Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Starting an online business: platforms, money and legal basics

Updated · 6 min read

Short answer Before the first sale, pick a store platform and know its full fee (subscription plus about 2.9% + 30 cents per card payment), choose a structure, get tax numbers, open a separate bank account, and post privacy, shipping and refund policies. Your home state may require a seller's permit from day one; other states and GST/HST start at thresholds.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

The setup checklist before your first order

Seven things, in this order. Structure and tax questions are worth a call to an accountant.

StepUnited StatesCanada
1. Check the nameUSPTO trademark databaseCIPO Canadian Trademarks Database
2. Pick a structureSole proprietor, LLC or corporationSole proprietor, partnership or corporation
3. Get tax numbersEIN from the IRS, freeBusiness number (BN) from the CRA when you need a program account
4. Open a business bank accountRecommended by the IRSSame logic: clean records
5. Choose a store platform and payment processorShopify, Squarespace, WooCommerce and othersSame platforms; fees in CAD
6. Set up bookkeepingSchedule C for sole proprietorsForm T2125 for sole proprietors
7. Post legal pagesPrivacy, shipping, refundsPrivacy, shipping, refunds; provincial consumer rules

Then sales tax: in the US, your home state may require a seller's permit before the first sale; other states, and Canada's GST/HST, start at sales thresholds. Details below.

Which platform should I build my store on?

Pick on total monthly cost and how much setup you want to do yourself. A hosted platform runs the servers and security for you; a self-hosted one is cheaper to start but you pay for hosting and add-ons.

PlatformMonthly price (USD, billed yearly)What else you pay
Shopify Basic$29 (Shopify)2.9% + 30¢ per online card payment with its own processor
Squarespace Basic$19 (Squarespace)2% transaction fee on top of 2.9% + $0.30 card processing
Squarespace Core$29 (Squarespace)0% transaction fee; 2.9% + $0.30 card processing
WooCommerceFree plugin (WooCommerce)Hosting, which WooCommerce puts at $25–$350 a month for most stores, plus paid extensions at $29–$299 a year each

The cheapest sticker price is not always the cheapest plan. Squarespace Basic's 2% fee costs more than the $10 jump to Core once you sell over $500 a month. If you sell a service (bookings, quotes) rather than products, you may not need a store platform at all; see what a small business website costs. For how each platform does in Google, see the best ecommerce platform for SEO.

What does it cost to take card payments?

Plan on about 2.9% plus 30 cents per card sale. Stripe's standard US rate is "2.9% + 30¢ per successful transaction for domestic cards" (Stripe), and its Canadian rate is 2.9% + CA$0.30 (Stripe Canada). Shopify's built-in processor charges the same 2.9% + 30¢ on its Basic plan (Shopify). The fixed 30 cents hurts small orders most: on a $10 sale it adds 3 points to your fee.

Do I need an LLC or a corporation?

Not to start selling, but a sole proprietorship gives you no shield. The SBA says a sole proprietor's business and personal assets and debts are not separate:

"You can be held personally liable for the debts and obligations of the business." (SBA: Choose a business structure)

The SBA adds that an LLC protects owners from personal liability "in most instances". Canada has no LLC; the CRA says a sole proprietor's risks "extend even to your personal property and assets" (CRA), while corporation shareholders "are not responsible for the corporation's debts", unless they personally guarantee a loan (CRA). The right choice depends on your risk and taxes; that is a question for an accountant or lawyer.

Which tax numbers do I need?

US: an EIN (Employer Identification Number, the business's tax ID). The IRS lists hiring employees, running a partnership or corporation, and paying sales or excise taxes as common reasons to need one, and says:

"You never have to pay a fee for an EIN." (IRS)

Sites that charge for an EIN are middlemen. Canada: the CRA says not every business needs a BN; you need one when you incorporate or open a GST/HST, payroll or other CRA program account (CRA).

When do I have to charge sales tax?

US, your home state: a state where you have a location usually expects tax from the first sale. California, for example, says that if you sell tangible goods in the state, "you are required to hold a seller's permit", including for internet sales (CDTFA Publication 107).

US, other states: each state sets its own rules for sellers based elsewhere. South Dakota, for example, requires a license only from remote sellers with "more than $100,000 in gross sales in South Dakota in the previous or current calendar year" (South Dakota Department of Revenue).

