How to measure SEO results: four numbers, in order
Start with customers and work back to rankings. The higher a number sits in this list, the closer it is to money.
| Order | Number | Where to find it (free) | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Calls, forms and bookings from Google search and Maps | Your call log and booking form; GA4 key events from Organic Search | Whether SEO brings customers |
| 2 | Clicks on searches without your business name | Search Console → Performance → Query filter → Non-branded | Whether new people find you |
| 3 | Profile calls, direction requests, website clicks | Google Business Profile → Performance | Whether your Maps listing gets used |
| 4 | Rankings (average position) | Search Console → Performance | An early hint, nothing more |
Google itself ranks position below clicks:
"In general, it's recommended to focus more on trends in impressions and clicks than on position alone." (Search Console Help)
If number 1 grows, Search engine optimization: work that helps your pages show up higher in the unpaid results on Google and Bing. More is working even when rankings wobble. If rankings rise and number 1 doesn't, it isn't working yet.
Branded vs non-branded searches: the real SEO test
Someone who searches your business name already knows you. They would likely find you without SEO. The test is people who searched for the service.
Google's free tool that shows which searches bring people to your site and flags pages Google can't index. More splits the two for you. Branded queries include "your brand name, domain, or a brand-specific product or service" (Search Console Help). Google on the other group:
"non-branded queries offer organic growth, as they show how new users find your content without any initial intent to go to your site." (Google Search Central Blog)
Small sites may not see the filter: it "isn't available for sites with a low number of impressions" (Search Console Help). Then use the query filter "Queries not containing" with your business name. To exclude several spellings, choose Custom (regex), then "Doesn't match regex", and list them as (name one|name two) (Search Console Help).
Where to find calls and bookings from search
- Ask. Put "How did you hear about us?" on your booking form and at the start of every first call. It catches people who saw you on Google and called later from memory.
- GA4. In the Traffic acquisition report, search for "google / organic" to see visits from Google search (Analytics Help). The Organic Search channel counts visits from "Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode" too (Analytics Help). Mark form submissions and booking confirmations as key events. Phone taps need their own setup: see GA4 for a small business.
- Your free business listing on Google Search and Maps: hours, photos, reviews, services and contact details. More. "Calls" is "The number of times a customer clicked on the call button on your Business Profile": taps, not answered calls. And the data "includes views, searches, and actions from both organic search results and Google Ads" (Business Profile Help). If you run ads, some of those calls were paid for.
- Link the profile to GA4. In GA4 Admin, under Product links, choose Google Business Profile links. The link shares "interactions, website clicks, calls, directions, messages, bookings, and menu clicks" (Business Profile Help).
How long before you judge SEO?
A few weeks for one change. Several months for a provider. Google's advice on any change:
"In general, you likely want to wait a few weeks to assess whether your work had beneficial effects in Google Search results." (Google SEO Starter Guide)
Compare like with like. Roofing, HVAC, tax and landscaping all have busy and slow months. Google suggests viewing the last 16 months and using "Compare last 3 months year over year", so a dip that happens every year isn't mistaken for failure (Google Search Central).
For a brand-new site, the timeline is different: see how long SEO takes.
SEO metrics that mislead
| Metric | Why it misleads |
|---|---|
| Domain Authority and tool "SEO scores" | Made by tool companies. Moz, which created Domain Authority, says it "is not a Google ranking factor and has no effect on the SERPs" (Moz). Google: "Third-party tools don't have access to our internal ranking data" (Google Search Central). |
| Impressions alone | An impression is each time your site "appeared in Search results" (Search Console Help). Rising impressions with flat clicks means you're seen but not chosen. |
| One ranking screenshot | Results "are specific to the time, place, device, and recent history of the person searching" (Search Console Help). On Maps, distance to the searcher is a ranking factor (Business Profile Help). |
| Bounce rate | In GA4 it's "the percentage of sessions that were not engaged": 10 seconds or less, no key event, one page (Analytics Help). A visitor who finds your number in 5 seconds and dials it counts as a bounce unless the tap is a key event. |
Is SEO worth it? The ROI math
ROI = (gross profit from customers SEO brought − what SEO cost) ÷ what SEO cost.
- Count new customers whose first contact came from Google search or Maps, from your own records.
- Multiply by your average job value, then by your gross margin. Use profit, not revenue: a $10,000 job at 30% margin earns $3,000 toward the fee.
- Subtract the monthly fee and the value of your own time.
Run it over the last 3 to 6 months, not one month. For what the fee should be, see what SEO costs.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented round numbers.
A plumber paying $1,500 a month (US dollars)
Over six months, non-branded clicks rose from 80 to 260 a month. In month six, 20 callers said "Google" or "Maps"; 10 booked at $450 each, 50% gross margin: $2,250 profit. ROI = (2,250 − 1,500) ÷ 1,500 = 50%. Working.
A dental clinic paying C$2,000 a month (Canadian dollars)
The agency's report shows Domain Authority up 6 points and The number of times your ad or listing was shown, whether or not anyone clicked. doubled. Non-branded clicks are flat at 40 a month, and the front desk logged 2 new patients from Google search. Not working yet. Ask what will move non-branded clicks to the treatment pages.
A roofer in February
Calls from search are down 40% from October. The year-over-year view shows the same dip last February. Seasonal, not failing.
Different for you?
- Setting up the free tools: Google Search Console for a small business.
- Traffic fell suddenly: after a Google core update or after a redesign.
- You want one report for all marketing, not just SEO: the report to ask for.
- The numbers say it isn't working and you're thinking of switching: hiring an SEO company.
- You'd rather have it done and tracked for you: SEO & GEO Agent.