Content discoverability: hub pages, a search box or filters?
Content discoverability is how easily a visitor finds the page they need once they're on your site. Three tools do that job, and most small sites need only the first.
| Tool | What it is | Fits | Skip it when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hub page | One page per service or topic: a short overview and a link to every page on it | Any site with more than one page on a topic | Never: even a 15-page site has groups |
| Site search box | A box that searches only your own pages | Large blogs and resource libraries, stores, listing sites | You have a few dozen pages; the menu and hubs are faster |
| Filters | Checkboxes or dropdowns that narrow a long list by price, size, date or place | Products, property listings, event calendars, staff or location finders | The whole list fits on one or two phone screens |
Three things change the answer:
- How many pages you have. Jakob Nielsen's rule of thumb from 1997: "sites with more than about 200 pages should offer search" (Nielsen Norman Group: Search and You May Find). Old, but a plumber with 30 pages still doesn't need one.
- Why people come. Someone booking one service wants a short path. Shoppers and readers of a big article library browse.
- Accessibility. WCAG, the main web accessibility standard, asks for two routes to each page at Level AA:
"More than one way is available to locate a web page within a set of web pages except where the web page is the result of, or a step in, a process." (W3C: WCAG 2.2, Success Criterion 2.4.5)
W3C counts a search function, a site map, a table of contents and links to related pages among those ways (W3C: Understanding Multiple Ways). Hubs with related links plus a site map page can meet it without a search box. Who must meet WCAG: ADA website compliance.
What is a content hub page?
A hub page (also called a topic or category page) sums up one subject in a few sentences and links to every page you have on it. Each of those pages links back. A plumber's "Water heaters" hub links to repair, replacement, tankless, cost and maintenance-plan pages.
Hubs help two readers. Visitors who land deep in your site see the rest of the topic without digging through the menu. And Google finds pages by following links: "the vast majority of the new pages Google finds every day are through links" (Google Search Central: Search engine optimization: work that helps your pages show up higher in the unpaid results on Google and Bing. More Starter Guide).
How to build one:
- List every page on your site. Group pages by what customers ask for (a service, a problem, a type of customer), not by your internal departments.
- Make one hub per group, named in customers' words: "Water heaters", not "Thermal solutions".
- On the hub, write two or three sentences, then link each page with one line on what it answers.
- On each page, link back to the hub (a breadcrumb line such as Home > Water heaters > Tankless does it) and to two or three related pages.
- Put the hubs in your main menu and link them from the home page.
Don't move pages into new folders for this. Google says "search engines will likely understand your pages as they are right now, regardless of how your site is organized," and folders matter for crawling mainly past "a few thousand URLs" (SEO Starter Guide). New web addresses carry risk: traffic drops after a redesign.
Will Google find pages that only your search box shows?
No. Google follows links; it doesn't type into your search box:
"Googlebot generally doesn't try to submit searches into a search box as part of crawling a site." (Google Search Central: Ecommerce website navigation structure)
Link every page you want on Google from a hub, category page or menu, with a standard HTML link to a web address, not a button that runs a script (Google Search Central: Link best practices). Pages you can't link go in an XML sitemap file (Google Search Central: Ecommerce website navigation structure).
The reverse matters too. Your search results and filtered lists shouldn't eat up Google's crawl:
"Typically, consider blocking dynamic URLs, such as URLs that generate search results, or URLs that can create infinite spaces, such as calendars, and ordering and filtering functions." (Google Search Central: URL structure best practices)
You block them in robots.txt, a text file at yoursite.com/robots.txt that tells crawlers which addresses to skip.
Does a small business website need a search bar?
Only when browsing gets slow. You likely need one if:
- You have more than about 200 pages, or a growing blog or resource library.
- Visitors come back to look things up: articles, forms, price lists.
- You list many products, properties, classes or events.
If none fits, spend the effort on hubs. If one does, follow the usability research:
| Do this | Source |
|---|---|
| Put search at the top of every page | Nielsen Norman Group, 1997: "Search should be easily available from every single page on the site." |
| On the home page, show a box to type in, not only an icon or link | Nielsen Norman Group, 2001: "On homepages, search should be a type-in field and not a link." |
| Make the box about 27 characters wide | Nielsen Norman Group: Top 10 Guidelines for Homepage Usability, updated guideline |
| Say plainly when nothing matched, and offer next steps | Nielsen Norman Group, 2014: "Clearly explain that there are no matching results." |
| Fix results for your most common searches by hand, and add synonyms | Nielsen Norman Group, 2016: 7 Ways to Improve Your Website's Built-In Search Engine |
These guidelines are 10 to 29 years old; check them against what your visitors type (below).
