTO says one of the most common reasons trademark applications are rejected is a name "too similar" to one already registered, and that a full clearance search covers federal and state databases and the internet. Search free in the USPTO's Trademark Search or, in Canada, the CIPO Canadian Trademarks Database. A match isn't a legal verdict; if you find one, talk to a trademark lawyer before changing anything.

How do I compare my brand image with competitors?

Pick the three businesses customers named in your calls, or the top three in Google Maps for your main service and town. Fill in one row each:

YouRival ARival BRival C
Main promise (website headline)
Price signal (free quotes, financing, "affordable")
Google rating and review count
Words that repeat in their reviews
What their ads promise
Look (modern, dated, plain)

For ads, Google's Ads Transparency Center is "a searchable hub of all ads served from verified advertisers" (Google Blog, 2023), and Meta's Ad Library lets people "search for all active ads running across products from Meta" (Meta Transparency Center). Search each rival by name.

You're looking for an empty spot: a promise customers want that no rival owns. If all three say "affordable" and your customers say "reliable", own reliable. For a deeper look at rivals' search strategy: Reverse engineer SEO competitors.

How do I turn the audit into a plan?

List each finding with one fix, one owner and a date. Do them in this order:

  1. Broken promises. Customers say "never calls back"; no message fixes that. Fix the operation first.
  2. Wrong facts and mixed names (old logo, different phone numbers). Cheap and fast.
  3. Messaging gaps. Rewrite the headline and profile in your customers' words.
  4. Visual refresh, only if the look fights your promise. It's the most expensive fix and the least urgent.

To see whether the fixes work, track a few free numbers monthly: Brand health tracking.

How often should I do a brand image audit?

The full audit, once a year. Rerun it after a big change: a new name, new owner, new service, price change or a move. The online check is quicker and worth doing every quarter.

Example

A roofing company that sold the wrong thing

Its site leads with "Lowest prices in the county." Survey answers to "three words" keep saying "honest" and "explained everything." Two lost leads say a cheaper roofer felt pushy. The owner changes the headline to "Straight answers, written quotes" and drops the price claim from ads.

A two-location dental office with two looks

Laid out together: the first office's sign uses an old tooth logo, the second the new one, and the Google profiles list different phone numbers. Fixing names, logo and phone costs a few hundred US dollars for a sign panel and a day of edits.

A Calgary cleaning service in a crowded field

Three rivals all promise "affordable." Customers' calls repeat "same cleaner every time." The owner makes that the headline and adds it to the quote template. The price stays at $150 CAD per visit.

FAQ

What is a brand image audit?

A check of how customers, lost leads and staff see your business, compared with how you describe it, plus your messaging, visuals and competitors.

How is a brand audit different from a brand image audit?

A brand audit reviews what you control: name, logo, messaging. A brand image audit checks what others think. This guide does both.

How many survey responses do I need?

Enough to see the same words repeat. Stop when new replies tell you nothing new, and read the comments rather than chasing a precise score.

Should I hire an agency for a brand image audit?

Not for the first one. An outsider helps when customers won't criticize you directly or you're too close to the business to judge the findings.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextCoffee brand marketing: what Starbucks, Dunkin' and Peet's teachWhat Starbucks, Dunkin' and Peet's do to win repeat customers, and the cheap versions a single cafe can run: one clear promise, a loyalty card, a Google menu.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Pew Research Center: Writing Survey Questions
  2. Bain & Company: Measuring Your Net Promoter Score
  3. SurveyMonkey: Individual plans and pricing
  4. eCFR: 16 CFR 465.4, Buying positive or negative consumer reviews
  5. 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d) (Cornell LII)
  6. California Penal Code § 632
  7. Criminal Code of Canada, section 184
  8. USPTO: Why search for similar trademarks?
  9. USPTO: Trademark Search
  10. CIPO: Canadian Trademarks Database
  11. Google Blog: Announcing the launch of the new Ads Transparency Center (March 29, 2023)
  12. Meta Transparency Center: Ad Library tools