Backlink Analysis: Find Hidden Link Opportunities
Short answer Pull your own links from Google Search Console's Links report and a rival's from Bing Webmaster Tools, both free. Then look for four things: sites linking to two rivals but not you, your linked pages that now break, mentions without a link, and the pages that earn rivals links. Go after real, relevant sites only. Never buy links.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow do you do a backlink analysis?
A backlink is a link to your website from someone else's. Analyzing them means listing who links to you and to your rivals, then turning the differences into a short list of sites to ask. Google still uses links: its PageRank system "continues to be part of our core ranking systems" (Google Search Central: Ranking systems guide).
| Step | What you do | Free tool |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Export your links | Download the sites and pages that link to you | Google Search Console |
| 2. Export two rivals' links | Pick the two businesses that beat you in search most often | Bing Webmaster Tools |
| 3. Find the gaps | Mark sites that link to both rivals but not you | A spreadsheet |
| 4. Check your own leaks | Find pages others link to that now show an error | Search Console |
| 5. Keep the real ones | Delete paid, spammy and unrelated sites from the list | Your judgment |
| 6. Ask | One personal email per site, a few a month |
Where to see your own backlinks for free
Start with Google Search Console, Google's free report on your site. Open Links. Under External links, three tables matter:
| Table | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Top linked pages | Which of your pages other sites link to most |
| Top linking sites | Which sites link to you most, by root domain |
| Top linking text | The words other sites use in links to you |
Click a site to see which of your pages it links to. To download everything, use the export button. Google says the export gives "up to 100,000 rows" and offers a "Latest links" slice, "sorted by discovery date" (Search Console Help: Links report).
Know its limits. Google says it "isn't a comprehensive list of every link on your site," it includes links "that Google has found over time" that "may have since been removed," and it "doesn't specify if a link is marked as nofollow" (Search Console Help: Links report). Treat it as a strong sample, not a full count.
A second free view: Ahrefs Free (formerly Ahrefs Webmaster Tools) shows "up to 1000 backlinks at once" for websites you verify you own (Ahrefs). It is not for rivals.
How to see a competitor's backlinks for free
Use Bing Webmaster Tools. You need an account with your own site added. Then open Backlinks. It has a Backlinks To Any Site view and a Similar sites view. Bing describes Similar sites this way:
"Analyze your websites' backlink profile with up to two other sites backlinks. Also get data on number of referring domains and anchors to each of the selected site." (Bing Webmaster Tools: Backlinks)
Add your two strongest rivals. A referring domain is a website that links to you at least once. Sort by those, not by total links: one directory linking 300 times is still one site.
Other free options are thin. Moz Link Explorer gives "10 free queries per month" with a free account (Moz: Link Explorer). Paid tools such as Ahrefs or Semrush show more of a rival's links. Each tool builds its own index of the web, so expect each to miss links the others find.
The four places hidden link opportunities hide
| Opportunity | How to spot it | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Link gap: sites linking to two rivals, not you | In your spreadsheet, the domains on both rival lists but missing from yours | Find out why they link (member list, supplier page, local story) and qualify the same way |
| Leaking pages: your pages with links that now error | Top linked pages in Search Console; open each one and see if it loads | Redirect the old address to the closest live page |
| Unlinked mentions: your name without a link | Search your business name and owner's name; open pages that aren't yours | Thank them and ask if they'd add a link to your site |
| Pages that earn rivals links | Which rival pages collect the most links in Bing's view | Make a better version of that kind of page: real price ranges, local permit steps, a project gallery |
Leaking pages are the quickest win, because the links already exist. Google says "301 and other permanent redirects don't cause a loss in PageRank," and its site move guide tells you to check the Links report "for pages that have internal and external links" before changing addresses (Google Search Central: Site moves).
The link gap is the richest list. When two rivals share a link, the site usually links to businesses like yours for a reason: a trade association directory, a manufacturer's installer finder, a chamber of commerce, a local news roundup. Those reasons are open to you too.
Which prospects are worth your time?
Keep a site on the list only if all three are true:
- It fits. Same trade, same town or the same customers. A wedding photographer and a florist fit. A crypto blog and a dentist don't.
- Real people read it. It has current posts, real contact details and no "write for us, $50" page.
- It would link for free. You are a member, supplier, partner, sponsor or a genuinely useful source.
Delete the rest. Google's spam policy calls these link spam, among others: "Buying or selling links for ranking purposes," "Excessive link exchanges," and "Low-quality directory or bookmark site links" (Google Search Central: Spam policies). A rival with links like these is taking a risk, not showing you a model.
Ignore the authority score each tool shows (Domain Authority, Domain Rating and similar). These are tool estimates. Moz, which makes Domain Authority, says it "is not a Google ranking factor and has no effect on the SERPs" (Moz: What is Domain Authority?). A small local site that sends you customers beats a high-score site nobody in your town reads.
What about spammy links you find?
Usually nothing. On known spam sites, Google says it "typically will ignore the links" (Search Console Help: Links report). Disavowing is for rare cases, such as links a past SEO company bought for you. Backlinks for a local business explains when the disavow tool is worth using, and Google manual action covers what to do if Google has flagged you.
How often should you repeat it?
Every three to six months is plenty for a small business. Export the "Latest links" slice from Search Console to see what's new, and rerun Bing's comparison to see what rivals gained. Google's own starter guide reminds owners that PageRank "is just one of" many ranking signals (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide), so keep this a small, steady habit, not your whole marketing plan.
Example
A roofer with 30 linking sites
Bing shows his two rivals share 12 linking sites he lacks. Five are spam directories, which he deletes. Seven are real: two shingle makers' contractor finders, the local builders' association, three town news stories about storm repairs, and a charity build. He applies to the two contractor programs and joins the association for $400 a year. Within a few months, three new links appear in Search Console.
A dental practice that changed websites
Search Console's Top linked pages lists an old "/new-patients.html" page with links from a school district and a health fair site. It now shows an error. A single redirect to the new patient page puts those links back to work at no cost.
A bookkeeper mentioned but not linked
A search for her firm name turns up a chamber of commerce event recap and a podcast page that name her with no link. Two short thank-you emails later, one adds the link.
FAQ
Is Search Console enough for backlink analysis?
For your own site, it's the best free start: Google's own sample. It can't show rivals' links, so add Bing Webmaster Tools.
How many backlinks does a small business need?
There's no number. Google doesn't publish one. A handful of relevant local and trade links beats hundreds from sites with no reason to mention you.
Should I copy every link my competitor has?
No. Copy the ones you can earn the same honest way. Skip paid links and spam directories; Google's spam policy covers both.
Do nofollow links show up in Search Console?
They may. Google says the Links report doesn't say whether a link is nofollow, so you can't filter them there.
How long does a backlink analysis take?
For a small site, usually an afternoon the first time and less on repeat checks, since you only look at what's new.
Different for you?
- You need ideas for where a local business earns links: How to get backlinks for a local business.
- You're new to Search Console: Google Search Console for a small business.
- Your gaps are mostly directory listings: Local citations and directories.
- An agency is selling you a "backlink audit": Hiring an SEO company.
- You'd rather have it done and tracked: SEO & GEO Agent.