Should one agency handle both SEO and PPC?
Usually, if you have one website, one budget and one person who decides. Search engine optimization: work that helps your pages show up higher in the unpaid results on Google and Bing. More (earning Google's free results) and PPC (pay-per-click ads, mostly Google Ads) chase the same searchers, land them on the same pages and spend the same money. The biggest decision is how to split that money, and only someone who sees both channels, and isn't paid more for one, can make it fairly.
| Option | Fits when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| One firm for both | One site, a few services, less than a full-time job of work | Thin skill in one channel; a fee that grows with ad spend |
| Two specialists | A large ad budget, a strict ad category (law, health, finance), or a big or complex site | Two reports claiming the same lead; nobody owns the budget split |
| AI tools or an AI agent | Steady routine work: pages, ad changes, reports | Mistakes and mass-made pages when nobody checks |
| You, with occasional help | Small budget, simple offer, an hour a week to spare | The weekly upkeep slips in busy months |
Who should do SEO alone (agency, freelancer or a hire): SEO agency vs freelancer vs in-house. Which channel to fund first: SEO vs Google Ads.
What one firm for both actually gets you
Shared data, if someone acts on it. A combined team can do four things two separate firms rarely do:
- Turn ad searches into pages. The ad account lists the searches that triggered your ads (how to read it). The ones that book jobs are the pages to write next.
- Build one page per service for both. A page with prices, area served and a call button converts ad clicks, and it's the page you want ranking too.
- Trim ads where you already rank. In Google's 2012 analysis of 390 tests where advertisers paused search ads, when the advertiser's free result ranked first, only half the ad clicks were extra; the rest would have come through the free listing anyway. At free positions 2 to 4, 82% were extra; below that, 96% (Google Research). The study is old, counts clicks rather than sales, and Google says results vary and recommends your own experiment. So test it: lower ads on one search where you rank first for a few weeks, and watch total calls.
- Count each lead once. One report, by source, through to booked jobs.
What it won't get you is better rankings from ads:
"Advertising with Google won't have any effect on your site's presence in our search results." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
Seeing paid and free results side by side in one Google report: SEO vs Google Ads.
The conflict to check first: how the fee is set
Ask how the firm is paid before anything else. If the ads fee is a percentage of your ad spend, the firm earns more when you buy more clicks, including clicks you'd get free. The trimming test above becomes a pay cut for it. A flat fee, or a written rule for when ad money moves to SEO, removes that pull.
Google's rules help you see the split. An agency that manages your Google Ads must disclose its fee in writing before you first buy and on every invoice, and report ad cost without it:
"When sharing Google advertising cost data with customers, report the exact amount charged by Google, exclusive of any fees that you charge." (Google Ads policy: Transparency requirements for third parties)
For a bundle quoted as one monthly number, ask for three lines: ad spend as Google charged it, ads management, and SEO. Fee models and the markup check: Google Ads management fees.
When to split SEO and PPC between two firms
Split when one channel needs more depth than one team has: ad spend big enough that a specialist pays for itself, an ad category with its own rulebook (lawyers, clinics, finance, housing), or a large or technical site such as an online store.
Splitting has costs you then manage:
- The same lead gets claimed twice. Google Ads credits a lead to an ad clicked within the conversion window, 30 days unless changed (Google Ads Help: About conversion windows). Someone who clicked an ad, came back through a free result and filled in your form can show up in both firms' reports. Fix it with one Google Analytics property in your name that both report from (key events setup).
- Nobody owns the split. Each firm argues for its own channel. You make the budget call, on cost per booked job.
- Overlaps. Agree in writing who edits which landing pages, and whether ads run on your business name.
Can AI replace an SEO and PPC agency?
