Link Building Strategies Ranked by Effort and Payoff
Short answer With little time, start where the site already knows you: fix old page addresses that lost links, ask partners and associations for a listing, and turn plain mentions into links. Then give one hour a week to answering reporters. Save big content projects for later, and skip bought, swapped or tiered links: Google calls them link spam.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhich link building strategies give the most for the least time?
The ones aimed at sites that already know you. A backlink is a link from another website to yours. A link from a site with a reason to name you (a supplier, your trade group, a reporter you helped) is easier to get, safer under Google's rules, and more likely to send real customers.
Here is our ranking for an owner or a two-person team with a few hours a month. Effort and payoff are our judgment, not measured figures.
| Rank | Strategy | Effort | Payoff | Do it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Win back links you lost in a redesign | Low, once | Restores links you already earned | This month |
| 2 | Partner, supplier and association listings | Low, one email each | Relevant links customers click | This month |
| 3 | Turn plain mentions into links | Low, ongoing | The easiest yes | This month |
| 4 | Local sponsorships and events | Low time, costs money | Mostly visitors and mentions | When it fits your budget |
| 5 | Answer reporter requests | Medium, steady | Few wins, but strong ones | One hour a week |
| 6 | Guest spots on podcasts or local shows | Medium | A link in the show notes plus an audience | A few a year |
| 7 | One page with facts others cite | High, once | Keeps earning links for years | After the quick wins |
| 8 | A guest article on a site your customers read | High per link | One good link and readers | Only for the right site |
| 9 | Replace dead links on other sites | High research, often a paid tool | Hit or miss | Only with a tool |
| 10 | "Skyscraper" (outdo a popular page, then pitch its linkers) | Highest | Rarely pays for a small team | Skip unless content is your business |
How we ranked them: effort is hours plus any tool you'd have to buy; payoff is whether the link comes from a relevant site and brings visitors; anything Google lists as link spam fell off the list entirely.
The quick wins: an afternoon each
1. Win back lost links. Search Console's Links report shows who links to you and includes links Google "has found over time" (Search Console Help: Links report). Open your most-linked pages. Any that no longer load need a permanent redirect to the closest live page.
2. Ask partners for a listing. Manufacturers' "find an installer" pages, trade association member lists, and the vendor lists of builders or property managers. One short email each, asking them to link your name to the matching service page.
3. Turn mentions into links. Google Alerts can email you when new results mention your name (Google Search Help: Create an alert). When a site names you without a link, thank the writer and ask for one. They already chose to mention you.
4. Sponsor locally, labeled. A team or charity page that lists sponsors is a paid link, so it should carry a nofollow or sponsored label. Google says that's allowed:
"It's not a violation of our policies to have such links as long as they are qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" attribute value..." (Google Search Central: Spam policies)
The label means little ranking credit. The payoff is the local mention and the people who see it.
Step-by-step versions of these are in link building tactics.
Worth a steady hour a week
5. Answer reporters. HARO (Help a Reporter Out) still offers "free daily media queries" to sources (HARO). Reply only where you have real expertise, in a few plain sentences, with your name, title and website. Most replies go nowhere; one quote in a local paper or trade outlet can outweigh a year of directory listings. More in digital PR strategy.
6. Be a guest on a show. Local business podcasts, trade association webinars and community radio often link guests in their show notes. Pitch one specific topic you know cold.
Big projects: only when the quick wins are done
7. One citable page. Sites link to facts or tools they can't get elsewhere: your real price ranges, local permit times, a simple cost calculator. Date it and say where the numbers come from. See content that earns backlinks.
8. A guest article. Fine when the site's readers are your customers. Google lists "links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases" as link spam, so let the link use your business name.
9. Dead-link replacement. Finding broken links at scale usually takes a paid SEO tool. Worth it only if you already pay for one; the method is in broken link building.
10. Skyscraper. You'd write a better version of a page that has many links, then email every site linking to the old one. It's heavy writing plus mass outreach, and most of those emails go unanswered. A small service business usually has better uses for that time.
Which "advanced" link strategies should you skip?
Google defines link spam as links made "primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings" (Google Search Central: Spam policies). That rules out several things sold as advanced:
| Offer | Why to skip it |
|---|---|
| Paid placement on a "quality" site with a normal link | Google lists "Exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links" as link spam, however good the site |
| Tiered links (links pointed at the pages that already link to you) | Their only purpose is to push rankings; Google also lists "Creating low-value content primarily for the purposes of manipulating linking and ranking signals" |
| "Link to me and I'll link to you" | "Excessive link exchanges" are spam |
| Infographic or widget embeds carrying keyword links | Google names "Keyword-rich, hidden, or low-quality links embedded in widgets" |
| Bulk directory or forum links | Low-quality directory links and forum signature links are on the list |
Bing bans the same: "link buying, link spamming, private networks, and artificial social promotion schemes that simulate popularity" (Bing Webmaster Guidelines). If a warning arrives anyway, see Google manual action.
What about "link velocity," the idea that links arriving too fast trigger a penalty? Google's spam policy doesn't mention speed. It judges why a link was made. A news story that earns 30 links in a week is fine; 30 bought links over a year are not.
How do you know it's working?
Every few months, check three things: new linking sites in Search Console's Links report, visitors arriving from those sites in your analytics, and whether those sites match your customers. To see who links to competitors, Bing Webmaster Tools shows "link profiles for both your own site and competitors" (Bing Webmaster Blog, June 2025).
Ignore "authority" scores from SEO tools as a goal. Moz, which created Domain Authority, says it "is not used by Google to determine search engine rankings" (Moz: Domain Authority).
Example
A plumber with four hours a month
Month one: he redirects two old service pages that still had links, and emails the water heater maker and his state trade association. Both list him. After that, he spends one hour a week on reporter requests. By month six he has five new linking sites, all relevant.
A bookkeeper tempted by a $400 "guest post package"
The seller promises five posts with keyword links. That's paying for links, which Google lists as spam. She spends the $400 sponsoring a chamber of commerce breakfast instead; the chamber lists her with a sponsored link and introduces her to members.
A two-person web design studio
Content is their trade, so a citable page fits: they publish real page-load times from 50 local business sites they tested. Two local news blogs link to it within a quarter.
FAQ
How many hours a month does link building take?
There's no fixed number. The quick wins take an afternoon each; after that, about an hour a week keeps reporter replies and mention follow-ups going.
Which strategy should I start with?
Lost links and partner listings. Both cost nothing, and the other site already has a reason to link to you.
Is guest posting still worth it?
For one site your customers read, yes. Writing many guest posts mainly to plant keyword links is link spam under Google's rules.
Can I pay for links if the site is high quality?
Only with a nofollow or sponsored label. Without it, Google treats any paid link as link spam, whatever the site's quality.
Does tiered link building work?
It's built to manipulate rankings, which is Google's definition of link spam. The risk outweighs anything it might add.
Different for you?
- You need step-by-step instructions for each tactic: link building tactics.
- You run a local business and fear a penalty: backlinks for a local business.
- You want to know how many links you need: how many backlinks do you need.
- You're choosing directories to join: local citations and directories.
- You'd rather have someone run the outreach and track it: SEO & GEO Agent.