Keyword research questions to ask before you pick keywords
Short answer Ask eight questions: would this searcher pay me, what does Google show for it, do I serve that area, does anyone search it, what do advertisers pay per click, can my site compete, do I already rank for it, and would I write this page without Google. Keep only keywords that pass the first three.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe eight questions, in order
Run every candidate keyword through these. The first three are pass or fail. The rest decide what to do first.
| # | Question | Where to look | Worth it if | Skip or wait if |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Would this searcher pay for what I sell? | Your own judgment, then the results page | They want the job done, or are choosing who does it | They want to do it themselves, or want a job, a definition, a free download |
| 2 | What does Google show for it today? | Search it yourself in a private window | Local map results, service pages, small local sites | Only national brands, directories or a full answer at the top |
| 3 | Do I serve it, where it's searched? | Your service list and service area | You do the job in that town | You'd have to stretch the truth to fit it |
| 4 | Does anyone search it? | Keyword Planner, autocomplete, your calls | Some volume, or customers say these words | No data and no customer ever used the phrase |
| 5 | Is a click worth money to someone? | Keyword Planner "Top of page bid" | Advertisers pay real money per click | Bids near zero and no buyer intent |
| 6 | Can my site compete? | Who ranks on page one | Sites like yours, with thin pages | Page one is all big brands with deep pages |
| 7 | Do I already show up for it? | Search Console, Performance report | Average position around 5 to 20 | Nothing yet (fine, but a slower start) |
| 8 | Would I write this page if Google didn't exist? | Your customers' questions | Yes, customers ask about it | You're only after traffic |
Finding the candidates in the first place, with free tools, is covered in keyword research for a local business. This page is the filter you run afterwards.
Would this searcher ever pay me?
This is the question that saves the most money. A thousand monthly searches from people looking up a definition bring fewer jobs than twenty searches from people ready to book.
Read the words. "Furnace repair" and "furnace making clicking noise" can both bring calls. "How furnaces work" and "HVAC technician salary" almost never do.
What does Google show for this search right now?
Search the keyword yourself and look before you plan a page. Google changes the whole page by the kind of search:
"Based on the user's query the search features that appear on the search results page also change." (Google Search Central: How Search works)
Google's own example: "bicycle repair shops" brings local results, while "modern bicycle" brings images (same page). What you see tells you what to build:
- A map with three businesses: people want someone nearby. Your Business Profile matters as much as a page.
- Service pages from local firms: a page of yours can win here.
- Directories, national chains, marketplaces: hard to beat. Look for a narrower phrase.
- A full answer at the top: many searchers stop there. See featured snippets and zero-click searches.
Results also change with where the searcher is: Google says "bicycle repair shops" shows different results in Paris than in Hong Kong (same page). Check from your own service area.
Do I serve this, where people search for it?
A keyword only pays if you can do the job for the person typing it. For map results Google says:
"Local results are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity." (Google Business Profile Help)
Distance is how far your business is from the searcher (same page). A plumber 40 miles away rarely shows on the map for that town, whatever the page says. Pick towns you actually serve.
Does anyone search it, and what is a click worth?
Keyword Planner, inside Google Ads, answers both. Its search count is an "Approximate number of monthly searches on this query, averaged for the past 12 months" (Google Ads API reference). Treat it as a rough size, not a count. The average hides seasons: Keyword Planner also shows each of the past twelve months (same page), so a snow-removal or pool-opening phrase can look small on average and peak for weeks.
Zero doesn't mean nobody. Google: "Keywords with very low search volumes, or keywords that are considered sensitive aren't discoverable or forecastable." (Google Ads Help). If customers use the phrase on calls, keep it.
The bid columns show what the search is worth. "Top of page bid" comes as a low range (20th percentile) and a high range (80th percentile) of bids (Google Ads API reference). High bids usually mean the searchers buy. A free ranking for that phrase is worth more than one for a phrase nobody bids on.
One trap: Keyword Planner's "Competition" column is about ads. Google defines it as how "competitive ad placement is for a keyword" (same page). It says nothing about how hard ranking in the free results will be.
Can my site actually rank for it?
Look at who holds page one, not at one score. SEO tools sell "keyword difficulty" and "authority" numbers, but they are each vendor's estimate. Moz, which invented one of them:
"DA is a predictive metric developed by Moz and is not used by Google to determine search engine rankings." (Moz: What is Domain Authority?)
Use the numbers to compare, not to decide. The better test: open the top five results. If they are thin pages from businesses your size, a thorough page with your prices and photos can compete. If they are national brands with deep guides, start with a narrower phrase: a service plus your town, or a specific job.
And no one can buy their way up: Google "doesn't accept payment to crawl a site more frequently, or rank it higher" (Google Search Central).
Do I already show up for it?
Search Console shows the searches your site appeared for, with clicks, impressions and "Average position in search results" (Search Console API). A keyword where you already sit at position 5 to 20 is usually the fastest win: the page exists, it needs to be better. How to read the report: Google Search Console for a small business.
Would I write this page if Google didn't exist?
Google lists this as a warning sign:
"Is the content primarily made to attract visits from search engines?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content)
A dentist writing about celebrity teeth for traffic fails this. A dentist answering "how long does a crown last" passes: patients ask it every week.
Then pick the page
One job, one page. Google says its systems "can understand how your page relates to many queries, even if you don't explicitly use the exact terms in them" (Google SEO Starter Guide). So close phrasings share a page; a different job gets its own. If a page for it exists, improve that one. How to build it: on-page SEO for service pages.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A roofer (US dollars)
"Roof replacement cost Tulsa": map results and two local roofers on page one, top of page bid $12 to $35. He already sits at position 14. Passes everything; he improves his replacement page first. "How to become a roofer": 1,000 searches, no paying customers. Dropped.
A family law firm (Canadian dollars)
"Divorce lawyer Calgary": page one is directories and big firms. "Uncontested divorce cost Alberta": smaller, page one has thin pages, bids around C$15. The firm builds a page with its flat-fee range for the second one.
A dog groomer (US dollars)
"Mobile dog grooming" plus her suburb shows no volume in Keyword Planner. Three callers last month used those exact words. She keeps it and names the suburb on her service page.
FAQ
How many keywords should a small business target?
Start with one main search per service you sell, plus your towns. That is often 5 to 20 pages, not hundreds.
Is a low search volume keyword a waste of time?
Not if the searcher is ready to buy and you serve them. Keyword Planner hides very low volumes, so a "zero" can still bring calls.
Are keyword difficulty scores accurate?
They are vendor estimates, and tools often disagree. Looking at the real page one for your area tells you more.
Should I target keywords my competitors rank for?
Only the ones that pass the first three questions for your business. Their keywords fit their services and towns, not always yours.
How often should I redo keyword research?
When you add a service or a town, and when Search Console shows new searches with impressions but few clicks.
Different for you?
- You don't have a list of candidates yet: keyword research for a local business.
- You run Google Ads and want to see which searches you paid for: Google Ads wasted spend.
- You want to cover many towns: city pages for service areas.
- You're unsure a blog is worth it for research searches: does a small business need a blog?.
- You'd rather have the research and pages done for you: SEO & GEO Agent.