Partly, and on the ads side Google's own AI already does much of it. Google Ads can set every bid by itself:
"Smart Bidding is a set of automated bidding strategies that use machine learning to optimise for conversions or conversion value." (Google Ads: Setting smarter search bids)
So the choice isn't person or machine at the bid level. It's who feeds the machine: tracking that counts booked jobs, not page views (tracking a lead to a booked job), the searches to block, the offer and the The page people reach after clicking an ad or link, built to get one action, such as a call or a booking. More. Some Smart Bidding strategies need a minimum volume of past conversions to do their best (Google Ads Help: About Smart Bidding).
On the SEO side, AI writes fast and Google allows it, with a limit:
"However, using generative AI tools or other similar tools to generate many pages without adding value for users may violate Google's spam policy on scaled content abuse." (Google Search Central: Guidance on using generative AI content)
The same page says to "manually factcheck and review all AI-generated content" before publishing. An offer of 50 AI-written town pages a month is a risk, not a bargain (city pages). More: AI agents for small business marketing.
Questions to ask an SEO and PPC agency
| Ask | Good answer | Walk away if |
|---|---|---|
| Who runs the ads, and who does SEO? | A named person or clear process for each | One generalist "does it all" on a large budget |
| How is your fee set? Does it rise with my ad budget? | Flat or capped; fee and ad spend on separate lines | An uncapped percentage, or one blended number |
| Where I rank first for free, will you test cutting ads? | Yes, with total calls before and after | "Ads and SEO always work better together" |
| How will you count leads? | Once each, by source, through to booked jobs | Ads and SEO reports that add up to more leads than you got |
| Whose name are the accounts in? | Yours: Google Ads, Search Console, Analytics, Business Profile, domain | Theirs |
| Can you guarantee page one? | No | Yes |
On the last row, Google says: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." And: "you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?). Clauses to get in writing: contract terms. The report to ask for: the monthly marketing report.
What it costs, and what return to expect
There is no standard price. Compare quotes on everything you pay (ad spend plus fees) divided by booked jobs. Price ranges: SEO, ads management, the whole budget.
Don't plan around the "$2 for every $1" Google figure you may see quoted. It is an assumption in Google's economic impact model: that businesses average $2 in profit per $1 spent on Google Ads, drawn from a 2009 paper by its first chief economist (Google Economic Impact: Methodology). It sizes the total across all advertisers; it isn't a forecast for yours.
Example
Illustrative cases, not real businesses.
An electrician spending USD 3,000 a month
One firm, a flat USD 900 fee, USD 2,100 in ads. By month five the site ranks first for "electrician" plus his town. The firm cuts ads on those searches for four weeks; total calls hold, so USD 500 a month moves to ads in the next town and two new service pages.
A personal injury firm spending USD 40,000 a month on ads
It hires an ads specialist and a separate SEO firm. The law firm owns the Analytics property; both agencies report from it, one row per source, ending in signed cases. The managing partner, not either agency, sets the split each quarter.
An Ontario cleaning company with CAD 800 a month
Too small for two firms. The owner runs one search campaign herself, checks its search terms each Monday, and drafts service pages with an AI tool, editing each before it goes live. She turns down an offer of 60 AI-written suburb pages.
FAQ
Do Google Ads help SEO?
Not directly. Google says advertising has no effect on your free results. But ad data shows which searches book jobs: the pages to write next.
Is it cheaper to hire one agency for both SEO and PPC?
Sometimes. A bundle may cost less, and one firm can test cutting ads where you rank first. Compare total cost per booked job, not fees.
How long until an SEO and PPC agency shows results?
Ads can run within days: Google reviews most ads within one business day. SEO: Google says some changes take effect in hours, others several months.
Different for you?
- Choosing which channel to fund first: SEO vs Google Ads
- Hiring for SEO only: hiring an SEO company
- Paying for ads that bring no calls: Google Ads not getting calls
- Leaving a firm that holds both accounts: leaving your marketing agency
- Law firm: Google Ads for lawyers and law firm SEO
- Want both run and judged on booked jobs: Paid Ads Agent or SEO & GEO Agent