Unethical SEO practices: 14 tactics that hurt your site
Short answer Refuse any tactic meant to fool Google rather than help customers: bought links, link networks, hidden text, keyword lists, copied or mass AI pages, doorway city pages, cloaking, sneaky redirects, keywords in your Business Profile name and fake reviews. Google can demote or drop your site, and you answer for what your agency does.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callUnethical SEO practices to refuse
Every tactic below is on Google's spam policy list (Google Search Central), except number 13, which breaks Google Business Profile rules, and number 14, which breaks Google Maps rules and US federal law. The middle column is how it tends to show up in a proposal or a monthly report.
| # | Tactic | How it gets sold to you | Google's name for it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Buying links | "50 high-authority backlinks a month" | Link spam |
| 2 | Private blog networks (PBNs: a ring of sites the seller owns, made only to link to clients) | "Our in-house publisher network" | Link spam |
| 3 | Guest posts and press releases with keyword links | "Guest posting outreach", "press release distribution" | Link spam |
| 4 | Link swaps and partner pages | "Trade links with other local businesses" | Link spam |
| 5 | Keyword stuffing | "Optimized copy", a footer listing 40 towns | Keyword stuffing |
| 6 | Hidden text and links | White text on white, text pushed off-screen | Hidden text and link abuse |
| 7 | Doorway city pages | "A page for every city you serve" with only the town name swapped | Doorway abuse |
| 8 | Mass AI or template pages | "200 new pages this month" | Scaled content abuse |
| 9 | Copied or spun content | "Content rewriting", competitor pages with synonyms swapped | Scraping |
| 10 | Cloaking | Google sees one page, visitors see another | Cloaking |
| 11 | Sneaky redirects | Phone visitors sent somewhere else | Sneaky redirects |
| 12 | Buying an old domain to rank fast | "An aged domain with authority" | Expired domain abuse |
| 13 | Keywords in your Business Profile name | "Joe's Plumbing" renamed "Joe's Plumbing Best Emergency Plumber Dallas" | Breaks Business Profile name rules |
| 14 | Fake or bought reviews | "Review packages", reviews written by staff | Fake engagement (Google Maps); illegal under the FTC rule |
One line in Google's policy matters for AI search. Its spam definition includes "attempting to manipulate generative AI responses in Google Search" (Google Search Central). Text planted to sway AI answers falls under the same rules.
What is black hat SEO?
It means anything done to trick a search engine instead of earning the ranking. Google's definition of spam:
"techniques used to deceive users or manipulate our Search systems into featuring content prominently" (Google Search Central: Spam policies)
White hat is the opposite: useful pages, real reviews and links people give you because they want to. A simple test for any tactic: would you do it if Google didn't exist?
What happens if your site uses them?
Your site drops or disappears from results.
"Sites that violate our policies may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all." (Google Search Central: Spam policies)
Google catches it two ways: automated systems, and human reviewers who can issue a manual action (a penalty notice you'll see in Search Console) (Google Search Central).
Blaming the agency doesn't help:
"Ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
The Business Profile is separate. Google says "Including unnecessary information in your business name isn't permitted, and could result in the suspension of your Business Profile" (Google Business Profile Help). Unnecessary information includes service, product and location words that aren't part of your real name (same page).
Fake reviews: the tactic that is also illegal
In the US, the FTC's reviews rule took effect October 21, 2024 (Federal Register). It bans a business from writing, creating or selling reviews that misrepresent that the reviewer exists or used the service (16 CFR 465.2). It also bans paying or rewarding people for reviews that must be positive (or negative) (16 CFR 465.4), and buying fake followers or views (16 CFR 465.8).
A knowing violation can cost up to $53,088 each (Federal Register, 2025), unchanged for 2026 (Federal Register, 2026).
In Canada, the Competition Bureau warns that "Anyone who writes or permits writing reviews that give a false or misleading impression to consumers" could be liable under the Competition Act, staff reviews included (Competition Bureau).
Google Maps also bans fake engagement, including paid reviews, and removes it (Google Maps Help).
How to ask for reviews within the rules: asking for reviews.
Look-alikes that are allowed
Several honest practices resemble the banned ones. Google says so itself (Google Search Central):
| Looks like | Allowed when |
|---|---|
| Hidden text | Accordions, tabs, sliders, tooltips and screen-reader text |
| Buying links | Ads and sponsorships, if the link is marked `rel="sponsored"` or `rel="nofollow"` |
| Sneaky redirects | Moving to a new domain or merging pages |
| Doorway pages | A city page with real local content: jobs done there, local staff, local rules. See city pages for service areas |
| Mass AI pages | Policy targets pages made "for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users" (Google), not the tool. See does Google penalize AI content |
How to tell if your agency used them
Five checks an owner can run in an afternoon:
- Manual actions report in Search Console. A notice names the problem. What to do next: Google manual action.
- Ask for a list of every link they built, with the site and price. A good firm has it. Refusal is the answer.
- Press Ctrl+A (Cmd+A on a Mac) on your home page. Selected text that was invisible before is hidden text.
- Scroll to your footer and city pages. Long lists of towns, or pages that differ only by the town name, are numbers 5 and 7.
- Read your Business Profile name on Google Maps. It should match your sign and invoices, nothing more.
Before you hire, the questions that screen these sellers out are in hiring an SEO company. Which links do help a local business: backlinks for a local business.
Example
Illustrative cases. Figures are invented for the example.
A roofer's "link package"
His agency's report shows 60 new backlinks a month for $400. The list shows blogs about casinos, pets and travel, all with the anchor text "roofing company Phoenix". He stops the package, asks for the list in writing, and checks Search Console for a manual action.
A cleaning company with 90 city pages
Each page is the same 300 words with a different town name. Traffic from them is near zero. She keeps the 8 towns where she has jobs and photos, writes real content for those, and redirects the rest to her service area page.
A dentist offered "review boosting"
A vendor offers 50 five-star Google reviews for $250. Under the FTC rule, buying reviews that misrepresent real patients is illegal. She declines and adds a review link to her follow-up text instead.
FAQ
Is buying backlinks illegal?
Google's spam policy bans it unless the link is marked sponsored or nofollow. The risk Google names is lower rankings or removal from results, not a fine.
Can a competitor hurt my site with spam links?
Rarely. Google says "In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance" (Search Console Help). If you get a manual action for links you didn't build, see Google manual action.
How do I report a competitor using black hat SEO?
Google takes spam reports through its search quality user report, and says it uses them to improve spam detection (Google Search Central). Don't expect a quick, visible effect.
Do penalties ever go away?
A manual action can be lifted once you fix the problem and ask Google to review it. The steps are in Google manual action.
Different for you?
- You already see a penalty notice: Google manual action.
- Traffic fell after an update, with no notice: traffic dropped after a core update.
- Choosing an SEO now: hiring an SEO company.
- Want links that don't put you at risk: backlinks for a local business.
- Want clean SEO done and shown to you each month: SEO & GEO Agent.