SEO KPIs by category: revenue, reach, authority and local
Short answer Group SEO KPIs by the question they answer. Revenue: leads, customers, cost per customer and ROI, from your own records and GA4. Reach: non-branded clicks and impressions, from Search Console. Authority: sites linking to you, from Search Console's Links report. Local: calls and direction requests, from your Business Profile. Judge SEO by revenue; use the rest to find the cause.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callSEO KPIs by category: one goal, one tool
A KPI (key performance indicator) is a number you agree to judge the work by. Sort them by the question they answer, and each category maps to one main tool.
| Category | Question it answers | KPIs | Main tool (free) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | Is SEO paying for itself? | Leads, customers, cost per customer, customer value, ROI | Your job list or CRM, plus Google Analytics 4 (GA4) |
| Reach | Are new people finding you? | Non-branded clicks, impressions, click-through rate, average position | Google Search Console |
| Authority | Do other sites vouch for you? | Linking sites, new and lost links, links to your money pages | Search Console Links report |
| Local | Does your Maps listing get used? | Calls, direction requests, website clicks, bookings, search terms | Google Business Profile, Performance |
Read the table top down. Revenue is the verdict. The other three explain it: if revenue falls, reach, authority and local tell you where.
Pick one or two KPIs per category. A plumber needs all four. An online shop with no storefront skips local. More numbers than you will act on is just noise.
Revenue KPIs: is SEO paying?
These come mostly from your own records, because no Google tool knows which caller became a customer or what the job was worth.
| KPI | How to work it out | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Leads from search | Calls, forms and bookings that started on Google Search or Maps | GA4 key events for the Organic Search channel; "How did you hear about us?" on every first call |
| Customers from search | Leads that became paying jobs | Your job list or CRM (customer relationship management software) |
| Cost per customer (CPA) | Monthly SEO cost ÷ new customers from search | Your invoices and job list |
| Customer value (CLV) | Average job value × jobs per year × years a customer stays | Your job history |
| ROI | (Gross profit from search customers − SEO cost) ÷ SEO cost | All of the above |
CPA (cost per acquisition) and CLV (customer lifetime value) belong together. A $400 cost per customer is too much for a one-time $300 repair and cheap for a dental patient who returns twice a year for eight years. Use gross profit, not revenue, when you compare.
Phone calls and bookings need tracking set up before GA4 can count them: GA4 key events for a small business. The full monthly ROI routine is in Is my SEO working?.
Reach KPIs: are new people finding you?
Search Console is Google's free report on how your site does in Google Search. Google draws the line between it and GA4:
"The source of truth for Search performance will always be Search Console" (Google Search Central: Using Search Console and Google Analytics data for SEO)
| KPI | What it means | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Non-branded clicks | Clicks from searches that don't use your business name | The best single reach number |
| Impressions | Times your site showed in results, AI Overviews and AI Mode included (Google Search Central: AI features and your website) | Up with flat clicks: seen but not chosen |
| Click-through rate (CTR) | Clicks ÷ impressions | Compare a page with its own past |
| Average position | Your average spot in results | A hint, never the goal |
Non-branded clicks matter most because people who type your name already know you. Google says non-branded queries "show how new users find your content without any initial intent to go to your site." Search Console's branded filter splits the two automatically, but "only for sites with a sufficient volume of queries and impressions" (Google Search Central Blog, 2025). Smaller sites can exclude their name with a query filter: Search Console for a small business.
For AI answers, Search Console's generative AI reports show how often your pages "appeared in generative AI features in Search and Discover", such as AI Overviews and AI Mode. By August 31, 2026, Google had rolled them out to all sites worldwide. They count impressions only (Google Search Central Blog, 2026).
On position, Google is blunt:
"In general, you shouldn't focus too much on your absolute position." (Google Search Central: Debugging drops in Google Search traffic)
Authority KPIs: do other sites vouch for you?
Links from other websites still count. Google says it "uses links as a signal when determining the relevancy of pages and to find new pages to crawl" (Google Search Central: Link best practices). For a small business, three numbers are enough, checked every few months, not weekly.
| KPI | What to look at | Tool |
|---|---|---|
| Linking sites | How many different websites link to you, not total links: 50 links from one directory are still one site | Search Console → Links → Top linking sites |
| New and lost links | Did a supplier, chamber of commerce or local paper link to you, or drop the link? | Ahrefs Free (formerly Ahrefs Webmaster Tools) or a paid backlink tool |
| Links to money pages | Do links point at the pages that sell, such as a service page, or only the home page? | Search Console → Links → Top linked pages |
Search Console's numbers are Google's own, but partial. Its Help page says the report "isn't a comprehensive list of every link on your site" and that tables stop at 1,000 rows. It also keeps links that have since been removed. Ahrefs Free is free for sites you verify and shows who links to you, so you can compare month to month; paid suites add competitor data.
