Online brand image audit: the checklist
For a small business, brand image is mostly what a stranger sees online before calling, booking or buying. Check it in one sitting, on your phone, signed out of Google (a private or incognito window works), and write down what you find.
| Where to look | What to check | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Google search for your name | Every result on page one: who runs it, is it current, is it kind | An old address, a complaint thread, a closed location |
| Suggestions as you type your name | The words Google adds after it | "scam", "lawsuit", "closed" |
| Google Business Profile and Maps | Hours, phone, address, website link, category, photos, the review summary | Wrong hours, strangers' photos, "Permanently closed" |
| Review sites | Rating, review count, newest review, share you answered, repeated complaints | Last review a year old, unanswered 1-stars, a Yelp alert |
| Better Business Bureau (BBB) | Rating and complaints | Complaints marked "Unanswered" |
| Social profiles | Same name, logo, phone and hours; last post; open comments | A dead account, or a fake one using your logo |
| AI assistants | What ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot say about you | Wrong services, wrong city, "closed" |
Three things change how you run it:
- Your name is common. Add your city to every search, or you're auditing someone else.
- Several locations. Each one has its own listing and reviews. Audit them separately.
- You are the brand. Lawyers, realtors, coaches and therapists should also search their own name.
How do I see what customers see when they search my business?
Search like a stranger. Your own results are tailored to you:
"...we use information such as your location, past Search history, and Search settings to determine what is most relevant for you in the moment." (Google: How Search Works)
So sign out, use a private window, and search from where your customers are; if you serve several towns, ask someone in another one for a screenshot. Run four searches:
- Your business name
- Name plus city
- Name plus "reviews"
- Name plus "complaints"
For each page-one result, note three things: who controls it (you, a platform, someone else), whether it's accurate and current, and its tone (good, neutral, bad).
Then watch the suggestions as you type your name. Google says "Autocomplete predictions reflect searches that have been done on Google" (Google Blog, 2020). You can't edit them; Google's teams remove predictions that break its published autocomplete policies, such as hateful or dangerous ones. If "[your name] complaints" shows up, people are asking; make sure what they find answers them.
If your site is in Google Google's free tool that shows which searches bring people to your site and flags pages Google can't index. More, its branded queries filter lists searches that include your business name. Google opened it to all eligible sites on March 11, 2026; sites with too few searches don't qualify (Google Search Central Blog). Words that keep appearing next to your name, like "price" or "refund", are questions your website should answer. Setup: Search Console for a small business.
What should I check on my Google Business Profile?
That every fact matches real life. Your owner edits aren't the only input: Google invites the public to keep listings fresh "by suggesting updates like open status, hours, phone numbers or website links," and to add photos and videos (Google Maps: Local Guides).
- Facts: name, hours (holiday hours too), phone (call it), address or service area, primary category.
- Website link: tap it on your phone. Does it open the right page?
- Photos: look at the newest ones customers added. Do they show your work, or a mess?
- Review summary: in the Google Maps app, read the AI summary of your reviews if one shows. Google began rolling out Gemini review summaries in the US in October 2024, and Ask Maps, which answers questions about places, in the US and India in March 2026 (Google Blog). A hurried customer may read only that summary.
Repeat the facts check on Apple Maps, Bing and the directories that matter for your trade: Local citations. Listing missing: Google Business Profile not showing.
How do I audit my online reviews?
List every site where people review you: Google, Facebook, Yelp, the BBB and your trade's own sites. Shoppers compare: in BrightLocal's 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults, "the average consumer uses six different review sites when choosing businesses." For each site, record five numbers:
| Record | Why it matters (BrightLocal 2026, US adults) |
|---|---|
| Average rating | 31% will only use a business with 4.5 stars or more |
| Number of reviews | 47% won't use a business with fewer than 20 reviews |
| Date of the newest review | 74% only care about reviews from the last three months |
| Share you replied to | 89% expect owners to respond |
| Themes that repeat | The top trust factor: a review backed up by others saying the same thing (56%) |
Then read your last 20 reviews, good and bad, and tally the words that repeat: "late", "price", "friendly", "clean". Repeated themes are your brand image. A single odd review is noise.
Two sites need an extra look:
- Yelp. Scroll to the "not recommended" link at the bottom of your page. Those reviews "don't factor into the business's overall star rating or review count" (Yelp Trust & Safety). Also check for a Consumer Alert, which Yelp describes as "a warning message displayed over the reviews of a business's Yelp page" when it detects abnormal activity, such as paid reviews or legal threats against reviewers. Its software also screens out reviews it suspects the owner or staff asked for, so don't ask for Yelp reviews.
