Forbes reviews controversy: lessons for trustworthy reviews
Short answer Forbes Advisor's review pages ranked on the strength of the forbes.com name, not on first-hand testing. In 2024 Google ruled that renting a strong site's reputation is spam, and outside tools showed those pages losing most of their Google rankings. The lesson for an owner: rank on your own proof, and never buy space or fake independence.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhat happened with Forbes reviews?
The fight was not about whether one Forbes editor was honest. It was about who wrote the "best credit card" and "best pet insurance" pages on forbes.com, who earned the commissions, and why those pages outranked sites that actually tested products.
| Date | What happened | Source |
|---|---|---|
| February 19, 2024 | HouseFresh, a small air purifier testing site, argues that big publishers rank for product picks "without firsthand testing" | HouseFresh |
| March 5, 2024 | Google announces a spam policy against low-value third-party pages hosted on strong sites, enforced from May 5, 2024 | Google blog |
| September 18, 2024 | SEO writer Lars Lofgren reports that Forbes Advisor is run by Forbes Marketplace, a separate company in which Forbes holds a minority stake, citing a Forbes SEC filing | Lofgren |
| September 25, 2024 | Analysts see Forbes Advisor's health, credit card, banking and car insurance sections drop sharply in Google | Search Engine Roundtable |
| November 19, 2024 | Google tightens the policy: owner oversight of third-party pages no longer protects them | Google Search Central blog |
| November 2024 | Sistrix reports Forbes Advisor's rankings for topics like pet insurance largely gone in English-speaking countries | Sistrix |
Google never named Forbes, and the ranking figures come from outside tools, not Google. But the timing and the policy wording line up.
Why Google cut those rankings
Because the pages ranked on borrowed trust. Google's spam policies define the problem:
"The site reputation policy applies where third-party content is published on a host site mainly because of that host's already-established ranking signals, which it has earned primarily from its first-party content." (Google Search Central: Spam policies)
In November 2024 Google closed the loophole of a site owner "supervising" the content:
"no amount of first-party involvement alters the fundamental third-party nature of the content" (Google Search Central blog, November 19, 2024)
Third-party content alone is fine. Freelance articles, columns, forums and press release sites aren't a problem by themselves. The test is purpose: was the page put there to ride the host's name in search? Outside the European Economic Area, a breach can bring a manual action, a penalty a Google reviewer applies by hand, shown in Search Console (see how manual actions work).
Lesson 1: Don't rent someone else's reputation
The small business version of the Forbes play is buying a spot in a "best [service] in [city]" article on a news or magazine site, or paying for guest posts stuffed with links. Google's link spam rules name it directly: "Exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links" and advertorials whose links pass ranking credit.
| What you're offered | Google's view | Safer move |
|---|---|---|
| Paid listing in a "best roofers" article on a big site | Site reputation abuse if it's there to rank | Earn local press with real news |
| Sponsored post with a followed link to you | Link spam | Ask for a sponsored-marked link, or skip it |
| Press release with keyword links | Link spam if links pass credit | Fine for news; expect no ranking boost |
Whatever rank borrowed trust gives you can vanish fast, the way Forbes Advisor's did. Honest ways to earn links are in backlinks for a local business.
Lesson 2: Prove first-hand experience
Google's guidance on reviews asks for the thing the criticized pages lacked: evidence you used what you review.
"When recommending something as the best overall or the best for a certain purpose, include why you consider it the best, with first-hand supporting evidence." (Google Search Central: Write high quality reviews)
For a service business, a "review" page is usually a comparison you give customers anyway: tankless versus tank water heaters, metal versus shingle roofs, clear aligners versus braces. Make it trustworthy:
- Photos from your own jobs, not stock images
- Real numbers you measured or quoted, with dates
- Drawbacks of each option, including the one you sell most
- Who wrote it, and why they know (license, years on the tools)
Google says E-E-A-T (experience, expertise, authoritativeness, trust) "isn't a specific ranking factor", but for health, money and safety topics its systems give more weight to content that shows it. More in E-E-A-T for a small business.
Lesson 3: Never fake independence
A "review site" you secretly own, ranking yourself first, breaks US federal law. The FTC's rule on reviews, in force since October 21, 2024, bans a business from misrepresenting that a site it controls "provides independent reviews or opinions" about a category that includes its own services (16 CFR 465.6). The same rule bans fake and bought reviews, and undisclosed reviews by your managers.
In Canada, the Competition Bureau treats this as deceptive marketing. It calls it astroturfing:
"creating commercial representations that masquerade as the authentic experiences and opinions of impartial consumers" (Competition Bureau Canada: Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest, Volume 1)
If you earn money from a recommendation, such as a referral fee from a supplier, say so on the page. How to ask customers for reviews within the rules is in asking for reviews.
Does trustworthy content rank better?
Over time, often, but not through tricks. Bounce rate, comments and "dwell time" are not signals Google confirms. Google's own pages say what it rewards: first-hand experience, a clear purpose and content made for people first. The Forbes story shows the other side: a famous name carried thin pages for years, then stopped.
Example
A roofer offered a "Top 10 roofers" spot
A magazine site offers a roofer a top-3 spot in its "best roofers in Denver" list for $1,500. The page exists to rank, and the link passes credit. Under Google's rules that is both link spam and the pattern of site reputation abuse. The roofer spends the $1,500 on a project gallery of 30 recent jobs instead.
A dentist with a comparison page
A dentist writes "Clear aligners or braces?" with photos of her own cases, typical treatment times from her chart, and when she sends patients to an orthodontist instead. That is first-hand evidence, the kind Google's review guidance asks for.
An HVAC company's "independent" site
An HVAC company builds bestfurnacesguide.com and ranks its own brand first without saying it owns the site. In the US, that is the kind of company-controlled review site 16 CFR 465.6 prohibits.
FAQ
Was Forbes Advisor penalized by Google?
Google never said so publicly. Outside tools showed its main sections lose most of their Google rankings in late 2024, right as Google tightened its site reputation policy.
Is Forbes Advisor owned by Forbes?
It was run by Forbes Marketplace, a separate company in which Forbes held a minority stake, as reported by Lars Lofgren from a Forbes SEC filing in 2024.
Can I still publish guest posts or sponsored content?
Yes. Google allows advertorials meant for readers, and guest writing in general. What breaks the rules is placing pages or followed paid links mainly to borrow a site's ranking.
Are "best of" lists bad for SEO?
No. Google says ranked lists should have enough useful content to stand on their own, with first-hand reasons for each pick.
Different for you?
- A sudden traffic drop after an SEO vendor bought links or placements: manual actions and how to fix them, or traffic dropped after a core update.
- An agency selling "high authority placements": hiring an SEO company.
- Customer reviews on Google rather than review articles: respond to negative Google reviews.
- Want this done on your own site: SEO.