Skip authority scores as a KPI. Domain Authority is Moz's own 1-to-100 score, and Moz says it "is not a Google ranking factor". Google adds:
"Third-party tools don't have access to our internal ranking data." (Google Search Central: Guidance on using third-party SEO tools)
A score is fine for comparing yourself with a competitor in the same tool. It isn't a result to pay for. How to earn links safely: backlinks for a local business.
Local KPIs: does your Maps listing get used?
For a business that serves an area, the Business Profile (your listing on Google Search and Maps) is often where a search turns into a call. Open it and choose Performance. Google's Business Profile documentation defines what each number counts:
| KPI | What Google counts | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Calls | Times "the business profile call button was clicked" | Closest to a lead; taps, not answered calls |
| Direction requests | Times someone asked for directions to you | Strong for shops, clinics, restaurants |
| Website clicks | Clicks from the profile to your site | Hands off to your revenue KPIs |
| Bookings | Bookings made through Reserve with Google | Only if you use a booking partner |
| Profile views | Views on Search and Maps, phone and computer; one person's repeat views in a day count once | Reach for your listing |
| Search terms | Words people used to find you, by month; small counts show only as "below" a threshold | Shows if you appear for the service, not just your name |
Check calls against your phone log. A tap that never connected, or a caller who hung up, still counts as a call here. If calls fall while views hold, look at hours, photos and reviews. If views fall, see how to rank higher on Google Maps.
Supporting numbers: engagement and site health
These don't measure results. They help find the cause when a result drops.
- Engagement rate (GA4). The share of visits that lasted over 10 seconds, had a key event, or viewed 2 or more pages. Bounce rate is simply its opposite (Analytics Help). A visitor who finds your number in 5 seconds and calls counts as a bounce unless the call tap is a key event, so don't chase bounce rate on a contact page.
- Core Web Vitals (Search Console). Google's targets: main content shown within 2.5 seconds (LCP), a response to taps under 200 milliseconds (INP), layout shift under 0.1 (CLS). Treat it as pass or fail: Core Web Vitals.
Which category matters most for you?
| Your business | Lead with | Can mostly skip |
|---|---|---|
| Local service (trades, clinics, law, salons) | Revenue, local | Authority scores |
| Online shop, no storefront | Revenue (GA4 purchases), reach | Local |
| Long sales cycle (custom builds, B2B services) | Leads, reach | Monthly revenue swings; judge by quarter |
| New site, first 6 months | Reach, indexing | ROI; too early to judge |
Compare every KPI with the same month last year. Search Console keeps 16 months, and Google suggests its "Compare last 3 months year over year" view so a seasonal dip isn't mistaken for failure (Google Search Central: Debugging drops).
Example
Illustrative cases with invented round numbers.
An electrician in Phoenix (US dollars)
SEO costs $1,200 a month. In March, 6 new customers said they found him on Google: CPA $200. Average customer spends $600 a year and stays 3 years: CLV $1,800, about $720 gross profit at 40% margin. Each customer returns more than three times the cost. Reach and authority barely moved that month; revenue is what counts.
A physiotherapy clinic in Calgary (Canadian dollars)
Search Console shows non-branded clicks up 30%, but Business Profile calls fell from 120 to 80. Views held steady. The profile showed old weekend hours, so callers saw "closed". Fixing the hours is a local problem, not a reach one, and no content work would have found it.
An online furniture shop
No Business Profile, so no local KPIs. Its agency reports Domain Authority up 8 points. Search Console's Links report shows the new links all come from 2 sites, and GA4 organic purchases are flat at C$9,000 a month. Authority score up, revenue flat: not working yet.
FAQ
What's the difference between an SEO metric and an SEO KPI?
A metric is any number a tool reports. A KPI is one you chose to judge results by, usually because it leads to money. Impressions are a metric; customers from search is a KPI.
Which SEO KPI matters most?
Customers from search, compared with what SEO costs. Everything else explains why that number moved.
Do I need paid SEO tools to track these?
No. Search Console, GA4, your Business Profile and your own records cover all four categories. Paid tools add competitor and backlink detail, not Google's own numbers.
Is Domain Authority a good SEO KPI?
No. Moz, which makes it, says it isn't a Google ranking factor. Use it only to compare sites inside the same tool.
How often should I check SEO KPIs?
Revenue, reach and local monthly. Authority every few months. Decide on changes by quarter, since single months swing.
Different for you?
- You want four numbers and a monthly ROI routine: Is my SEO working?.
- Calls and forms aren't tracked yet: GA4 key events.
- Your agency's report is all rankings and scores: the report to ask for.
- Your site is new and has little data: how long SEO takes.
- You want the SEO done and reported for you: SEO & GEO Agent.
- Search brings leads but too few book: Conversion Agent.