Website navigation best practices: the short list
Navigation is every link that moves people around your site: the top menu, its dropdowns, the footer and links inside pages. The top menu does most of the work.
| Practice | What it looks like | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Menu in plain view on a computer | Every top item shows on a laptop | Desktop users were at least 39% slower with the menu hidden (Nielsen Norman Group, 2016) |
| Your customers' words | "Drain cleaning", not "Flow solutions" | No "made-up words, internal jargon, or abstract high-level categorization" (Nielsen Norman Group, 2024) |
| Same menu, same order, every page | Items never swap places | Keeping the order is a Level AA rule of WCAG, the web accessibility standard (W3C) |
| Show where they are | The current page's item is highlighted | NN/g calls skipping this "probably the single most common mistake" on menus |
| Logo top left, linked home | Click the logo, land on the home page | With a centered logo, people were 6 times as likely to fail to get home in one click (NN/g, 2016) |
| Dropdowns open on click, one level deep | "Services" opens a panel; no menu inside a menu | Works the same with a mouse, a finger or a keyboard (NN/g, 2024) |
| Call or Book in one fixed spot | A button at the top right of every page | WCAG 2.2 asks for contact options in the same place on each page (W3C) |
| Real links | Each item is a plain link to its own page | That's what Google can crawl (Google Search Central) |
What should go in my website menu?
The pages a customer uses to choose you. For most service businesses:
- Services, or your main service by name if you offer one.
- Pricing, if you publish prices or ranges.
- Reviews or Our work: proof from real jobs.
- Service area if you travel to customers, Locations if they come to you.
- About: who you are, licenses, team.
- Contact, plus a separate Call or Book button.
Put them in the header, Services first and Contact last. NN/g's checklist says users expect "specific menus in specific areas of the screen": the main menu in the header, extras such as job listings in the footer, the strip of links at the bottom of each page. Move blog, careers, FAQ and privacy policy there.
How many items should a website menu have?
No number is proven. The "magical number seven" rule comes from George Miller's 1956 research on short-term memory. A menu stays on screen, so people recognize options instead of recalling them.
"So there are no usability gains to be made by limiting the number of menu items to seven." (Nielsen Norman Group: How Chunking Helps Content Processing, 2016)
What does matter: every top item, plus the button, fits on one line on a laptop, and each item is clearly different. If a customer can't tell "Services" from "Solutions", drop one.
How to word menu labels
Use the words customers use, not your trade's. Find them in the queries people type to find you (Google Search Console lists them), in what callers ask for, and in your reviews.
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| Solutions | The service itself: "AC repair" |
| Resources | What's there: "Price list", "FAQ" |
| Investment | Pricing |
| Get started | What happens next: "Book a visit" |
| Hydro-jetting | Drain cleaning |
- Label matches the page. Use the words of the heading the link opens. Google's sitelinks advice wants anchor text, the clickable words of a link, that is "concise and relevant to the page they're pointing to."
- Key word first, so a glance down a list works: "Water heater repair", "Water heater install". NN/g calls this front-loading.
- Words, not icons alone. Visual cues such as icons should be "additional supportive elements, rather than replacing clear text labels" (NN/g, 2024).
Dropdowns and mega menus: when to use them
Use a dropdown when one item, usually Services, has more pages than the bar can hold. A mega menu is a big dropdown panel showing several groups at once, such as Repairs, Installs and Maintenance; NN/g says it "can save users time by letting them skip a level (or two)."
- Open on click or tap, not on hover only. NN/g wants "a consistent, reliable interaction pattern across devices and input modalities."
- Show a small arrow beside items that open more, or people may not know there's more.
- One level, no menu inside a menu. NN/g: a simple dropdown "works well for one-tier navigation but becomes frustrating with two tiers." For deeper groups, use a mega menu or link to a page that lists the group.
- Works with a keyboard. WCAG Level A: "All functionality of the content is operable through a keyboard interface" (W3C: 2.1.1 Keyboard). In the W3C menu tutorial, a submenu opens when the user activates the top item, not while tabbing past it.
- Hover panels stay put. A panel that opens on hover must stay open while the mouse moves onto it, and close with a key such as Escape without moving the mouse (W3C: 1.4.13 Content on Hover or Focus, Level AA).
Where should the phone number and Book button go?
