Link Building Techniques Compared: Guest Posts to Skyscraper
Short answer For most small businesses, resource pages come first: local lists already exist, and one email can earn a link. Broken link building is next when a dead page had many links. Guest posts suit owners who can write for one site their customers read. The skyscraper technique costs the most work and suits sites with a real data or content edge.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhich link building technique should I use?
Pick by what you already have. A backlink is a link from another website to yours. All four techniques below get one the same way: you find a page, offer something useful, and ask by email. They differ in what you must make first.
| Resource pages | Broken link building | Guest blogging | Skyscraper | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What you do | Ask to be added to a list of useful links | Find a dead link, offer your page as the fix | Write an article for another site | Make a better version of a much-linked page, pitch everyone who linked |
| What you need first | One good page or your business itself | A page that truly replaces the dead one | Time to write one strong article | A content or data edge, plus a backlink tool |
| Effort per link | Low | Medium | High | Highest |
| Tool cost | Free | Free for small runs; paid tools speed it up | Free | Usually a paid backlink tool |
| Rule risk | Low | Low | Medium: anchor text and scale matter | Low |
| Best fit | Local service businesses | Anyone near a closed rival or rotting list | Owners with real expertise to share | Sites that can publish original data |
All four are allowed by Google when you offer nothing in return for the link. The risk column is about how people misuse them, covered below.
Resource pages: the easiest start for a local business
Resource pages are lists a site keeps for its readers: a chamber of commerce member directory, a city's "community resources" page, a school's or homeowners' association's recommended vendors. They exist to link out, so the ask is small.
How to find them: search your town or trade plus words like "resources", "useful links" or "recommended". Check each list is current and that your business fits it. Then email whoever maintains it with one line on why your page helps their readers.
The catch: many lists require membership or a sponsorship. That's fine for a real membership. But Google's link spam examples include "Exchanging money for links", so if a site sells only the link, it should be marked as paid (Google: Spam policies). Google says a paid link is allowed "as long as they are qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" attribute value" (Google: Spam policies). Pay for the membership's other value, not the link.
Broken link building: best when a rival closed
You find a link on someone's page that now leads to an error, and suggest your working page instead. It helps the site owner, so the pitch is easy to accept.
It pays most when one dead page had links from many sites, because a single replacement page can be pitched to all of them. For a local business, the usual find is a closed competitor still listed on local pages. Our broken link building guide covers the tools and steps.
The catch: your page must really replace what was lost. A dead price guide needs a price guide, not your home page.
Guest blogging: allowed, with two limits
Google doesn't object to guest posts. Its 2017 reminder on the topic says:
"Google does not discourage these types of articles in the cases when they inform users, educate another site's audience or bring awareness to your cause or company." (Google Search Central Blog, 2017)
The problem is scale and anchor text, the clickable words of a link. Google's current link spam examples include "links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases distributed on other sites" (Google: Spam policies). The 2017 post also flags articles "published across many different sites" and writers who "aren't knowledgeable about the topics" (Google Search Central Blog, 2017).
So: one useful article, on a site your customers actually read, with your business name as the link. Never pay for the slot or trade a post for a post. If the host marks your link nofollow, that's their call and still worth the exposure.
Skyscraper technique: does it still work?
Yes, if "better" means more useful, not longer. Brian Dean of Backlinko named it in three steps: find link-worthy content, "make something even better", and reach out to the right people (Backlinko: Skyscraper Technique, updated 2024).
The trap is copying a popular page and adding length. Google asks whether content will "avoid simply copying or rewriting those sources, and instead provide substantial additional value and originality" (Google: helpful content). It also asks:
"Does the content provide original information, reporting, research, or analysis?" (Google: helpful content)
A small business rarely wins on size, but it often has what big sites lack: real prices from its own jobs, local permit rules, photos from the field. That's the edge a skyscraper page needs. Without it, skip this one. See linkable assets for page types that earn links.
The catch: finding everyone who linked to the original needs a backlink tool, and most free tiers only show your own site. Budget for a month of a paid plan, or use link prospecting to work from a short list.
What do all four have in common?
An outreach email, and most go unanswered. A 2019 study of 12 million outreach emails by Backlinko and the outreach tool Pitchbox found "only 8.5% of all outreach emails receive a response", and a reply is not a link (Backlinko: outreach study). The same study found one follow-up raised replies. Send a few personal emails, follow up once, then stop.
The email rules differ by country:
- US: CAN-SPAM covers commercial email, and "The law makes no exception for business-to-business email." Include "your valid physical postal address" and a clear way to opt out (FTC: CAN-SPAM guide).
- Canada: CASL implies consent when the person "has conspicuously published" the address with no refusal of such mail, and the message is relevant to their "business, role, functions or duties" (CASL, section 10(9)(b)). An editor's address published on the site can qualify; one you found elsewhere doesn't.
Whatever the technique, judge the target site first: a link from a site your customers use beats a high score from an unrelated one. See what makes a quality backlink.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A landscaper in a small city (US dollars)
He spends one afternoon on resource pages: the chamber directory (part of his $300 yearly membership), the garden club's vendor list and a realtor's "trusted pros" page. Two add him. No tool cost.
A bookkeeper weighing guest posts (Canadian dollars)
A regional business magazine accepts expert articles. She writes one on year-end payroll deadlines and links her firm by name. One link, about six hours of work, $0 paid. She turns down a "guest post package" at $400 for five posts, since that buys links.
A roofing company with job data (US dollars)
It has costs from 200 local jobs. It publishes a roof replacement cost page with real ranges, pays $129 for one month of a backlink tool, and emails 30 sites that link to an older national cost guide. A few reply; two link.
FAQ
Which link building technique is fastest?
Resource pages, for a local business: the lists already exist and the ask is one line. Skyscraper is the slowest, since you build the page before you pitch.
Is guest blogging still worth it in 2026?
Yes, when the site's readers are your customers and the article is genuinely useful. A pile of posts on unrelated sites with keyword-stuffed links is link spam under Google's policies.
Do I need a paid tool for any of these?
Not for resource pages or guest posts. Broken link building can start free on local lists. Skyscraper usually needs a paid backlink tool to see who links to the original.
Can I combine techniques?
Yes, and most businesses do. One strong page can be pitched to resource lists, offered as a broken link fix and cited in a guest post.
Different for you?
- You want more tactics, including reporter quotes and partner links: link building tactics.
- A rival closed or a local list has dead links: broken link building.
- You need a list of sites to pitch: link prospecting.
- You need a page worth linking to first: linkable assets.
- You'd rather have the prospecting and pitching done for you: SEO & GEO Agent.