Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Behavioral email segmentation: send based on what people do

Updated · 8 min read

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Behavioral email segmentation: the short version

A segment is a group of contacts on your email list that share something. In a behavioral segment, that something is an action: they clicked, visited a page, bought, booked, or went quiet. A demographic segment shares a trait instead, like city or age. Actions show what someone wants right now, so the email can match it.

Each segment is one rule: an action, a time window, and who to leave out. Starter segments that fit most businesses:

SegmentRuleWhat to send
Clicked, didn't buyClicked a service or product link in the last 14 days; no purchase or booking sinceThe answer to their likely question (price range, how it works) and a book or buy button
New customerFirst purchase or booking in the last 30 daysHow to get the most from it; a review request
Due againLast job near its usual repeat point, such as 11 months for a yearly tune-upA reminder with a booking link
Repeat customer3 or more purchases or visits in 12 monthsEarly access, a referral ask
LapsedNo purchase in 12 months or moreA reason to come back
Started, didn't finishBegan checkout or the booking form; no orderOne reminder within a day
Gone quietNo clicks, replies or purchases in 6 monthsFewer emails, then one asking if they still want them

Three things change how you use it:

Which actions should you segment on?

Money and clicks first; opens last.

ActionWhere the data comes fromHow much to trust it
Purchase, booking, paid invoiceStore, booking or job software, connected or exportedHigh: money changed hands
Quote sent, not acceptedJob or quoting softwareHigh
Reply to an emailYour inbox, tagged by handHigh, but manual
Link clicked in an emailEmail toolGood: interest in that topic
Page viewed on your siteEmail tool's site tracking, known visitors onlyGood, with gaps
Email openedEmail toolLow: inflated by Apple Mail

For a service business, the most useful action is usually the date of the last job. A plumber, dentist or bookkeeper rarely has a cart; they have a last visit.

Can you segment by who opened your emails?

Not reliably. Apple Mail has a setting called Mail Privacy Protection:

"It also prevents senders from seeing if you've opened the email message they sent you." (Apple Support: Use Mail Privacy Protection on iPhone)

Email tools still log an open, and it misleads. Mailchimp says that with this setting on, messages in Apple Mail are reported as "opened," "regardless of the contact's activity". Its "Resend to non-openers" feature won't reach those contacts, and A/B tests judged by opens "may not be accurate". Its advice: "we recommend that you focus on clicks" (Mailchimp Help: Apple Mail Privacy Protection FAQs). Klaviyo tags these opens "Apple Privacy Open" so you can keep them out of engagement rules (Klaviyo Help: How to identify iOS15 Mail Privacy Protection opens).

So define "engaged" by clicks, replies, bookings and purchases. Treat opens as a hint at most, with Apple opens filtered out if your tool allows it.

How does a website visit get tied to a person?

Through your email tool, and only for people it already knows. Klaviyo says it plainly:

"A visit or interaction with your site alone does not make a browser known." (Klaviyo Help: Getting started with Klaviyo onsite tracking)

A browser becomes known mainly when that person clicks through from one of your emails or texts, or types an email address or phone number into the tool's form. Mailchimp's page-view segments are narrower: they work on websites built with Mailchimp, with its tracking switched on, and only for visitors who subscribed from that site (Mailchimp Help: All the segmenting options).

Google Analytics can't fill the gap. Its terms bar you from passing Google information it "could use or recognize as personally identifiable information" (Google Analytics Terms of Service, section 7). It shows what groups of visitors do, not which subscriber did it. Use it to learn which pages lead to bookings: GA4 key events.

How to set up behavioral segments, step by step

  1. Pick three segments tied to revenue. For most service businesses: due again, clicked but didn't book, and lapsed. A shop might add "started checkout, didn't finish".
  2. Get the action data into your email tool. Connect your store or booking software if the email tool has an integration. If not, export a monthly file with email, last job or purchase date, and service type, and import those as contact fields.
  3. Write each rule with dates. "Last job 330 to 365 days ago, no booking since" works. "Old customers" doesn't.
  4. Say who stays out. Recent buyers stay out of the win-back email, and anyone in an active follow-up stays out of the newsletter that week.
  5. Choose automatic or monthly. Actions that go cold fast, like an unfinished checkout or a quote request, need an email sent automatically when they happen. Slow ones, like "due again", can go out once a month to a saved segment.
  6. Judge each segment by clicks, replies and bookings, against the same month last year or the email you used to send everyone. Small groups swing a lot, so judge over several sends.

Should you remove inactive subscribers?

