Validate keywords before you write: a six-point check
Short answer Validating a keyword means checking it's worth a page before you write one. Pass six checks: real people search it, they want what you sell, sites like yours rank for it, advertisers pay for it, you don't already have a page for it, and you can say something the top results don't. Free Google tools cover all six.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe six-point keyword check
Run a keyword through these six checks before you spend a day writing. If it fails one, drop it, change it, or fold it into a page you already have. Finding keyword ideas in the first place is a separate job: keyword research for a local business.
| # | Check | How to do it, free | Fails when |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Real people search it | Type it into Google and watch autocomplete; look it up in Keyword Planner; look for it in Search Console | No tool shows it and no customer has ever used those words |
| 2 | They want what you sell | Search it yourself and look at what page one is made of | Page one is how-to articles and you sell a service, or the reverse |
| 3 | A site like yours can rank | Note who holds the top results | Every result is a national brand or directory with nothing local or small |
| 4 | It's worth money | Keyword Planner's "Top of page bid" columns | Nobody bids, and the search doesn't lead to a job |
| 5 | You don't already cover it | Search Console: click the query, open the Pages tab | One of your pages already shows for it |
| 6 | You can add something | Read the top three results | You'd only repeat them |
Low numbers on their own are not a fail. A buyer search with 20 searches a month can bring more jobs than a research search with 2,000.
Check 1: does anyone actually search it?
Three free places show real demand.
- Google autocomplete. Start typing the phrase. Google says predictions "reflect real searches that have been done on Google" (Google Search Help: How Google autocomplete predictions work). It also weighs "The location a query is coming from" and "Your past searches", so what you see is partly personal.
- Keyword Planner (inside Google Ads) gives "Avg. monthly searches": the average searches for a keyword "and its close variants" for the location you choose (Google Ads Help: Keyword Planner metrics). Very local phrases often show nothing:
"Keywords with very low search volumes, or keywords that are considered sensitive aren't discoverable or forecastable." (Google Ads Help: Use Keyword Planner)
- Search Console, if your site is live, lists the searches you already appear for. That is the strongest proof, because it's your own data (Search Console Help: Performance report).
Google Trends compares two phrasings, but it shows relative interest, not counts: "Each data point is divided by the total searches of the geography and time range it represents" (Google Trends Help).
If none of these shows the phrase, ask whether customers say it. Words from your own calls and emails count as evidence.
Check 2: does the searcher want what you offer?
Search the keyword and read page one as Google's verdict on intent: what most searchers want.
| Page one shows | The searcher wants | Write |
|---|---|---|
| Map listings and service companies | To hire someone nearby | A service page with prices and a way to book |
| Price guides and comparisons | To decide | A guide that links to your service page |
| Step-by-step how-tos and videos | To do it themselves | Usually skip; these readers rarely call |
If your planned page doesn't match what Google already shows, it's an uphill fight. Change the keyword, or change the page type.
Check 3: can a site like yours get on page one?
Look at who ranks. If small local businesses hold some of the top spots, you can join them. If every result is a national brand, a marketplace or a directory, try a narrower phrase: add your town, a job type or a price word.
For local searches, the map listings follow different rules:
"Local results are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity." (Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google)
So a phrase that's hopeless in the blue links can still bring calls through your Business Profile.
Paid tools give a keyword difficulty score from 0 to 100. Treat it as a rough hint. Ahrefs itself says that if you check the same keywords in different tools, "the numbers will vary quite substantially" (Ahrefs blog: Keyword Difficulty). Your own look at page one counts for more.
Check 4: is it worth money?
Search volume says how many people look. It doesn't say whether they pay. Keyword Planner has a free signal for that: what advertisers bid. "Top of page bid (high range)" is "an approximation of the 80th percentile" of what advertisers "have historically paid for a keyword's top of page bid", for your location (Google Ads Help: Keyword Planner metrics).
Businesses keep paying for clicks that bring them sales, so real bids are a good sign. No bids is a warning. Then do the owner's math: what is one job from this search worth to you, and how many would you need for the page to pay off?
Check 5: do you already have a page for it?
Two pages aimed at one search compete with each other. In Search Console's Performance report, click the query, then the Pages tab, to see which of your URLs Google showed (Search Console Help: Performance report, common tasks). If one already shows, improve that page instead of writing a second one. When to merge or update old pages: content decay.
Check 6: can you say something the top results don't?
Read the top three pages. Then answer Google's own self-check questions honestly:
"Does the content provide original information, reporting, research, or analysis?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content)
"Does the content provide substantial value when compared to other pages in search results?" (same page)
A small business usually has the edge here: your real prices, your job photos, the questions customers ask you, local rules you deal with. If you have none of that for this keyword, it may not be your keyword. Google also asks whether you're writing about something "simply because they seem trending", and says there is no preferred word count (same page). Don't pad.
Keyword validation mistakes
- Choosing by volume alone. Big numbers usually mean broad, hard, mixed-intent searches.
- Skipping your own Search Console. It already shows searches Google links you to.
- Writing a second page for a search you already rank for. Fix the first one.
- Trusting one tool's difficulty score. Tools disagree; page one doesn't lie.
- Validating once. Re-check after you publish (below).
After you publish: did the keyword hold up?
Give a new page a few months, then open Search Console. Check impressions (how often you appeared), clicks and "Average position", which Google defines as "The average position of the topmost result from your site" (Search Console Help: Performance report). Impressions with very few clicks can mean your title doesn't match what searchers want. No impressions at all means the keyword or the page needs another look. What to watch monthly: is my SEO working?.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A pest control company in Texas (US dollars)
"Termite treatment cost Austin" shows in autocomplete, Keyword Planner says 50 searches a month, page one has two local companies, and the top bid is $12. The company has no page for it and has real prices from past jobs. Passes all six: write it.
A bookkeeper in Ontario (Canadian dollars)
"How to do bookkeeping" has thousands of searches, but page one is software companies and how-to videos. It fails checks 2 and 3. She targets "bookkeeper for restaurants Ottawa" instead: tiny volume, but two clients used those words and a client is worth about C$4,000 a year.
A dentist with an existing page
"Teeth whitening cost" looks good, but Search Console shows the whitening page already at position 9. The dentist adds a price table to that page instead of writing a new one.
FAQ
What is keyword validation?
Checking that a keyword is searched, matches what you sell, is winnable and is worth money, before you write a page for it.
Do I need Ahrefs or Semrush to validate keywords?
No. Google's free tools cover the checks for most small businesses. Paid tools add estimates, like difficulty scores, that differ between tools.
Is a keyword with zero search volume worth targeting?
It can be. Keyword Planner hides very low volumes, so "zero" can mean "too few to show". A real buyer search can still bring jobs.
How often should I re-check my keywords?
Look at Search Console monthly and re-run the checks when a page stops getting impressions or clicks, or when you add a service.
Different for you?
- You don't have a keyword list yet: keyword research for a local business.
- The keyword passed and you're writing the page: on-page SEO for service pages.
- You're new to Search Console: Google Search Console for a small business.
- Your keyword is a research question, not a buyer search: does a small business need a blog?.
- You'd rather have keywords checked and pages written for you: SEO & GEO Agent.