SERP overlap: decide if keywords belong on one page
Short answer Search both phrases from your service area and count the pages that appear in both top 10s. Five or more shared pages (over 40%) usually means Google treats them as one need: cover both on one page. Zero to two means separate pages. Three or four is a judgment call. It's a tool makers' rule of thumb, not Google's.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow do I check SERP overlap?
SERP overlap is how many of the same pages Google shows for two different searches (SERP means search engine results page). It's the fastest way to see whether Google thinks two phrases are one customer need or two. You can do it by hand in about ten minutes:
- Search the first phrase in a private browser window, from your service area (on your phone at work is fine).
- Write down the top 10 regular results: the page addresses, not just the site names. Skip ads, the map pack and the AI Overview.
- Search the second phrase the same way and list its top 10.
- Count the pages that appear on both lists. Same address, same page.
- Read the count with the table below, then check intent (step 6).
- Look at what kind of pages rank. If one search shows service pages from local businesses and the other shows how-to articles, they're different needs, whatever the count says.
| Shared pages in the top 10 | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| 5 or more | Google treats both as the same need | One page targets both |
| 3–4 | Unclear | Decide by intent: same job and same buyer means one page |
| 0–2 | Different needs | Separate pages |
These cut-offs come from tool makers, not Google. thruuu's documentation calls "more than a 40% similarity between two keywords" the point where it's "advisable to create a single article" (thruuu: SERP Similarity Tool). Keyword Insights says many shared addresses point to one page and few point to separate pages, without giving a number (Keyword Insights: SERP Similarity tool). Treat the count as a strong hint, then use judgment: a page shared at #1 tells you more than one shared at #10.
Why does this work?
Google ranks pages by what the searcher wants, not by the exact words typed. Google says it first needs to establish "the intent behind your query," and that its synonym system finds relevant pages "even if they don't contain the exact words you used" (Google: How Search works, ranking results). So when two phrases bring up the same pages, Google has decided the same answer serves both. A page built for one will likely rank for the other.
Google's own guide says you don't need every wording on the page:
"Google's language matching systems are sophisticated and can understand how your page relates to many queries." (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide)
Count pages, not websites
The most common mistake is counting sites. For local services, the same big directories and review sites often rank for nearly every search in a trade. Yelp showing up for both "plumber" and "sewer line replacement" says little. Two different Yelp pages are two different results. Count only when the full address matches.
Your own site counts too. If your page already ranks for both searches, that's a sign they belong together. If two of your pages each rank for one, that's the overlap problem to fix (below). Google also generally limits how often one site appears:
"we generally won't show more than two web page listings from the same site in our top results" (Google Search Central: A guide to Google Search ranking systems)
So two of your pages chasing the same search don't double your chances. They split it.
Why do my results look different from a tool's?
Results change with location. Google's own example: someone searching "football" in Chicago "will likely see results about American football and the Chicago Bears," and a search for "pizza" brings up nearby businesses (Google: How Search works, ranking results). Overlap tools usually pull results for a country and language you pick, not your exact spot in town. For a local service business, your own search from your service area is closer to what customers see. Results also shift over time, so recheck before a big rebuild.
Overlap is high: merge, or add a section?
- Same job, different words ("AC repair" and "air conditioner repair"): one page. Use both wordings naturally in headings and text.
- Same job, one more question ("AC repair" and "AC repair cost"): one page with a section that answers the extra question.
- You already have two pages for it: keep the stronger one, move anything useful from the weaker one into it, and send the weaker address to the stronger one with a permanent redirect (a 301, which tells browsers and Google the page has moved for good).
Google's guide says two pages with the same information "can be a confusing user experience" and suggests a redirect "to a URL that best represents that information" (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide). A permanent redirect makes Google "show the new redirect target in search results" (Google Search Central: Redirects and Google Search). Duplicates aren't a penalty: Google says duplicate content "is not a violation of our spam policies" (same Starter Guide). The cost is two weak pages instead of one strong one.
For deciding which old pages to merge, update or delete, see content decay: update, merge or delete.
Overlap is low: build a separate page
Low overlap with a different kind of result means a different customer. "Roof repair" and "roof replacement" usually bring up different pages because the job, price and decision differ. Give each its own page with its own title and main heading. What each service page needs is in on-page SEO for service pages.
How do I find overlap on my own site?
Use Search Console, Google's free tool for site owners. Its Performance report breaks traffic down "by queries, pages, and countries" (Google Search Central: Get started with Search Console). Click a search phrase, then the Pages tab. If two of your pages both get impressions (times shown) for the same phrase, run the overlap check on what each page is meant to rank for. If the results overlap, merge them. If they don't, make each page clearly about its own job. A walk-through of the reports is in Google Search Console for a small business.
Free SERP overlap tools and their limits
| Option | What you get free | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| By hand (above) | Any two searches, from your real location | About ten minutes per pair |
| Keyword Insights SERP Similarity | Compares 2 keywords per check | Up to 6 keywords on a paid plan; set by country and language (Keyword Insights: SERP Similarity tool) |
| thruuu SERP Similarity Tool | 10 credits on a free account | Comparing two results pages costs 2 credits (thruuu: SERP Similarity Tool) |
A business with a handful of services rarely needs a paid tool for this. Tools pay off when you're sorting hundreds of keywords at once. Finding the keywords in the first place is covered in keyword research for a local business.
Example
A plumber with two pages
A plumber has "Water heater repair" and "Hot water heater repair" pages, each with about 500 words. Searching both phrases from town shows 7 of the same 10 pages. Overlap is high. The plumber merges them into one stronger page and redirects the weaker address to it.
A dentist deciding on a new page
A dentist ranks for "teeth whitening" and wonders about a separate "whitening strips" page. The two searches share 1 page in 10. "Whitening strips" brings up stores selling strips, not dental offices. Different buyer: the dentist skips that page rather than chase shoppers who want a box from the store.
An accountant at three
An accountant compares "bookkeeping services" and "monthly bookkeeping." 3 shared pages. Both show local firms' service pages, and the buyer wants the same thing. One page, with a section on monthly plans.
FAQ
What is a good SERP overlap percentage?
Tool makers commonly treat more than 40% (5 or more of the top 10) as one page, and 0–2 shared as separate pages. Google publishes no number.
Should I count the map pack and AI Overview?
No. Count the regular web results. The map pack lists Business Profiles, not web pages; what moves it is in how to rank higher on Google Maps.
Does SERP overlap work for Bing?
Yes. The method works on any search engine: compare its results for both phrases. The two engines can disagree, so check the one your customers use.
How often should I recheck?
Before building or merging pages, and when a page's traffic drops. Results shift, so a check from a year ago may be out of date.
Different for you?
- You have lots of old blog posts covering similar topics: sort them with update, merge or delete.
- You serve several cities: overlap between city searches doesn't make thin city pages safe. See city pages for service areas.
- You don't have a keyword list yet: start with keyword research for a local business.
- You want someone to sort and fix your pages: see SEO.