Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

SEO angel investing: earn equity with your SEO skills

Updated · 6 min read

Short answer SEO angel investing means doing a client's SEO for a share of the business instead of, or on top of, a fee. It pays only if the business grows and you can later sell or draw profits. Half of new US business locations close within five years, so treat each stake as a bet, keep some cash, and plan for tax.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

What is SEO angel investing?

You do a business's SEO and get paid, fully or partly, in ownership: shares in a corporation or a stake in an LLC or partnership. An angel investor puts in money; you put in work. The stake is worth something only when the business is sold, pays out profits, or raises money at a higher price.

Before you say yes, run three checks:

  • Can it ever pay out? A local plumber with no plan to sell may never turn your 3% into cash, unless the deal also gives you a share of profits.
  • Can you go without the fee? Every month you work for equity is a retainer you didn't bill. Keep a cash part if you need it.
  • Will tax hit before cash does? In the US and Canada, getting paid in shares can count as income now, even though you can't spend it (see below).

Is equity worth more than a retainer?

Only if you'd still say yes after pricing in failure. Of US business locations that opened in March 2015, 79.6% were still open a year later, 50.2% after five years and 34.6% after ten (US Bureau of Labor Statistics: Survival of private sector establishments). And surviving isn't the same as being worth selling.

A rough test: what you give up in fees, against your stake times a realistic sale price times the chance that sale happens.

RetainerEquity onlyMixed
Cash nowFull feeNonePart fee
Upside if the business sellsNoneYour % of the saleSmaller % of the sale
If the business closesYou were paidYou get nothingYou kept the cash part
Tax timingWhen paidOften when shares vest (US) or are received (Canada)Both

Most SEO pros who try this keep the mixed column: a lower fee plus a stake. If you'd rather tie pay to results without owning anything, look at pay per lead SEO or a revenue share in the contract.

Which businesses are worth a stake?

Ones where your work can move sales and the stake can turn into cash:

  • Search brings buyers. People already search for what they sell, and more search traffic shows up as calls, bookings or orders.
  • A path to cash. A plan to sell, raise money, or pay out profits.
  • Open books. The owner shows sales, margins and debts before you sign.

What terms go in an equity-for-SEO deal?

Write down what you deliver, what you get and when you earn it. A handshake over "5% for SEO" is how both sides end up angry.

TermWhat to settle
Stake and typeShares or LLC units, and what percent of the business today
VestingYou earn the stake over time (for example, monthly over two years) so neither side is stuck if it ends early
MilestonesOutcomes you can measure in Search Console and the owner's sales records: leads from search, calls, booked jobs
Cash partAny monthly fee, and who pays for tools and content
DilutionWhat happens to your % when new investors come in
InformationYour right to see monthly sales and the books, not just traffic
ExitWhat you get if you stop work, are let go, or the business sells
Ownership of workWho owns the site, content and accounts if you part ways

Pick milestones that show up in money, not rankings. See what to check each month for numbers an owner trusts. The standard service terms still apply too: marketing agency contract terms.

How is equity for services taxed?

US. Property you get for services is income. The tax code taxes its value, minus anything you paid, once it's yours to keep or sell (26 U.S.C. § 83). The IRS puts it plainly:

"In most cases, if you receive property for your services, you must include its FMV in your income in the year you receive the property." (IRS Publication 525)

FMV is fair market value: what the stake would sell for today. If the stake vests over time, you're taxed as each piece vests, at its value then. You can instead elect to be taxed on the full value when you receive it, often when it's worth little. That's the 83(b) election, and the deadline is strict:

"An 83(b) election must be filed no later than 30 days after the date the property was transferred." (IRS Form 15620)

If the business is an LLC or partnership taxed as one, a share of future profits only (a profits interest) is treated differently: receiving it for services is "not a taxable event for the partner or the partnership," with exceptions, such as selling it within two years (IRS Publication 541).

Canada. The Canada Revenue Agency treats a trade of services for something of value as a barter. If you're in business and exchange your services, "you have to include the value of the goods or services you exchanged in your income" (Canada Revenue Agency: Sources of income). Barter can also carry GST/HST.

This is how the rules read, not tax advice. Have an accountant price the stake before you sign.

Can a business legally give you shares for SEO work?

Yes, but it's a securities transaction, and the business needs an exemption from registration.

US. Rule 701 lets private companies issue shares as pay to "employees, consultants and advisors" (SEC: Rule 701). A consultant must be a natural person providing real services (17 CFR 230.701), so a grant to your agency's company may need a different route. The shares are "restricted securities" and may not be freely traded (SEC: Rule 701). Plan on holding them until a sale of the business.

Canada. National Instrument 45-106 exempts shares issued to a consultant if "participation in the distribution is voluntary." A consultant there works under a written contract and spends a significant amount of time on the business (NI 45-106, sections 2.22 and 2.24).

Example

A US agency and a two-location HVAC company

The owner offers 4% for a year of SEO instead of a $3,000 monthly retainer. The agency would give up $36,000. If the company might sell for $2 million in five years, 4% is $80,000, but only if it sells. The agency takes $1,500 a month plus 2%, vesting monthly, and files an 83(b) election within 30 days.

A Canadian freelancer and a software startup

A Vancouver freelancer gets shares worth CA$10,000 for six months of SEO, with no cash. Under CRA's barter rule, CA$10,000 is income this year. She asks for CA$3,000 in cash to cover the tax.

An SEO consultant and a family landscaping business

The owner offers 10% but has no plan to sell. The consultant asks for 5% of yearly profit above a set base instead, paid each quarter.

FAQ

How much equity should I ask for?

There's no fixed rate. Start from the fees you're giving up, divide by a realistic value of the business, then add a margin for the chance it never pays out.

Do I still need a contract if I own part of the business?

Yes. The ownership papers say what you own; the service contract says what you do, how it's measured and what happens if you stop.

What if the business fails?

Your stake is worth nothing and the work is unpaid. Ask an accountant whether you can claim the loss.

Can I do this with many clients at once?

Yes, and spreading small stakes lowers the damage of one failure. But each stake is real work; cap how many you hold so the clients paying cash still get your time.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextSEO angel investor: what founders should know before a dealAn SEO angel investor does your SEO for a share of your company. What they look for, how to attract one, and the legal points to settle before you sign.

Do it yourself

SEO onboarding checklist: what to hand over at kickoffWhat a new SEO client should share in week one: business facts, the right access level for each account, and the expectations to agree in writing.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. US Bureau of Labor Statistics: Survival of private sector establishments by opening year
  2. 26 U.S. Code § 83: Property transferred in connection with performance of services
  3. IRS Publication 525: Taxable and Nontaxable Income
  4. IRS Form 15620: Section 83(b) Election
  5. IRS Publication 541: Partnerships
  6. SEC: Employee benefit plans (Rule 701)
  7. eCFR: 17 CFR 230.701
  8. Canada Revenue Agency: Sources of income (barter transactions)
  9. National Instrument 45-106 Prospectus Exemptions (BC consolidation)