Yes, after one last check-in. Mailbox providers notice when people ignore you:

"Sending email to users who are not reading them, or who report them as spam, will harm your delivery metrics and reputation." (Yahoo Sender Hub: Sender best practices)

Yahoo suggests "sending a reconfirmation email to inactive subscribers periodically". Define inactive by signals you can trust: no clicks, replies or purchases in 6 to 12 months. Send one email asking whether they still want yours, and stop the newsletter for those who don't answer. They stay customers in your own records.

What do the rules say about behavioral emails?

Every marketing email follows the basic rules, segmented or not: see email and text marketing rules. Four points touch segments directly.

US: an unsubscribe isn't per segment. You may offer a menu of email types, but "you must include the option to stop all marketing messages from you", and opt-outs must be honored "within 10 business days" (FTC: CAN-SPAM Act compliance guide). Someone who opts out from one segment's email leaves every marketing segment, unless your menu let them pick a narrower option.

California's privacy law applies above set sizes. The CCPA covers for-profit businesses doing business in California that have gross annual revenue of $26.625 million or more, buy, sell or share the personal information of 100,000 or more California residents or households, or earn 50% or more of revenue from selling or sharing it (California Privacy Protection Agency: FAQ). A business that meets none of the three isn't covered, unless a covered business controls it.

Canada: the purchase date sets the email window. Without express consent, Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation: the law on consent before sending commercial emails and texts to people in Canada. More lets you email based on a purchase "within the two-year period immediately before the day on which the message was sent", or an inquiry within the previous six months (CASL, s. 10(10)). Express consent has "no time limit unless the recipient withdraws" it (ISED: Getting consent to send email). So a "lapsed" segment needs a cutoff: customers past two years with no express consent drop out. An email asking for consent is itself a commercial message (CASL, s. 1(3)), so send it before the two years end. Details: CASL consent.

Quebec: notice before profiling. Anyone who collects personal information with technology able to identify, locate or profile a person must "first inform the person" of that technology and of how to switch those functions on (Quebec's Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, s. 8.1). The same section defines profiling as assessing a person's characteristics, including their "personal preferences, interests or behaviour".

Example

Illustrative cases; the numbers are invented.

An HVAC company with 2,000 past customers (USD)

Its job software exports the last service date each month. About 150 customers a month land in "last tune-up 11 to 12 months ago" and get a booking link. Anyone who clicked the "repair or replace?" link in the newsletter gets an email the next day with typical price ranges for both and a free-estimate button.

A bookkeeping firm with 600 contacts (USD)

Contacts who clicked "catch-up bookkeeping" twice in a month get a short email with a price range and a link to book a call. Those with no clicks or replies in 9 months get one "still want these?" email; the ones who don't answer stop getting the newsletter.

An online candle shop in Ontario (CAD)

First-time buyers get a care guide 7 days after delivery. Buyers whose last order was 22 months ago, and who never ticked the opt-in box, get one email asking them to subscribe before their implied consent ends at 24 months.

FAQ

What's the difference between behavioral and demographic segmentation?

Demographic segments group people by who they are: age, city, type of business. Behavioral segments group them by what they did. Good segments often combine both, such as "homeowners in one suburb who clicked the roof inspection link".

Do I need a customer data platform (CDP)?

Usually not. A CDP merges data from many systems into one profile per person. A small business with one store or booking tool can connect it straight to the email tool, or import a monthly export.

Can AI build my segments?

Some email tools predict churn risk or the next order, but they need history first. Klaviyo shows lifetime-value predictions only when "At least 500 customers have placed an order", orders arrive from a store integration or its API, and there are 180 days of order history, recent orders and some customers on 3 or more orders (Klaviyo Help: Understanding Klaviyo's predictive analytics).

How long should a segment's time window be?

As long as your buying cycle. An unfinished checkout goes cold in hours. A furnace tune-up, dental cleaning or tax return comes around every six or twelve months, so its window is months.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextEmail open rates: how to get more people to open your emailsWhy emails go unopened and the fixes, in order: Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook sender rules, list cleaning, then subject lines. Plus why open rates now mislead.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Apple Support: Use Mail Privacy Protection on iPhone
  2. Mailchimp Help: Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) FAQs
  3. Klaviyo Help: How to identify iOS15 Mail Privacy Protection opens
  4. Klaviyo Help: Getting started with Klaviyo onsite tracking
  5. Mailchimp Help: All the segmenting options
  6. Google Analytics Terms of Service
  7. Yahoo Sender Hub: Sender best practices
  8. FTC: CAN-SPAM Act, a compliance guide for business
  9. California Privacy Protection Agency: Frequently asked questions
  10. Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation, S.C. 2010, c. 23 (Justice Laws)
  11. ISED: Getting consent to send email (CASL)
  12. LégisQuébec: Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (P-39.1)
  13. Klaviyo Help: Understanding Klaviyo's predictive analytics