Do you need backlinks? A quick test for your site
Short answer Maybe not yet. Search what a customer would type, open the top three results, and compare them with your page: how well each answers the search, and how many different websites link to it. If your page answers worse, fix the page first. If the pages are equally good and theirs have far more linking sites, links are your gap.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callDo you need backlinks to rank?
Links count, but they are rarely the first thing missing. A backlink is a link to your site from someone else's site. Google confirms it still uses them:
"How PageRank works has evolved a lot since then, and it continues to be part of our core ranking systems." (Google Search Central: A guide to Google Search ranking systems)
Google's public explanation of ranking names links as one quality clue among several:
"For example, one of the factors used to determine quality is understanding if other prominent websites link or refer to the content." (Google Search: How Search works, ranking results)
The same page says Google also weighs the words of the search, whether a page is relevant and usable, and the searcher's location. So a page that doesn't answer the search well won't be rescued by links. The test below tells you which problem you have.
| What the test shows | What to do first |
|---|---|
| Your page isn't in Google at all | Fix indexing. Links aren't the issue |
| The top pages answer the search better than yours | Improve your page |
| Pages are about equal, and the top ones have few linking sites | Keep improving the page; links aren't the gap |
| Pages are about equal, and the top ones have many more linking sites | Earn links |
| The top results are directories or national brands | Pick narrower searches, and get listed where those directories are |
How to test whether you need backlinks
It takes about 20 minutes per search. Use a sheet with one row per page.
- Pick three searches that bring paying customers. Use the words a customer types, like "water heater repair Mesa", not your company name. Not sure which words? See keyword research for a local business.
- Search from where your customers are. Google uses the searcher's location, so results in your office can differ from results across town. Use a private browser window so your own history matters less.
- Skip the ads and the map listings. Note the top three regular results below them. The map pack (the three businesses shown with a map) follows different rules, covered further down.
- Score each page on the answer. Does it say what the service costs, where it's offered, what's included, how to book? Does it show real photos, reviews or licenses? Give each page a plain "better", "same" or "worse" than yours.
- Count the websites linking to each page. Use a free tool from the next section. Write down the number of different linking websites (called referring domains), not the total number of links.
- Do the same for your own page, then read the gap with the table above.
Two warnings. Count links to the ranking page, not just the whole site: a competitor's homepage may have all the links while their service page has none. And one site can link thousands of times from a footer, so total link counts mislead.
How do I see a competitor's backlinks for free?
No free tool shows every link. Each shows a sample, which is enough for a comparison.
| Tool | What it shows free | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search Console, Links report | Sites linking to your own site and your most-linked pages | Your site only. Google says it shows "a sample" and is not "a comprehensive list" |
| Bing Webmaster Tools, Backlinks | Your links next to the links of up to two other sites, with referring domains and link text | Free account, your site verified |
| Semrush free account | Backlinks for any site or page | 10 requests a day, 10 results per report |
| Ahrefs Backlink Checker, free version | Backlinks for any site or page | A preview of the paid tool |
Bing's tool describes its comparison this way: "Analyze your websites' backlink profile with up to two other sites backlinks." That makes it the most useful free option for this test, since you can put a competitor next to you on one screen. Search Console also doesn't say whether a link is marked nofollow, a label that asks Google not to count the link. For what Search Console's other reports show, see Google Search Console for a small business.
Do backlinks help you rank in the Google map pack?
They help, but less than for regular results, and they can't beat distance. Google's help page for local ranking says:
"Local results are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity." (Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google)
Under popularity (also called prominence), it adds: "This factor's also based on info like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have." So links sit next to reviews in one of three factors. If the businesses in the map pack are closer to the searcher than you, more links won't move you past them. See how to rank higher on Google Maps.
Are Domain Authority and Domain Rating Google scores?
No. They are SEO tool companies' estimates of a site's link strength. Moz, which makes Domain Authority, says it "is not a Google ranking factor and has no effect on the SERPs" (search results pages). Ahrefs' Domain Rating is the same kind of outside score. Use them to compare sites roughly, never as a target to buy toward.
What if the test says you need backlinks?
Earn them, don't buy them. Google's spam policies list "Buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam, including trading goods or services for a link. Sites that break the policies can rank lower or drop out of results.
Start with sites that already have a reason to mention you: suppliers, trade groups you belong to, local sponsorships, partners. How to get backlinks for a local business lists where to ask and how. Then give it time. Google's SEO Starter Guide says "Some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months," and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A plumber in Mesa, Arizona (US dollars)
The top three results for "water heater repair Mesa" have pages listing prices from $150, service towns and photos. His page has two lines of text. All four pages have fewer than five linking sites. Links aren't the gap. He rewrites the page first, using on-page SEO for service pages.
An accounting firm in Toronto (Canadian dollars)
For "small business accountant Toronto", the firm's page lists its C$1,500 starting fee, services and staff credentials, as good as the top results. But those pages have 40 to 80 linking sites against its 3. This firm needs links, starting with its professional association profile and local business groups.
A dog groomer whose search is all directories
The top results for "dog grooming near me" are Yelp, a national chain's location finder and a directory. Links won't change what kind of page Google shows there. She aims for narrower searches like "cat grooming" plus her town, and keeps her listings on those directories complete. See local citations and directories.
FAQ
Can a new website rank with no backlinks?
Yes, for searches where the top pages have few links themselves, which is common for specific local services. Google says links also help it discover pages, so a few real ones speed up being found.
How many backlinks do I need?
There's no fixed number. Google publishes none. The useful number is how many different sites link to the pages beating you for your search.
Do backlinks matter for ChatGPT and AI answers?
Use the same test: see which pages the AI answer cites, then compare them with yours. For how ChatGPT picks businesses, see where ChatGPT finds local businesses.
Should I pay for an SEO tool to do this test?
Not for three searches. The free tools above cover it. A paid plan helps if you track many searches every month.
Different for you?
- Your page doesn't show up in Google at all: website not showing on Google.
- The test says your page is the gap: on-page SEO for service pages.
- The test says you need links: how to get backlinks for a local business.
- You want to study a competitor's whole site: Screaming Frog competitor analysis.
- You care most about the map pack: how to rank higher on Google Maps.
- You'd rather have the test run and the fixes done: SEO & GEO Agent.