What does pay per placement (P4P) mean?
You pay to be put in a spot: a search result, a page on a website, a story in a publication. The term is loose. It gets used for four deals that work very differently, so ask which one you're being offered.
| What you're offered | What you pay for | Is the spot guaranteed? |
|---|---|---|
| Google search ads | Each click (pay per click, or PPC) | No. Google reruns the auction on every search |
| Google display or YouTube "placements" (sites, apps or videos you pick) | Clicks or views, for example per 1,000 views (CPM) | No. Other advertisers bid for the same sites |
| Pay-per-placement PR (public relations) | A set fee to a PR firm for each story that runs | No. An editor decides whether it runs |
| Sponsored article bought from a publication | A fee to the outlet or a writer | Yes, because it's an ad, and it must be labeled as one |
Google defines CPM (cost per mille, Latin for thousand) as a way to bid where you "pay per one thousand views (impressions) on the Google Display Network." An impression is one showing of your ad.
How is pay per placement different from pay per click?
Pay per click describes billing: you pay only when someone clicks. Pay per placement describes what you buy: a position. The two can overlap. Early paid search engines sold position and billed by the click. A sponsored article sells position for a flat fee, clicked or not.
| Pay per click | Flat-fee placement | |
|---|---|---|
| You pay when | Someone clicks your ad | The spot runs |
| If nobody clicks | You pay nothing | You still pay |
| Who decides your position | The platform, search by search | The deal you signed |
| Main risk | Clicks that never become customers | A spot nobody notices |
Where did pay per placement come from?
From search engines in the late 1990s. GoTo.com launched its model on June 1, 1998, according to its 1999 filing with the SEC (the US securities regulator):
"The advertiser with the highest bid is listed first in the search results, with the remaining advertisers appearing in descending bid amount order." (GoTo.com, Form S-1)
| When | What happened |
|---|---|
| 1998 | GoTo.com ranks paid listings by bid. Each advertiser pays per click |
| 2001 | GoTo.com, renamed Overture, charges each advertiser "the amount of its bid" per click and shows rivals' bids (Overture annual report) |
| July 2001 | The watchdog group Commercial Alert asks the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to act against search engines that don't disclose paid listings |
| June 2002 | FTC staff decline formal action but tell search engines to label paid placement clearly |
| June 2013 | FTC staff repeat it as labels fade: "Including or ranking a search result in whole or in part based on payment is a form of advertising." |
The 2002 letter gave the working definition:
"In conducting its review, the staff considered 'paid placement' to be any program in which individual Web sites or URLs can pay for a higher ranking in a search results list, with the result that relevancy measures alone do not dictate their rank." (FTC staff letter to Commercial Alert, June 27, 2002)
How does it work on Google today?
Money still matters, but it no longer buys the top spot outright. Google runs an auction for every search and ranks ads by Ad Rank: your bid, the quality of your ad and the page it links to, the context of the search and other factors.
"So, even if your competition has higher bids than yours, you can still win a higher position at a lower price by using highly relevant keywords and ads." (Google Ads Help: Ad Rank)
You also often pay less than your bid: Google charges "only what's minimally required to clear the Ad Rank thresholds and beat the Ad Rank of the competitor immediately below you." Your position can change from one search to the next.
The closest thing to buying a placement is a bid setting called Target impression share. You pick a position (Top, Absolute top, meaning the very first ad, or Anywhere) and a percentage. Set 65% for absolute top, and Google sets your per-click bids to aim for that spot in 65% of the times your ad could show. You still pay per click. Google says it can be useful for campaigns on your brand name.
Display and YouTube "placements" are sites, apps or videos you choose. Picking one doesn't reserve it: Google says "you'll compete with other advertisers to show your ads on placements you select."
What is pay-per-placement PR?
A PR firm pitches your story to journalists and bills you a set fee for each placement it lands. PR News described the model this way in 2005: fees scale with the outlet's audience, and no such firm will guarantee coverage. You pay the PR firm, not the outlet. The editor decides, so the coverage is earned.