- BBB. It serves the US and Canada. "Complaints will appear on BBB Business Profiles for three years," and failing to respond to one "may have a negative impact on the BBB rating" (BBB: How BBB Complaints Are Handled).
Never fix the picture with fake reviews or threats. In the US, the FTC's 2024 review rule bans businesses from writing or selling fake reviews, and bans using "an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation" to stop or remove one (16 CFR Part 465). In Canada, the Competition Bureau warns that anyone who writes or allows misleading reviews could be liable under the Competition Act (2024). How to ask legally: Asking for reviews.
What should I check on social media?
That each profile clearly belongs to the same business, and that it's alive.
- Same details: name, logo, phone, hours and website match your Google listing.
- Last post date: an account untouched for a year looks closed. Post, or delete it and point people to the one you use.
- Open conversations: unanswered comments and messages are public proof nobody's home.
- Impostors: search each platform for your name. An account copying your logo can take customers' money in your name. Report it in the app; Facebook's Help Center covers how to report a "profile or Page pretending to be you or someone else." Link your real accounts from your website so customers can tell which are yours.
Posting more won't lift your Google ranking directly: Does social media help SEO?
What do AI assistants say about my business?
Ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot what they know about your business in your city, and whether they'd recommend it for your main service. Note wrong facts and the sources they cite. People do ask: in BrightLocal's 2026 survey, use of ChatGPT and other AI tools for local recommendations rose from 6% to 45% in a year. When an answer is wrong, fix the source it names. Full method: Does ChatGPT recommend your business? and Where ChatGPT finds local businesses.
How do I score the audit and decide what to fix first?
Mark each row green (accurate, current, positive), yellow (accurate but stale or thin) or red (wrong, hostile or fake). Fix reds in this order, since a wrong phone number loses customers today and a stale photo doesn't:
| Order | Finding | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wrong hours, phone, address, or "closed" | Correct it at the source: Remove or update information on Google |
| 2 | Unanswered bad reviews or BBB complaints | Reply once, calmly: Respond to negative reviews |
| 3 | Fake listings or impostor accounts | Report them: Report fake Google listings |
| 4 | Few reviews, or none in three months | Ask every customer: Asking for reviews |
| 5 | Stale or duplicate social profiles | Update, merge or delete |
| 6 | Unflattering results you don't control | Fix the cause; Google removes pages only in narrow cases |
How often should I run a brand image audit?
Run the full audit every quarter. Three months is the window most review readers care about, and it catches stale listings early. Between audits:
- Set a Google Alert for your business name. It's free, and Google describes it as a way to "monitor the web for interesting new content," sent as it happens, daily or weekly (Google Alerts).
- Read new reviews weekly. 81% of consumers expect a reply within a week (BrightLocal 2026).
- Rerun the audit after a move, a new phone number, a new name or a burst of bad reviews.
Do I need surveys or paid tools for a brand image audit?
Not to start. The online audit shows what strangers see. A short survey or a few calls with past customers show why people hired you or didn't; add them when your online picture looks fine but sales don't. Paid reputation and social listening tools collect reviews and mentions in one inbox and alert you to new ones. They earn their cost with many locations or more reviews than you can read, and they don't change what's already out there.
Example
A plumber who moved
Page one shows his Google listing with the old address and two directories with the old phone number. His newest review is 14 months old. He fixes the listing, then the directories, and asks every customer for a Google review. Next quarter: right address, 12 new reviews.
A physiotherapy clinic with an impostor
A Toronto clinic finds an Instagram account using its logo and selling "10-visit packages, $400 CAD by e-transfer." It reports the account, posts a warning on its real pages and links them from its website. Its Google rating is 4.6 from 85 reviews, but 9 of the last 20 mention long waits, so it spaces out bookings.
A bakery that "closed"
Typing the bakery's name brings up "[name] closed". It shut its second shop, but that listing still shows, and ChatGPT says the bakery is closed. The owner marks only that location closed, says "one location" on the website and asks ChatGPT again next quarter.
FAQ
What is a brand image audit?
A check of how people see your business. Big companies survey customers and staff; a small business should start with what strangers find online.
Can I pay someone to remove bad reviews or search results?
Platforms remove reviews and results only when they break platform rules or the law, not for payment. Distrust anyone promising removal. What qualifies.
Should I audit my competitors too?
Briefly. Run the same searches for your two closest competitors. Their rating, review count and newest review date are what customers compare you against.
Different for you?
- A fair or fake bad review hurts most: Respond to negative Google reviews.
- Lawyers and clinics have extra limits on review replies: lawyers, clinics.
- Your business has a knowledge panel, the info box beside results: Google knowledge panel.
- Your home address or personal details show up: Remove information from Google.
- You'd rather have listings, reviews and AI answers watched and fixed for you: SEO & GEO Agent.