Canada: you are a "small supplier" until your taxable sales pass $30,000. Pass it in one calendar quarter and you must charge GST/HST from the sale that crossed the line. Pass it over four quarters and you stop being a small supplier at the end of the month after that quarter (CRA).

How should I handle bookkeeping from day one?

Keep business money in its own account and log every expense from the start. IRS Publication 583 says "You should keep your business account separate from your personal checking account" (IRS Publication 583). Early records pay off: you can elect to deduct up to $5,000 of start-up costs, reduced once those costs pass $50,000 (same source).

United StatesCanada
Where a sole proprietor reports profitSchedule C, plus Schedule SE for self-employment tax (IRS)Form T2125 (CRA)
How long to keep recordsUntil the period of limitations for that return runs out (IRS Publication 583)Six years (CRA)

Spreadsheet or accounting software both work; what matters is that every sale and fee lands somewhere the day it happens.

Three: privacy, shipping and refunds. Each states a promise you then must keep.

  • Privacy policy. Say what you collect and why, and do what it says. The FTC's guide for business builds data security on five principles: know what you hold, keep only what you need, protect it, dispose of it properly, and plan for a breach (FTC). In Canada, PIPEDA covers private businesses that handle personal information in commercial activity; Alberta, British Columbia and Quebec have their own private-sector privacy laws (Office of the Privacy Commissioner).
  • Shipping policy. In the US, the FTC's mail order rule applies even when you state no shipping time:
"If you make no shipment statement, you must have a reasonable basis for believing that you can ship within 30 days." (FTC)

If you will be late, you must ask the buyer to accept the delay, and refund promptly if they cancel (same source).

  • Refund policy. In Canada, buying goods and services falls largely under provincial and territorial law (Office of Consumer Affairs), so check your province's consumer office.

Ads, emails and reviews have their own rules; see digital marketing legal rules.

Example

A US candle shop on Shopify

40 orders a month at $50 is $2,000 in sales. Card fees: 2.9% of $2,000 is $58, plus 40 × $0.30 = $12, so $70. Add the $29 plan: about $99 a month, or 5% of sales, before shipping and ads.

The same shop on Squarespace Basic

$19 plan + $40 transaction fee (2%) + $70 card fees = $129. Core at $29 with no transaction fee would cost $99.

A Canadian online jewelry shop

Sales of about CA$9,000 a quarter reach CA$36,000 after four quarters, past the CA$30,000 line. The shop stops being a small supplier at the end of the month after that quarter and must register for GST/HST.

FAQ

Can I start selling online before forming an LLC?

Yes. You can sell as a sole proprietor in both countries, but you are personally liable for the business's debts.

Is an EIN free?

Yes. The IRS charges nothing for an EIN; sites that charge are reselling a free form.

Can I use my personal bank account?

You can, but the IRS recommends a separate account, and mixing them makes taxes and records harder.

Do I charge sales tax to customers in other states?

Only once you pass that state's threshold, such as South Dakota's $100,000 in yearly sales there.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextStartup legal basics: structure, contracts, permits and IPThe legal steps a new business takes in the US and Canada: pick a structure, register, get tax numbers and permits, sign contracts, own your logo and site.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Shopify: Pricing
  2. Squarespace: Pricing
  3. WooCommerce: Pricing
  4. Stripe: Pricing (US)
  5. Stripe: Pricing (Canada)
  6. SBA: Choose a business structure
  7. CRA: Sole proprietorship
  8. CRA: Corporation
  9. IRS: Get an employer identification number
  10. IRS: Sole proprietorships
  11. IRS Publication 583: Starting a Business and Keeping Records
  12. CDTFA Publication 107: Do You Need a California Seller's Permit?
  13. South Dakota Department of Revenue: 2023 legislative updates
  14. CRA: When you need a business number or program account
  15. CRA: When to register for and start charging the GST/HST
  16. CRA: Report business income and expenses
  17. CRA: Where to keep your records, how long to keep them
  18. FTC: Business Guide to the Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule
  19. FTC: Protecting Personal Information, A Guide for Business
  20. Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada: PIPEDA in brief
  21. Office of Consumer Affairs: Consumer protection legislation in Canada
  22. USPTO: Search our trademark database
  23. CIPO: Canadian Trademarks Database