Threats to Google search: where people search instead
Short answer AI chat, video and social apps, and shopping sites each take a slice of search, but Google still handles most of it. On US desktops, Google ran 73.7% of searches across 41 sites in late 2025; AI tools ran 3.2%. For local businesses, 52% of US consumers start on Google Search, and 71% use it at some point.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThreats to Google search: the four places people go instead
Four kinds of platforms pull searches away from Google. None has replaced it. Each matters to some businesses far more than others.
| Where people search instead | What they look for there | Its size today | Who should care most |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI chat (ChatGPT, Gemini app, Copilot, Perplexity) | A shortlist, a comparison, "who should I call?" | ChatGPT: 1.2 billion people a week (OpenAI, November 2026). Gemini app: one billion users (Google, October 2026) | Any business people compare before buying |
| Video and social (YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, Pinterest) | Ideas, how-tos, "show me" | YouTube used by 84% of US adults, Instagram 50%, TikTok 37% (Pew, 2025). Pinterest: 107 million monthly users in the US and Canada (Pinterest, Q3 2026) | Food, beauty, design, trades with visible results |
| Shopping sites (Amazon, Walmart, eBay) | A product to buy now | More than 250 million customers used Amazon's AI shopping assistant in 2025 (Amazon) | Anyone selling products |
| Review and local apps (Yelp, Apple Maps, Nextdoor) | A nearby business with good reviews | Grouped with others in surveys; no reliable share alone | Local service businesses |
The count that best shows the split comes from Datos, a panel of millions of US desktop computers. Across 41 sites in late 2025, Google handled 73.7% of searches. Shopping and booking sites (Amazon, Walmart, Airbnb and others) took about 10%, social networks about 5.5%, and AI tools 3.2% (SparkToro, March 2026). Phones and apps were not counted, so video and social apps are undercounted.
Is ChatGPT taking searches from Google?
Some, mostly at the "help me decide" step. ChatGPT is huge as an app but small as a search engine. In the same Datos count, Amazon, Bing and YouTube each saw more search activity than ChatGPT, and ChatGPT's share fell during 2025 (SparkToro, March 2026).
For local businesses, US survey data says the same. In BrightLocal's July 2026 survey of 1,227 US consumers:
- 8% started their last local search on an AI tool.
- 23% used one at some point in that search.
- 43% of those who started on AI went on to check Google.
- Only 18% of AI users felt ready to contact a business an AI tool named.
So AI chat builds the shortlist, and Google often confirms it. What ChatGPT reads and how to get named is in how to get ChatGPT to recommend your business. A full head-to-head is in ChatGPT search vs Google.
Are TikTok, YouTube and Instagram the new search engines?
For ideas and "show me how", yes for many people; for "call someone now", less so. In BrightLocal's survey, 9% started their last local search on social media and 30% used it at some point (BrightLocal, July 2026). Around two in five who started on social, AI, review sites or Apple Maps returned to Google before choosing.
Reach is the reason these apps matter: 84% of US adults use YouTube, 71% Facebook, 50% Instagram and 37% TikTok, and about 80% of adults 18 to 29 use Instagram (Pew Research Center, survey of 5,022 US adults, 2025). Younger customers see you there first, even when they book through Google.
Google has noticed. Its CEO said Google now handles "over 50 billion visual searches per month," and that one in five AI Mode searches uses voice, images or documents (Google, October 2026). Searching with a camera is no longer something only Pinterest and TikTok offer.
Is Amazon a threat to Google for shopping searches?
Yes, for products. In the Datos count, shopping sites took about a tenth of desktop searches, and over 70% of Amazon visitors searched on it (SparkToro, March 2026). Amazon added its own AI assistant: more than 250 million customers used it in 2025, and on May 13, 2026 Amazon renamed it from Rufus to Alexa for Shopping (Amazon).
If you sell services, not products, this one barely touches you. People don't look for a plumber or an accountant on Amazon.
Is Google losing?
Not by its own numbers or outside ones. Google says its year-over-year query growth in Q3 2026 was "the highest it's been in the last five years" (Google, October 2026). Its AI answers sit inside search itself: AI Overviews had over 2.5 billion monthly users and AI Mode over 1 billion by May 2026 (Google I/O 2026). Even after leaving Google to search elsewhere, 71% of US local searchers still used Google Search at some point (BrightLocal, July 2026).
What has changed is the click. Pew Research tracked 900 US adults in March 2025: when Google showed an AI summary, they clicked a result on 8% of visits, against 15% without one. Google's head of Search wrote:
"Overall, total organic click volume from Google Search to websites has been relatively stable year-over-year." (Google: AI in Search is driving more queries and higher quality clicks, August 2025)
Both can be true: total clicks hold steady while each AI-answered search sends fewer. The bigger threat to your traffic is Google answering on its own page, not people leaving Google. How that works is in Google search evolution.
What should a small business do about it?
Keep Google first, then add the one or two platforms your customers use before they call.
- Fix Google basics. Business Profile, reviews and clear service pages still reach most local searchers.
- Pick by business type. A restaurant or salon adds Instagram or TikTok. A product seller adds Amazon or a marketplace. A firm people compare (lawyer, accountant, contractor) checks what ChatGPT says about it.
- Ask new customers where they looked. One question at booking tells you which platform matters for you.
- Build channels no search engine controls. Email lists and referrals: see diversify traffic beyond Google.
Example
Illustrative cases with round numbers.
A bakery in Portland (US dollars)
Most new customers say they saw the cakes on Instagram, then looked up hours on Google Maps. The owner posts three photos a week and keeps her Business Profile hours right. She spends $0 on ads.
An accounting firm in Toronto (Canadian dollars)
New clients say they asked ChatGPT for "small business accountants near me" and then checked reviews on Google. The firm fixes an outdated fee page that ChatGPT quoted, and keeps C$1,000 a month on Google search ads.
A hardware store selling online
Product searches start on Amazon. The store lists its top 50 products there and keeps its own site for local pickup.
FAQ
What is the biggest threat to Google search?
Google's own AI answers, which reduce clicks to websites, matter more to most businesses than any rival. Among rivals, shopping sites take the largest share of searches (SparkToro, March 2026).
Do young people use TikTok instead of Google?
Many use it alongside Google. About half of US adults 18 to 29 go on TikTok at least once a day (Pew Research Center, 2025), but no study we found shows them dropping Google for local businesses.
Should I stop doing SEO?
No. Google still starts most local searches. See is SEO dead because of AI?
Is Bing a threat to Google?
A small one, but it feeds Copilot. See Bing Places for Business.
Different for you?
- You want one plan for Google, AI, YouTube and social: search everywhere optimization.
- Your traffic fell after AI Overviews appeared: Google AI Overviews for local businesses.
- You're comparing AI tools as a user: best AI search engines.
- You want Google and AI search handled for you: SEO & GEO Agent.