Once money reaches the outlet or a writer, it's advertising. The Public Relations Society of America (PRSA) calls the hidden version pay-for-play:
"It involves a transaction where the payor makes undisclosed payments to the media channel to feature specific content, whether that content be blog posts, videos interviews, podcast interviews, print or digital columns or interviews." (PRSA Code of Ethics: Pay for Play)
Before you sign, ask the firm:
- Who gets paid: only the firm, or the outlet or a contributor too?
- What counts as a placement: a full story, a one-line mention, a reprint on a partner site?
- Will any paid piece carry an "Ad" or "Sponsored" label, with links marked as paid?
- What happens if the outlet edits or pulls the story?
What can go wrong with pay per placement?
| Risk | What the rule says |
|---|---|
| A paid article that reads like news | US: the FTC treats it as deceptive when readers are misled. Canada: the Competition Bureau calls hidden ads misleading |
| Paid links that pass ranking credit | Google's spam policies count them as link spam |
| A "guaranteed" top spot | Ad Rank changes every search. For free results, Google says: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." |
| An old price list for big-name outlets | Programs close: HuffPost announced the end of its contributor platform on January 18, 2018 |
| Paying for exposure, not customers | A placement or a click isn't a sale. Count calls and bookings |
The FTC's rule on disguised ads:
"The Commission has long held the view that advertising and promotional messages that are not identifiable as advertising to consumers are deceptive if they mislead consumers into believing they are independent, impartial, or not from the sponsoring advertiser itself." (FTC: Enforcement Policy Statement on Deceptively Formatted Advertisements)
The FTC's business guide says "advertisers are responsible for ensuring that native ads are identifiable as advertising" (native ads match the look of the page around them). So the label is your problem too, not only the publisher's. Labels it calls likely to be understood include "Ad," "Advertisement" and "Paid Advertisement."
In Canada, the Competition Bureau says the Competition Act's deceptive marketing rules apply to "anyone who is promoting a product, service, or any business interest," and that "It's misleading if you don't make it clear that your online content is actually an advertisement." The industry's Canadian Code of Advertising Standards agrees: "No advertisement shall be presented in a format or style that conceals the fact that it is an advertisement."
For search rankings, Google lists as link spam:
"Advertorials or native advertising where payment is received for articles that include links that pass ranking credit, or links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases distributed on other sites." (Google Search Central: Spam policies)
The fix is rel="sponsored", a small code label the publisher adds to the link. Google says to mark "advertisements or paid placements (commonly called paid links)" this way. More in backlinks for a local business.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A roofer offered a "guaranteed #1 on Google" (US dollars)
A caller offers the top Google spot for $900 a month, guaranteed. Neither ads nor free results work that way, so the roofer asks in writing what the $900 buys. If it's Google Ads, they can run the ads themselves with Target impression share at absolute top on their company name, pay per click, and check the hit rate in the report.
A Calgary accountant offered pay-per-placement PR (Canadian dollars)
A PR firm quotes C$600 per story in a local business paper, billed only when a story runs. The accountant confirms in the contract that no money goes to the outlet. Three stories in a month cost C$1,800. A month with none costs nothing.
A dental office buying a sponsored article (US dollars)
A local news site sells a $400 featured story. It runs under a "Sponsored" label, and the link to the office's site carries rel="sponsored". The office judges it by calls to a tracking number printed in the article, not by rankings.
FAQ
Is P4P the same as PPC?
Not quite. PPC bills per click; P4P buys a position. Early search engines did both. A flat-fee sponsored article is P4P with no clicks counted.
Can I pay Google for the top ad spot?
No. Google reranks ads every search by bid, ad quality and more. Target impression share aims for the top, and you still pay per click.
Is paying for a media placement legal?
Paying isn't the problem; hiding it is. The FTC calls misleading disguised ads deceptive; Canada's Competition Bureau calls hidden ads misleading.
Is pay-per-placement PR worth it for a small business?
It can, if you have real news; you pay only for stories that run. For steady monthly calls, search ads are easier to track.
Different for you?
- You want ads that show when people search for your service: Google Ads for small business.
- You're choosing between ads and free rankings: SEO vs Google Ads.
- Someone offers paid guest posts or links: backlinks for a local business.
- Someone promises a #1 ranking: hiring an SEO company.
- You need a monthly number: Google Ads budget for a small business.
- You'd rather have the ads run for you: Paid Ads Agent.