Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Search history and SEO: why your Google ranking looks different

Updated · 5 min read

Short answer Your own Google search is a poor ranking check. Google uses location, past searches and settings to pick results, and it can lift a page you visit often. So your site may look higher to you than to a customer across town. Use Search Console's average position, which averages real searches, and check local results from your customers' area.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Why Google rankings differ from person to person

There is no single "rank" for a search. Google builds each results page for the person and the moment. Its own explanation:

"we use information such as your location, past Search history, and Search settings to determine what is most relevant for you in the moment." (Google Search: How results are automatically generated)

What moves your result:

CauseWhat it doesCan you switch it off?
LocationA plumber 2 miles away can outrank one 15 miles away for "plumber near me"No, only change the searched place
Search historyPages you visit often can move up for youYes, in your settings
Settings, language, deviceChange which results and features showPartly
TimeNew pages and system updates reach Google's data centers at different timesNo

Google says time "may be one of the biggest reasons why results vary between people" (Google Search Help: Why your Google Search results differ). Not every result is personalized. Google says its systems "only personalize when doing so can provide more relevant and helpful information," and that results can also differ "for reasons other than personalization, such as location" (Google Blog, September 2022).

Does my search history make my own site look higher?

Often, yes. If you open your own website from Google every week, Google may treat it as a page you want:

"Our systems can recognize if you have visited the same page multiple times before and bring that page to the top of your Search results." (Google Search: How results are automatically generated)

That lift is for you only. That is why an owner can see the business in spot 2 while a new customer sees it in spot 8, or not at all. Google's "About this result" panel tells you whether your search history or other personal data played a part.

How to check your real Google ranking

Start with numbers from real customers' searches, not your own. Search Console, Google's free report on how your site does in Search, says so directly:

"For your specific search your position might be different than the average because of many variables, such as your search history, location, and so on." (Search Console Help: What are impressions, position, and clicks?)
MethodWhat you learnLimit
Search Console, Performance reportAverage position (your highest link, averaged over every search that showed you), per queryAn average, not what one person saw
Private window, signed outResults with your account history left outStill uses your location
A customer or friend in another part of townA real local viewOne person, one moment
A local rank grid toolYour map ranking checked from many points across an areaMostly paid; Local Falcon offers 100 free credits

For Google Maps and the local pack (the map with three businesses), location matters most. Google says local results "are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity" (Google Business Profile Help). A grid or a check from customers' neighborhoods tells you far more than a search from your desk. To raise those results, see how to rank higher on Google Maps.

Google Analytics won't help here. It shows what people do after they arrive; Google says Search Console "focuses on activity that happened before a person arrived at your website from Google Search" (Google Search Central).

Do clicks change rankings for everyone?

Only in bulk, and never from you alone. Google says it uses pooled behavior from many searchers:

"We also use aggregated and anonymized interaction data to assess whether search results are relevant to queries." (Google Search: How results are automatically generated)

Clicking your own listing again and again changes your personal results, not your customers'. Asking staff to do it won't help either. What helps is a listing and page people choose and find useful: a clear title, the service and city named, reviews, and a page that answers the question.

Yes. Signed in, turn off "Personalized Recommendations"; signed out, turn off Search customization (Google Search Help: Personalization & Google Search results). To compare once, use the "Try without" link at the bottom of a personalized results page. Google says it is updating these settings, so names may differ. Location, language and device still apply.

Bing works the same way. Microsoft says Bing uses "search history, location, language, device characteristics" to tailor results, and you can view and delete your Bing history or set your location in Bing Settings (Microsoft Support: How Bing delivers search results).

Example

Roofer checking from the office

A roofer searches "roof repair" from the shop and sees the business at spot 1. Search Console shows an average position of 9 for that query over the last 3 months. The 9 is closer to what customers see. The work is on the page and profile, not the report.

Dentist with two neighborhoods

A dentist ranks first in the map pack near the office and doesn't appear 6 miles north. A grid scan shows the drop starts about 3 miles out. That's distance, which no setting changes. A second location or stronger reviews and pages for that area are the real options.

Owner who clicks the site daily

An owner opens the website from Google every morning to check email links. It looks like the site ranks well for everything. A signed-out private window shows it on page 2 for the main service. The daily visits were lifting it for the owner alone.

FAQ

Does incognito mode show true Google rankings?

Closer, not true. A private window leaves out your account history, but Google still uses your location, so you see the results for where you are sitting.

Why does my business show up on my phone but not my customer's?

Usually distance and history. Your phone is near your business and has visited your site; your customer's isn't and hasn't.

What is a good average position in Search Console?

Lower is better: 1 is the top spot. Read it per query, not for the whole site, because a site-wide average mixes searches where you rank well with ones where you barely show.

Should I delete my search history to help SEO?

No. Your history only changes what you see. Deleting it gives you a cleaner view, not better rankings.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextAverage position rising in Search Console: what it meansYour Search Console average position number went up. Why that often isn't a ranking drop, how to tell what moved it, and when it is a real problem.

Do it yourself

Keyword research checklist: every step from seed to trackingA 15-step keyword research checklist for a small business: collect customer words, choose buyer searches, give each group one page, then track it free.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Google Search: How results are automatically generated (ranking results)
  2. Google Blog: Helping you find and control personalized results in Search (September 28, 2022)
  3. Google Search Help: Personalization & Google Search results
  4. Google Search Help: Why your Google Search results differ from others
  5. Search Console Help: What are impressions, position, and clicks?
  6. Google Search Central: Using Search Console and Google Analytics data for SEO
  7. Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google
  8. Microsoft Support: How Bing delivers search results
  9. Local Falcon: product page