How to add site search on WordPress, Squarespace, Wix or Shopify
All four have a built-in option, per their help pages as of November 2026:
| Platform | How | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| WordPress | Add the Search block (type /search in the editor) | Its "Button only" setting hides the box |
| Squarespace | A search block, or the built-in page at yoursite.com/search | On version 7.1 and some 7.0 templates you can't add a search field above page content, so link to /search from the menu. Noindex and Not linked pages still show in site search unless password-protected |
| Wix | Add the Wix Site Search app | Searches pages, products, bookings, events and blog posts; not images, galleries, embedded iframes, private member pages or pages hidden from search engines |
| Shopify | Storefront search, with predictive search, is on by default | Filters live in the Search & Discovery app. Your theme must support them; a store gets up to 25, and collections over 5,000 products show none |
When do filters help, and how do they affect Google?
Filters help when a list is too long to scan. Nielsen Norman Group describes them as tools that "analyze a given set of content to exclude items that don't meet certain criteria." Many filters working together are called faceted navigation, which is "more difficult to create and maintain," so first "make sure that users truly do need faceted navigation" (Nielsen Norman Group: Filters vs. Facets, 2014).
- Filter by what customers decide on: price range, size, date, location. Not your internal codes.
- Never leave a dead end. If a combination has no results, say so and offer to clear filters.
- Keep filtered lists out of Google's crawl. Each combination can create a new web address, which Google says "can generate infinite URL spaces." Its fixes: block those addresses in robots.txt, or put filters after a # in the address, which Google "generally doesn't support" in crawling (Google Crawling Infrastructure: Managing crawling of faceted navigation URLs).
- Keep one unfiltered list open. Google suggests allowing "just the individual items' pages along with a dedicated listing page that shows all products without filters applied."
If people search Google for a filtered view, such as "leather sofas," give it a real category page linked from a hub.
How do I see what visitors search for on my site?
Google Analytics 4 (GA4) records it when the search word appears in your results page's web address. Google's example: a visit to /some-page.html?q=some-term gives the Search term "some-term" (Google Analytics Data API). The site search setting in enhanced measurement (GA4's automatic tracking) records a search "based on a query parameter," the part of the address after the ? (Google Analytics Admin API).
- Search your site for "test" and look at the address bar. The word just before =test (often q or s) is your query parameter.
- In GA4, open your web data stream's enhanced measurement settings. Check that site search is on and lists that word.
- If the address doesn't change when you search, GA4 can't read the term on its own; that needs custom tracking.
- Monthly, in Explore, build a free-form table with the Search term dimension and event count.
On Squarespace, the Site search queries panel in its analytics shows the same list (Squarespace Help).
What to do with the list, adapted from Nielsen Norman Group's guide to search logs (2017):
| You see | Do |
|---|---|
| The same search every week | Put that page in the menu or near the top of its hub |
| A search your site can't answer | NN/g's label: "What people want but does not exist". Write the page, or add the word as a synonym |
| Customers' words that differ from yours ("AC" vs "cooling") | Use their words in headings, links and hub names |
GA4 shows what people typed, not whether anything matched, so run your top 10 searches yourself. Then ask two or three customers to find a page while you watch, without helping; where they stall, fix the label or link.
For hubs, watch engagement. GA4 counts a session as engaged when it "lasted longer than 10 seconds, or had a key event, or had 2 or more screen views"; bounce rate is the share that wasn't (Google Analytics Data API). Calls and bookings matter more: GA4 key events.
Example
A plumber with 30 pages
No search box. Five hubs (water heaters, drains, leak repair, remodeling, maintenance plans), each linking four to six pages, and each page links back. A site map page lists all 30. Every page now has two routes, which is what WCAG 2.4.5 asks for.
A family law firm with 300 articles
The firm adds a search box at the top of every page. After a month, GA4 shows "custody" searched 60 times, while the firm's pages say "parenting time." It adds "custody" to its headings and hub name, and writes a page on a question searched 20 times that no article answered.
A furniture store with 800 products
The Shopify store adds price, size and color filters to each collection; its price ranges run from $500 to $3,000 CAD. Its robots.txt blocks the filtered addresses, while the plain collection pages, which link every product, stay open to Google. Leather sofas, searched often on Google, get their own collection page.
FAQ
Is content discoverability the same as SEO?
No. SEO gets people to your site from Google or AI answers; discoverability gets them to the right page once there. Hub pages help both.
Do I need sitelinks search box markup?
No. Google began removing that search box from results worldwide on November 21, 2024. Leftover markup "won't cause issues in Search" (Google Search Central Blog).
How many links should a hub page have?
One to every page on the topic. Past about a dozen, group them under subheadings so the page stays easy to scan on a phone.
Different for you?
- You sell products online: Ecommerce SEO.
- Deciding whether to publish articles at all: Do blogs help SEO?
- Pages you want on Google show as not indexed: Crawled or discovered, currently not indexed.
- One page per city you serve: City pages for service areas.
- Visitors find the page but don't call or book: Website not getting leads.
- Accessibility rules in the US and Ontario: ADA website compliance.
- You want hubs, search and tracking built for you: Website Agent.