Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Run of site vs targeted ads: pros and cons for a small business

Updated · 7 min read

Short answer Run of site (ROS) shows your ad on any page of one website, to everyone who visits. Targeted ads pick the people, places or topics. ROS wins when most of that site's readers could hire you and its price is low. Targeting wins when you need one area, people searching now, or past visitors, and its extra cost buys more accuracy than it adds.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Run of site vs targeted ads: the difference

With run of site, you buy space on one website and the site decides which pages and slots carry your ad. Anyone reading that site can see it. With targeted ads, you or the ad platform decide who sees the ad: people in a city, people reading about a topic, people who visited your website.

Run of siteTargeted
Who chooses the readerThe website's audience, as a wholeYou, by area, topic, interest or past visit
Price per 1,000 viewsLowerHigher
WasteEveryone on the site who will never buyWrong guesses in the audience data
Best goalBeing known in one placeLeads, calls, bookings
What you controlWhich siteWho, where, and how often

Run of network is the same idea across many sites: you pick the network, not the sites. Google's Display Network is the biggest one, "a group of more than 2 million websites, videos, and apps where your ads can appear" (Google Ads Help: Display Network definition).

Pros and cons of run of site ads

Pros:

  • Cheap reach. You pay less per 1,000 views because you give up the choice of page and slot.
  • No data guesswork. The site's own audience is the target. If that audience is your market, there's nothing to get wrong.
  • Simple. One site, one order, one report.

Cons:

  • You pay for everyone. A regional news site's readers include people outside your service area, renters if you sell roofs, people who just hired a competitor.
  • Weak placement. Your ad goes wherever the site has room, not the spots you'd pick.
  • Hard to tie to leads. Most views never click, so results show up slowly, if at all, in your calls and bookings.

Pros and cons of targeted ads

Pros:

  • Fewer wasted views. You can limit ads to your area, to a topic, or to people who already visited your site.
  • Control. You can pick sites by hand, raise bids where results come in, and limit how often one person sees you.
  • Easier to measure. Smaller, closer audiences make it easier to see which ads bring leads.

Cons:

  • Each layer shrinks the audience. Google's own rule: "Generally each time you add a new layer of targeting, you narrow the potential reach of your ads" (Google Ads Help: About targeting for Display campaigns).
  • Audience data is often wrong. In three field studies of more than 90 audience segments from 19 data brokers, the researchers found:
"Audience segments vary greatly in quality and are often inaccurate across leading data brokers." (Neumann, Tucker and Whitfield, Marketing Science, 2019)
  • Popular spots cost more. Google warns that if you choose popular sites or videos, "you may need higher bids to get impressions" (Google Ads Help: About placement targeting).

Is targeting worth the extra cost?

Only when it raises your share of right people by more than it raises the price. In the same 2019 study, display targeting with bought audience data cost about 151% extra on average, while the best case found the right person 123% more often than picking people at random. A gender segment was about as accurate as chance. The authors concluded third-party audiences "are often economically unattractive except for higher-priced media placements" (study abstract; INFORMS news release, November 4, 2019).

That study tested bought interest and demographic data. It says nothing against the targeting a local business depends on most: location, a search someone just typed, or your own past visitors.

The test, in plain math: divide the price per 1,000 views by the share of viewers who could actually hire you.

Price per 1,000 viewsShare who could hire youCost per 1,000 right people
Run of site, regional site$825%$32
Targeted to your county$2080%$25

These numbers are illustrative. Ask each seller for its own price and the share of its readers in your area, then run the same division.

When run of site beats targeting

  • The site's audience is your market. A town news site, a neighborhood group's site, a trade publication your buyers read. Picking the site already did the targeting.
  • The goal is being known, not clicked today. A new location, a launch, the start of your busy season.
  • The targeting premium is bigger than the gain. If a seller wants double the price to "target" homeowners on a site that's mostly local homeowners anyway, you're paying twice for the same people.

When targeted ads win

  • You serve one area. A plumber covering one county gets nothing from readers three states away. Location targeting is the one filter almost every local business needs.
  • People search before they buy. Someone typing "water heater repair" is a better prospect than any audience segment. That's search ads, not display.
  • You want past visitors back. Google lets you show ads to people who visited your site, but a list needs "a minimum of 100 active visitors or users within the last 30 days" before ads run (Google Ads Help: About audience segments in Audience manager).
  • You need control over repeats. In Google Display campaigns, a frequency cap limits "the number of impressions you will allow an individual user to have on the campaign per day, week, or month" (Google Ads Help: Frequency capping definition). A site's ROS package may not offer this; ask.

Can you mix them?

Yes, and that's often the best of both. Two common ways:

  1. Pick the site, target inside it. In Google Ads, placement targeting lets you "hand-pick placements to run your ads on YouTube and the Display Network", including one website or a single page (Google Ads Help: About placement targeting). Add location targeting on top, and you get that site's readers in your area only.
  2. Broad first, narrow second. Run cheap reach on one strong local site to get known, then show ads to the people who visited your website afterward.

One catch on Google: optimized targeting gives a campaign "flexibility to explore which customers have the highest likelihood to convert", using your keywords or audiences only as signals (Google Ads Help: About targeting for Display campaigns). If you aimed by audience or keyword, check this setting: your ads can reach people beyond what you chose.

Example

Illustrative cases, round numbers, US dollars.

A roofer and the town news site

The town's news site offers 100,000 ROS impressions a month for $600 ($6 per 1,000). The publisher says about 70% of readers live in the roofer's service area. Cost per 1,000 local readers: about $8.60. A data broker's "homeowners in your county" segment on other sites quotes $18 per 1,000. ROS on the town site wins.

An HVAC company on a regional TV station's site

The station's site reaches three states; about 15% of readers are in the company's area. At $10 per 1,000, that's about $67 per 1,000 local readers. Placement targeting on the same site in Google Ads, limited to the company's area, costs more per view but cuts the waste. Targeted wins.

A med spa with 60 site visitors a month

It wants to show ads to past visitors, but its list is below Google's 100-visitor minimum. It runs ROS on a local lifestyle site for a season, which brings more visitors, then turns on ads to past visitors once the list qualifies.

FAQ

Is run of site the same as run of network?

No. Run of site covers one website's pages. Run of network spreads your ad across many sites, usually without letting you choose them.

Is run of site cheaper than targeted ads?

Per 1,000 views, usually yes. Per 1,000 people who could hire you, either can win: divide each price by its share of right people.

Do run of site ads get calls and leads?

Sometimes, but they're built for being seen. If you need calls this month, search ads aimed at people looking for your service usually come first.

Can I target by location inside a run of site deal?

Some publishers can; ask before you buy. In Google Ads, add the site as a placement and set your location.

Different for you?

Keep learning

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Neumann, Tucker and Whitfield: How Effective Is Third-Party Consumer Profiling? Evidence from Field Studies (Marketing Science, 2019)
  2. INFORMS news release on the Marketing Science study (November 4, 2019)
  3. Google Ads Help: About targeting for Display campaigns
  4. Google Ads Help: About placement targeting
  5. Google Ads Help: Display Network definition
  6. Google Ads Help: About audience segments in Audience manager
  7. Google Ads Help: Frequency capping definition