Top right, as a button that looks different from the menu links, in the same place on every page. WCAG 2.2, a W3C Recommendation since October 5, 2023, added a Level A rule, Consistent Help, for contact details and contact options:
"Put help in the same place when it is on multiple pages." (W3C: What's New in WCAG 2.2)
Make it big enough to tap: WCAG 2.2 Level AA asks for targets of at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels, or enough space around smaller ones (W3C: 2.5.8 Target Size). On long pages, a sticky header, one that stays on screen as people scroll, keeps the button in reach; NN/g suggests considering one.
Does website navigation affect SEO?
Yes, through links. Your menu is the set of links Google sees on every page, and links are how it finds pages:
"Google primarily finds pages through links from other pages it already crawled." (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide)
- Real links. Google can generally crawl a link only if it's an "a" HTML element with an href attribute, a standard link with an address (Google Search Central: Link best practices). Google says most links in other formats won't be parsed, so a menu that opens pages through scripts may be missed. Ask whoever built the site.
- A path to every service page, from the menu or a page it links to. Google's sitelinks page (sitelinks are the extra links sometimes shown under your result) says:
"Create a logical site structure that is easy for users to navigate, and make sure you link to your important pages from other relevant pages." (Google Search Central: Sitelinks)
Don't expect a reshuffled menu alone to lift rankings. Google says search engines "will likely understand your pages as they are right now, regardless of how your site is organized." If an overhaul also changes page addresses, read why traffic drops after a redesign first.
Navigation on phones
NN/g's advice: "If your site has 4 or fewer top-level navigation links, display them as visible links." With more, hiding some behind a menu button (three lines, called a hamburger) is, in NN/g's words, "the only reasonable solution." In its 2016 study, phone users were 15% slower with navigation fully hidden than with some links shown beside the button. Keep Call or Book outside it.
How do I test my menu?
Ask five people before you launch it. Jakob Nielsen estimated that five testers find about 85% of usability problems (Nielsen Norman Group, 2000). A simple tree test checks the menu as a bare list, "without any visual design or content" (Nielsen Norman Group: Tree Testing, 2023):
- Write the menu as a plain list, dropdown items indented under their parent.
- Write five tasks in customer terms. NN/g warns that using the label's own words gives the answer away: ask "There's water on your basement floor. Where would you click?"
- Ask five people who don't work for you where they'd click.
- Where two or more go wrong, rename or move that item.
Test again whenever you add a service or rename a page.
After launch, a heatmap shows which items get clicked; Microsoft Clarity is "a free service forever" (Microsoft Learn: Clarity FAQ). Count Call and Book taps as key events in GA4.
Is my menu part of ADA or AODA compliance?
WCAG, the accessibility standard, covers menus. Whether it binds you depends on where you are.
- US: see ADA website compliance for what the ADA asks of a business site.
- Canada (Ontario): since January 1, 2021, a business or non-profit with 50 or more employees must make its public website meet WCAG 2.0 Level AA, except live captions and pre-recorded audio descriptions (Government of Ontario). Consistent navigation (3.2.3) and keyboard access (2.1.1) are in WCAG 2.0. Consistent Help and the 24-pixel target came with WCAG 2.2, so Ontario's rule doesn't name them.
Example
A plumbing company with 14 services
Before: Home, About, Solutions, Residential, Commercial, Resources, Blog, Careers, FAQ, Contact, on two lines on a laptop. After: Services (a panel with Repairs, Installs, Drains and sewer), Pricing, Reviews, Service area, About, and a "Call now" button. Pricing lists ranges, such as $200 to $400 USD to clear a main drain. Blog, careers and FAQ move to the footer.
A Toronto dental clinic with 60 employees
The AODA applies, so the site must meet WCAG 2.0 Level AA. Menu: Treatments, New patients, Fees and insurance, Our dentists, Contact, with "Book online" at the top right of every page. Treatments opens on click or with the Enter key, and the current page is highlighted.
FAQ
Do I need a Home link if my logo links home?
NN/g recommends both: "many users still look for an actual Home link." If space is tight, a logo linked home is the minimum.
Should I use a hamburger menu on desktop?
No. NN/g: "Do not use hidden navigation (such as hamburger icons) in desktop user interfaces."
Do I need breadcrumbs?
Only with many levels, like an online store; a few service pages rarely need them. Since January 2025, Google shows them in desktop results only.
Different for you?
- Visitors find you but don't call or book: Website not getting leads.
- Pages built only for ads, which can drop the menu: Landing page best practices.
- An online store with categories and filters: Ecommerce SEO.
- You must meet ADA or AODA rules: ADA website compliance.
- A clinic adding heatmaps or session recordings: Meta pixel and Google Analytics on a clinic website.
- A second-language version of your site: Multilingual website SEO.
- You want the menu and pages built for you: Website Agent.